Showing posts with label Commonwealth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commonwealth. Show all posts

14 November 2013

If the Common Welt is to be erased...



‘Crime and punishment’ is the title of a novel.  Human society embraced the notion of punishment as a mechanism to facilitate cohesion by way of agreement or contractual obligation which turned populations into societies.  Transgressions of whatever kind and whatever magnitude subverts the contract and punishment was and is thought to obtain adherence to agreement.  Threat of punishment then stops rupture.  If crime goes undetected, that’s a leaking that might result in a lot of things, laws included, going down the tube.  If crime goes unpunished it emboldens those who find reason to transgress.  All this is true of even the most rudimentary social organization such as a sports club as well as larger collectives such as multilateral gatherings with complex rules of association. 


Just the other day, British Foreign Secretary William Hague announced that Kenyans tortured by British colonial forces during the Mau Mau uprising will receive payouts totaling 20 million pounds.  Thousands of people were killed during the revolt against British rule.  The victims cannot be brought back to life and most if not all of the perpetrators of genocide are now dead.  On the other hand in the affairs between states or countries the violence done to collectives by those operating in the name of other collectives call for collective compensation by way of punishing those guilty of crime.  In Britain’s case, the living have benefited from their ancestors’ handiwork which of course cost and continues to cost those whose ancestors received the blood-worth of that very handiwork.  ‘It happened a long time ago,’ is a cop-out objection for the past is always past, whether we are talking of yesterday, the day before or one hundred years earlier. 


Apology is a good thing, but we’ve not seen any of that.  Hague, speaking on Kenya, stated that the British government recognizes that Kenyans were subject to torture, regrets the abuse and understands that they marred Kenya’s progress towards independence.  No mention of how Kenya came to lose independence in the first place.  If he were speaking of Sri Lanka, would Hague say that the British violated the agreement signed with the Kandyan Chieftans and ‘recognize’ that that very act, complemented by a butchery replicated in other countries that are now members of the Commonwealth ‘marred progress towards independence’ to the tune of 133 years? 


Talk, though, is cheap and cannot be banked.  If saying ‘sorry’ would do, then all legal systems would degenerate to the ‘give-take’ of Catholic Confessionary.  Anyone, then, could get away with ‘It was God’s will, His ways are not our ways and it is not ours to question Him’.  The British courts won’t accept that and neither should any other member state of the Commonwealth.  

Statue of Tara ferreted away by Governor Brownrigg

The reverse transaction is not possible in full.  The true value that was extracted and the true cost of the damage done cannot be ascertained accurately.  How does one cost the erasure of a culture and destruction of ways of life, for example?  Do we know how much of value was extracted from slaves, over and above the costs of dislocation, the violence associated with slavery and the trauma that entire communities were subjected to?  Has anyone kept count of the resources that were extracted and shipped ‘home’; the gold, diamonds, sapphires and other precious stones, the ivory, the spices, the timber?  Never mind their true value can anyone make a complete list of the items that were robbed?   



Still, fourteen Caribbean nations are getting ready to sue the United Kingdom (and also France and the Netherlands) for reparations over ‘the lingering legacy of the Atlantic slave trade’.  The exact amount demanded has not been specified, but it has been noted that Britain paid 20 million pounds (equivalent to 200 billion pounds today!) to British planters in the Caribbean in 1834, i.e. the time of ‘emancipation’.  Britain may point to roads, railways and other ‘development’, but all that was built by local labor, funded by illegal taxes and for more than a century only facilitated the extraction of resources.  The British, in addition to the butchery, destroyed temples, set fire to countless and invaluable Buddhist manuscripts and shipped out countless artifacts.


So let’s talk of loot now.  A few days ago, Yale University in Connecticut decided to return to Peru a collection of antiquities taken from the Inca site of Machu Picchu almost one hundred years ago.  Richard Burger who has been in charge of these items for 30 years says that the situation is different from classic repatriation because it was not about stolen goods but a contract dispute; things were not clandestinely dug up’. 

 
Mask from Nigeria
Yale has a case. Barely.  Britain does not.  ‘A catalogue of antiquities and other cultural objects from Sri Lanka (Ceylon) abroad,’ is the title of a book by P.H.D.H. De Silva, published in 1974.  It lists a considerable set of known artifacts stolen from this island.  There are over 15,000 items listed.  The loot it seems has ended up in 23 countries and 140 holding facilities.  The vast majority are in Britain.  Bristol, Cambridge, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Berkshire, Leicester, Liverpool, London, Sheffield, and Windsor all have ‘Little pieces of Ceylon’ so to speak.  All stolen goods.  For antique and historical value, each and every amulet, the tiniest statuette, the most fragile manuscript with hardly legible lettering, is priceless. 


