Showing posts with label Kurahan Satakaya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kurahan Satakaya. Show all posts

25 November 2019

Gotabaya Rajapaksa can go for ‘Yahapalanaya PLUS’



The term Yahapalanaya came into currency in the run up to the 2015 Presidential Election. It is the Sinhala version of ‘Good Governance’.  Although the term itself was not used, notions such as transparency, accountability and fair representations have been around for a long time.  

Perhaps it is the newness of the term that made it difficult to grasp or rather made for flippant usage. There was very little time between the rise of the term and the election anyway. It wasn’t as though it was the result of an organic process made of lengthy debate across social strata. Its quick demise of course was largely due to the violation of basic tenets by the advocates themselves. 

Yahapalanaya, then, as a brand, has run its course. The idea though persists. Indeed, it is all there in the Buddhist scriptures and even in the Grade 9 Buddhism text book. The problem in application was largely a product of ignorance and disinterest. 

There was ‘good’ and there was ‘governance’. The generous view would be that the yahapalanists really wanted good, decent and honorable people running things. The way things unfolded, however, we have to conclude that ’good’ seems to have been understood less as persons and processes endowed with integrity as ‘on our side.’  ‘Our governance’ would have been closer to the truth with respect to compulsion, but then again that’s not exactly a truth that can be marketed in an election campaign.  

Today, close to five years after that experiment has gone down the tube. The word itself has taken on a cuss-word persona. In retrospect, if one were to break the term down to key constituent elements and assess performance against them, the previous government wouldn’t score well. And yet, we must revive both ‘good’ and ‘governance’ because there is nothing really wrong with those words.

First and foremost, there’s one element of ‘good’ that seems to have been lost on the Yahapalanists: effectiveness. That quality obviously is closely related to ‘governance’. Take it out and you get ‘our people’ and ‘lack of governance’ or even ungovernability.  That gives us a clue to where the newly elected president, Gotabaya Rajapaksa can take the country during his tenure.  

Gotabaya Rajapaksa inherited a mess on all counts. However, the fathers and mothers of that mess do not belong only to the previous regime. Starting from Independence, we’ve had good intention and bad plans.  

We threw the baby out with the bathwater when a post-independence language policy was formulated and implemented. Politics of expedience framed all engagements when it came to communal and religious issues. The public service was first vilified and then nullified by ‘experts’ on development, both foreign (through conditionalities imposed on aid) and local (‘brained’ to toe the line of ‘theorists’ intent on furthering capital interests). Whereas an independent and competent public service was indispensable in nation-building, public servants were made subservient to politicians. Political appointments, rewarding the incompetent, sidelining the best minds and a steady deterioration followed. 

Nationalization was not necessarily a bad idea, but this too was scuttled by politicization. As for constitutional reform, it was marked by tinkering and, once again, political expediency.  It was never about strengthening representation or institutional arrangements with a view to creating a robust state. Successive governments saw it as a tool to further the interests of the particular party or coalition. 

It’s a long list of wrongs which Gotabaya, if he so wishes, has to fix. His political friends are not exactly angels and are no more devilish than those who fall into the category ‘political enemy’. In other words, he has set out to take the country forward in less than ideal conditions. And yet, his initial moves have been quiet, determined and effective.  A doer is how he was described. ‘Work!’ Is what he promised he would do and what he requested that his voters do as well. 

It is not that others before him promised sloth, but the doing has been typically accompanied by frill and brag. Gotabaya in these early days has demonstrated that he is a bit different. One notes that he didn’t claim to be simple, but simple he has been. Quiet he is, but this doesn’t mean that he is silent. One doesn’t have to shout to announce presence and one doesn’t have to scream to get things done.

A good example would be the helmet story that is doing the rounds in social media. For years, certain communities in certain parts of the country essentially gave the proverbial finger to the law in the form of refusing to abide by the requirement for motorcyclists to wear helmets. Immediately after Gotabaya Rajapaksa became President, lo and behold, helmet sales in Kattankudy and Matale are reported to have gone up exponentially.  

Why, though?

Well, one can surmise that his opponents painted him as a brute, a devil, a heartless enforcer. That ‘billa’ if you will has come to haunt people because there is a tendency to believe one’s own propaganda after a while. It is not the best way to get people to abide by the law, but if we focus on effect and little else, we can say ‘it’s a good thing, all things considered’.

In the first week of his presidency Gotabaya Rajapaksa can be said to have set the pace, clearly articulated behavioral expectations and led by example. No frills. No grandiose celebrations. No show of force. Just intent. 