What was common in all this wealth and all the wealth plundered from all Commonwealth countries?  Theft! 



That’s a crime, ladies and gentlemen.  Sure, the present day custodians did not pilfer anything.  They are not answerable to crimes committed by their ancestors.  They may not suffer guilt on account from benefitting from the sacking of cities.  But there is no getting around the fact that possessing stolen goods is a crime.  Punishable.  And on the other side of the equation there is a people, a nation that demands that stolen goods be returned, even if the thieves got away with murder and were duly unburdened of whatever ghosts spawned by wrongdoing by death decades ago.                             


After all these years of lies and self-delusion, perhaps it is now time to sober up.  There was never a commonwealth.  There was never a sharing of wealth.  There was wealth accumulation through outright looting.  We can let bygones be bygones and move on, but if that is to happen, dignity has to be restored.  Some will have to hang their heads in shame but that’s just necessary but not sufficient condition for friendship. 


Collection centers will duly be set up in all member countries of the ‘Commonwealth’.  That is easily arranged.  Return the loot.  It’s as simple as that.


That’s a first step.  We’ll talk reparations later.                                                                                    

 msenevira@gmail.com

14 October 2013

How big is CHOGM anyway?



Canada will not send a high level delegation to the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM), Prime Minister Stephen Harper has announced. Canada’s Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird, regurgitating the anti-Sri Lanka noises emanating from Canada, has explained why.  The Sri Lankan Government, for its part, has conveyed disappointment, pointing out that Canada was isolated in its decision ‘as the majority of Commonwealth countries were siding with Sri Lanka’. 

Canada’s logic shows its abysmal understanding of Sri Lanka and betrays myopia and selectivity in censure as well as a shocking readiness to let domestic electoral issues determine approach to multilateral affairs. That country has a long and sordid history of human rights violation and has been complicit in multiple crimes against humanity, aiding and abetting the regional ‘big brother’, the United States of America as well as its ‘mother country’, Britain, to whose Queen, Harper, Baird and the rest of Canada genuflect as per constitutional requirement. 

Although Minister of External Affairs G.L. Peiris has stated that in the Commonwealth, a voluntary association of sovereign states, no country had the right to sit in judgment of others.  The legality and niceties aside, assessment and judgment are part and parcel of CHOGM politics. Indeed, if ‘judgment’ is taken away from things associated with the Commonwealth it would amount to an erasure of the plunder and genocide that is the history common to the member states. It pre-empts, one could argue, moves to secure reparations.  Worse, Peiris’ statement implies that Sri Lanka has to stop short of criticizing Canada (or anyone else), on judgements and other things. So let Canada criticize and be duly taken to task. 

What is more disturbing is the readiness on the part of the Government to read participation as ‘siding with Sri Lanka’.  That would be myopic too. 

Agreement on a venue for a gathering such as CHOGM in no way suggests that participants, by the act of presence, sides with host country on all issues relevant as well as irrelevant to the confab.  Indeed if every country were to work their way through a check list of the much talked of ‘core values’ of the Commonwealth and assessed all other members against it, we would not have a CHOGM, not in Colombo and not anywhere else either. The flip side has also got to be understood; participation does not amount to a support for the particular country on all counts by other participating country.

The fact of the matter is that the only commonality is the fact of invasion and attendant violence and theft.  The meeting itself amounts to recognition and celebration of a one-time global thug. There’s no economic cooperation scripted into CHOGM and in a global context where such arrangement make sense only regionally and not on account of shared suffering the Commonwealth is nothing more nothing less than an event or moment for verbal sparring, before, during and after such meetings.

If Peiris or anyone else believes that the countries taking part in CHOGM will side with Sri Lanka when small-minded, ill-informed rogue states of the international community point fingers, they are dead wrong.  Harper may believe that boycotting will yield returns in elections, but that would be a long shot, given the stronger claims that his opponents have when it comes to ‘listening’ to pro-LTTE or anti-Sri Lanka Tamil voters in that country.  If, as Peiris says, the rest of the Commonwealth turns up in Sri Lanka, it will be an international snub for Canada.  Sri Lanka can crow about it, but crowing will not secure votes in Geneva or elsewhere when judgment is passed on this country. 