It is not that Gotabaya Rajapaksa wants to abandon everything his brother and former president (and now Prime Minister) Mahinda Rajapaksa stands for. He is clearly in tune with his brother’s brand of nationalism. It has also obvious that he rode to power largely on the immense popularity of his brother. And yet, he is also himself; we have ‘Gota’ as Mahinda’s brother AND himself. It would have been very easy for him to piggyback on the popularity-factor in the matter of post-election consolidation. All he had to do was to wear a kurahan satakaya. He didn’t. He did things his way. Quietly. Without fanfare. 

And yet, there’s something about the kurahan satakaya that is not easily dismissible and not just for reasons of expedience. We know that it is a metaphor amenable to multiple application. It is also, like yahapalanaya, something that has been tarnished due to excesses of all kinds by those associated with it politically (and not so much ideologically and culturally). 

Fourteen years ago, just after Mahinda Rajapaksa was elected president for the first time, I reflected on the kurahan satakaya. The following were my conclusions: 

The kurahan saatakaya is and was essentially defined by what it is not, namely the tie-coat world as one would put it in “Sinhala”. It was the perfect “other” to everything represented by the (adopted) children of the colonial project, the privileges they enjoyed and the elitism they fostered and fought for tooth and nail perhaps never as ferociously as in this election. Still, it was not merely a matter of style, preferred clothing, notions of fashion etc. People can vote for any number of reasons but it would be safe to say that few would have factored in the choice of dress in their decision. It was what these things represented and the extent to which the avowed representation was manifest in program and ideological bent that settled the issue, I believe.

All of the above in one way or another found their way into the rhetoric of the Mahinda Rajapaksa regime. Rhetoric. That’s the word. I was skeptical and over the course of the next 14 years my apprehensions were proven to be justifiable. Back then, however, in that very note I expressed a wish:

If there comes a day where every single institution insists that all employees wear a kurahan saatakaya we would still not have won if they continue to have tie-coat heads. On the other hand, if these institutions continue to insist that employees wear Western attire, replete with tie and coat, but the people inside these clothes have a kurahan saatakaya frame of mind, then the November 17 decision would most certainly have produced something we can be proud of as a nation. I humbly submit that this is not impossible.

This brings us back to yahapalanaya or rather another element which the Yahapalanists missed or were ignorant of or due to world view and ideological preference were so ready to rubbish that there was no way it could have made its way into the yahapalana discourse. They understood ‘good’ in a very narrow way. They understood ‘governance’ as ‘our people being in power, never mind what they do or don’t do’. They did not understand the kurahan satakaya for what it truly represents or ought to have represented. For this they cannot be totally blamed for it was the overriding symbol of a regime they opposed for good, bad and silly reasons.  Nevertheless, if we want yahapalanaya back, it has to be scripted into the politics of the Gotabaya Rajapaksa presidency.

Gotabaya 'wore' the kurahan satayaka during the time he was Secretary, Ministry of Defence and Urban Development. He 'wore' it during the election campaign. He 'wore' it in his swearing-in ceremony. He is 'wearing' it now as he goes about the business of running a country in a period of political transition. He wears it without wearing it. 

It seems, going strictly by what we’ve seen over the last couple of years, i.e. his preparation to contest and the campaign itself, and during his first days as President, that Gotabaya Rajapaksa has a good sense of ‘good,’ and ‘governance’. He has added two things: effectiveness (simple directives that are pragmatic) and a strong and yet not-in-your-face allegiance to the kurahan satakaya in the best sense of the term, i.e. sans the chest-beating nationalism associated with his brother’s term in office and, sadly, in the election campaign of his principal rival, Sajith Premadasa.

Gotabaya Rajapaksa is well poised to deliver Yahapalanaya Plus. At this point, in the immediate aftermath of his victory, it wouldn’t be out of place to wish him the protection of the Noble Triple Gem. 


10 February 2015

Saatakakaranaya: the right and wrong way

Five years ago, a few days after Mahinda Rajapaksa was re-elected President, the following article was published in the 'Daily News' (February 5, 2010).  It refers to another article on the same lines published in the 'Daily Mirror' in December 2005, a few weeks after he was first elected President, 'In search of the kurahan saatakaya'.  Today, a few weeks after Mahinda Rajapaksa was defeated, it would be good to revisit by way of assessing what went wrong, what needed to be done but was not, what had to be avoided but was embraced etc. For those who don't know the term, 'Saatakaya' is a long piece of cloth draped around the neck and one which came to be associated with the Rajapaksa presidency.  