So what does one make of this CHOGM, then?  Well, when Prince Charles married Lady Diana, someone wrote to the editor of a newspaper something on the following lines: ‘I heard that a few years ago Prince Charles had chosen to sleep on the plane during a brief stopover in Colombo; all things considered, I think I will sleep through the Royal Wedding.’

CHOGM, then, is ‘one of those things’ that does very little; so little that it would be folly to make too much out of it. Either way.
 

12 September 2012

Nothing to cheer about the Common Welt

The 58th Commonwealth Parliamentary Conference is currently underway in Colombo.  Over 850 parliamentarians and other officials from 54 countries are participating in this annual event.  They are to discuss at length various issues relevant to the ‘Commonwealth’ (CW), although resolution on key matters must await the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting. 

Glancing through the stated ‘Beliefs and Values’ of the CW, one is struck by a stunning absence.  Here’s the legend: ‘Beyond the ties of history, language and institutions, members are united through the association’s values of democracy, freedom, peace, the rule of law and opportunity for all’.  No mention of the one, true, abiding commonality: the common welt.  To elaborate, this refers to the ridge or bump on the cultural, physical and societal skin of nations caused by colonial lash and blow or by an allergic reaction to colonial presence in all its numerous forms.  This, more than anything, is the common bind that gives reason for periodic gatherings. 
The values are found in their breach in the welt-giver and in the welt-receiver in local engagement as well as engagement in international affairs.  In the name of democracy, countries are invaded and plundered.  That’s not in the colonial past but the post-colonial present.  In the name of freedom, bombs are dropped, enemies named, captured, tortured and killed.  The rule of law is a notion reduced to the imposition of will by the powerful, either using threat of attack or threat of pulling the rug from under the feet of nations conveniently tagged ‘rogue’ in the form of sanctions.  As for opportunity for all, it is a wish that is terribly at odds with the fixations of capitalism. 

The CW, however, periodically toss around these lovely words and notions, delude themselves and/or delude the respective populations that these values make sense, while at the same time operating as though the common welt which clearly overrides all other markers (economic, political and social etc.) has left no scars and indeed that the whipping has stopped.  The sun may have set on the British Empire, but Britain certainly has not woken up to the fact.  Instead, it has found comfort in playing side-kick to its world conquering successor, the United States of America. 

The global political economy is made of processes that commonalities such as welts and subjugated histories just cannot contain.  While regional gatherings, such as SAARC, for purely geographical reasons, make sense in terms of trade and cultural exchange (where there is commonality as opposed to the wide disparities one finds among the welt-ridden nations), the binding power of the Commonwealth is palpably thin.  The only thing it seems to reinforce is the fact of subjugation and the only tangible outcome is a mild ego boost to the conqueror, by the simple fact of a memory-upgrade of a ruling time, which, on the flip side was a time of rape, theft, murder, plunder, desecration and other crimes against humanity.
The other major absence is the total aversion to mentioning the one tangible avenue for correcting historical injustice: the compensation by returning loot. 

The class of locals who were consoled by tidbits and other crumbs from the colonial plate would point to ‘benefits’ such as roads, schools and hospitals of course.  On the other hand, roads and railways, while facilitating the transport of what was plundered, were built using local labor and taxes collected from subjugated populations.  Speaking strictly about Sri Lanka, every region had 7 types of physicians, temples were schools and the scholarship and literature produced by them (long before the British set up ‘schools’ to produce loyal human resources necessary to upkeep the plunder) is of no less value to any scholarship or writing anywhere in the world.  Our ancestors saw tree and not timber, animal and not game, community and not selfish individual.  One could go on enumerating but the point is clear: we lost far, far, far more than we gained.  We need not say thank you.  And we need not act ‘grateful’. 

The Commonwealth Parliamentary  Conference may or may not mention ‘loot’ and ‘welt’, but if these words don’t come up then let it be because of decency and civilization that always existed and not because we’ve internalized the biggest colonial lie: ‘English Decency’.

 

06 June 2012

So when will the Common Thief compensate?

[For two years, beginning in September 2009, I wrote a column for the Daily News.  It was called 'The Morning Inspection' and appeared in print 6 days of the week, except for the odd occasion when I was indisposed or didn't have access to a computer or the internet and during a few weeks long hiatus due to an unwarranted 'huff' on my part at the Editor not carrying a particular piece.  I wrote close to 400 articles for the Daily News before I joined 'The Nation' as its Editor.  Now, as The Nation readies to become a daily publication, I've 'revived' the Morning Inspection (in our trial runs) and hope to make it a regular feature once we launch the daily paper. Here's the first piece.] 


There’s a Commonwealth story that I often find reason to re-tell.  It’s a conversation that took place in the University of Peradeniya at a conference on Commonwealth Literature.

People were talking about Derek Walcott, who had just won the Nobel Prize for Literature and commonwealth literature in general.  A friend of mine, a Yaka if anything, whispered to me, ‘they’ll never understand that there never was a common wealth, that we only had a common thief, and talking about it won’t get us back the loot’.  I jotted this observation on a piece of paper and passed it to Dr. Arjuna Parakrama, who responded ‘it’s not all black and white’.  That observation was relayed to my Yaka friend, who said ‘some things are black and white and if we don’t recognize it, it would all be f****** grey!’
All this happened almost twenty years ago, and it could have been a conversation that had taken place 2 centuries ago and one which could be as fresh today.  The insults directed at the victims by the looters come in various forms but in predictable regularity, decades after the thugs were reduced to being yes-persons of whoever happens to live in that notorious white house in Washington DC. 

The President of Sri Lanka, Mahinda Rajapaksa, was due to deliver the keynote address at the morning sessions of the Commonwealth Economic Forum on Wednesday June 6, 2012.  The Commonwealth Business Council, which organized the event, is reported to have issued the following statement: ‘After careful consideration the morning sessions of the Forum on Wednesday 6th of June have been cancelled and will not take place. The event will therefore commence with lunch at 1300hrs followed by the originally planned afternoon sessions beginning at 1400hrs.’

As I write (Wednesday, 12.30 pm, Sri Lanka time), it is still not known whether the organizers have struck off the keynote address from the agenda as well. 
It is hard to imagine that the event was organized in a hurry, considering the profiles of those invited to participate.  It is speculated that the decision was made following protests by groups that heavily sided with the terrorist outfit called the LTTE.  It is no secret also that Britain, as per directions from Washington, was at the forefront of moves to censure Sri Lanka at the Human Rights Council in Geneva last March.  Leaders of that country, it is apparent, are yet to come to terms with the fact that Mahinda Rajapaksa refused to blink when Britain (as directed by the USA, clearly) pushed to halt the offensive against the LTTE.

So was this an accident of some sort?  Was it, for example, a decision prompted by the organizers being unable to find enough chairs?  Was some irreparable damage done to the sound system of the particular room where the event was to take place?  Have the people in that island on which the sun set a long, long, long time ago taken to and taken the streets from the corporate thugs who along with their minions in the Government impoverish them?  Did President Rajapaksa back off, citing a throat infection or after determining that there is absolutely no point wasting his breath on people who can only hear their corporate and political masters or themselves?  We don’t know.
What we do know is what we’ve learnt to recognize over 500 years of being treated as though we owe something to some European thieves who believed they were civilized and that they had discovered us: a snub.  The target may have been Mahinda Rajapaksa and that cannot have been on account of displeasure at his role in eliminating the threat of terrorism and the manner in which it was done, for I cannot imagine the same courtesy being accorded to Ranil Wickremesinghe whose culpability in the deliberate murder of unarmed citizens (not armed terrorists) is well known.  The target may have been Mahinda Rajapaksa, but the snub is for all Sri Lankans. 

Not too long ago, Isreal threatened to leave the UNHRC on account of repeated censure for known, proven crimes against humanity in Gaza.  Israel, some may argue, can afford to thumb its nose, since it has a blank cheque book from Washington DC.  Sri Lanka can’t afford to do anything of the kind, some may say.  But this is not the UN.  It is a thing called ‘Commonwealth’, presided over by a bunch of thugs.  This is also about economic issues, true, but it is not that we are talking about a common commonwealth currency or a Commonwealth Free Trade Agreement, keeping in mind that such agreements are wrought by arm-twist and designed to favour the powerful. 
The Commonwealth today it nothing but a tool for a has-been empire to feel good about the good old days of butchery and thieving.  It has the added advantage for war criminals to point fingers at those they’ve labeled ‘bad boys’.  It is a forum for holier-than-thou posturing by unrepentant violators of human rights about what wonderful things ‘human rights’ are. 

It is not a forum where Mahinda Rajapaksa or any other representative of any nation robbed by England can tell the thieves where to get off or when.  It’s a place, simply put, only worth visiting to say one thing, loud and clear: ‘COMPENSATE!’


[Also posted in 'Editor's Blog', www.nation.lk]