No girl is like her father and I know girls whose lifestyles are quite unlike like those of their fathers nor in tune with the kind of lifestyles their fathers’ advocated or championed.  I know a girl whose father was a lyricist, a self-confessed godaya who took pride in the fact. She, on the other hand, was educated in Colombo and is quite the sophisticated young urbanite and in dress, manner and language very different to her father.  I have heard a few disparaging comments consequently but she told me one day that they had got it all wrong and had never understood her father

‘He may have liked a particular kind of lifestyle but there was one thing that was important to him: he wanted to be who he was and he was proud of who he was.  This is what I learnt from him and his life.’ 

If there is anything that has acquired iconic status in Sri Lanka over the past 5 years it is the kurahan saatakaya.  Today this simple matter of a piece of cloth around the neck is symbol of loyalty to the President and the Government as well as a wardrobe accessory that has become quite popular.  This morning (February 4, 2010), watching briefly the Independence Day celebrations on television, I wondered whether we as a nation have missed the point of the kurahan saatakaya and the point made by its most visible icon-bearer, Mahinda Rajapaksa by the very fact of wearing it.

This is what I saw.  I saw two presenters, on Rupavahini, one speaking in Sinhala and one in Tamil, in full national costume but draped in saatakas.  It smacked more of loyalty to party and Mahinda Rajapaksa than to country or President for party is not state and person is not president.  It made me recall a far more incongruous usage of the saataka.  This was just after S.B. Dissanayake was thrown in jail for contempt of court by Sarath N Silva.  His supporters organized a demonstration and satyagraha in protest at Town Hall.  The organizers had made the participants, especially those on the ‘satyagrahing’ stage, wear saatakas.  They were not kurahan-coloured of course; yellow and black if I remember right.  The logic escaped me then and I still cannot put a finger on it.  It seemed incongruous then and seems so now as well. 

Mahinda Rajapaksa is not Mr. Perfect.  He is in many ways Mr. Ordinary and that’s not an insult but a compliment.  There is one ‘extraordinary’ aspect to the man, though.  He is not only aware of where he came from he is proud of the fact and draws strength from it.  And this, more than anything else, is what his detractors just cannot suffer.  Had he been the nobody who became a somebody in the manner in which the nobody-Senanayakes became somebody-Senanayakes or the nobody-Wijewardenas became somebody-Wijewardenas few would find fault with him, but alas, he was Mahinda Rajapaksa from Medamulana in 1970 and is more or less the same Medamulane Mahinda Rajapaksa 40 years later. 

The challenge is two-fold for the nation and those who admire the President. First, the need to resist being his clones and instead being themselves, conscious of who they are, where they come from, who their parents are, what their values are etc etc and being proud and not ashamed of all that, preferably not because it is impossible to become a Senanayake-somebody, for instance, but because that is possible but not desired.

The second and more important challenge is to understand that the kurahan saatakaya is not wardrobe accessory but metaphor. This means that the important thing is not to wear it in the manner of mimicry, but to internalize all the important things it symbolizes (yes, there are unimportant and not very laudatory things it represents, we must acknowledge). 

In early December 2005, a couple of weeks after Mahinda Rajapaksa was elected President for the first time, I wrote a piece to the Daily Mirror titled ‘In search of the kurahan saatakaya’ (you can google the title along with my name and find it on the internet).

I argued then in the following manner: The kurahan saatakaya is and was essentially defined by what it is not, namely the tie-coat world as one would put it in “Sinhala”. It was the perfect “other” to everything represented by the (adopted) children of the colonial project, the privileges they enjoyed and the elitism they fostered and fought for tooth and nail 
perhaps never as ferociously as in this election.

The project, then, I agued, was to ‘establish the validity and practicality of the kurahan saatakaya in all things subject to the caveat that there is nothing to say that the tie-coat universe has nothing to offer to us.’

What I said then is still valid and if we haven’t come too far part of the reason is that we’ve been a nation under subjugation for over 500 years and part of the reason is we have been lazy and intellectually and ideologically slow. 

There are I think two kinds of saatakafication or saatakakaranaya. The first, the kind of cloning exemplified by the two TV presenters (the fault of sycophantic producers and other superiors, I am sure). It doesn’t take us anywhere.  The second is that of the lyricist’s daughter.  This is how I wrote the difference 4 years ago and I believe it is still valid.

If there comes a day where every single institution insists that all employees wear a kurahan saatakaya we would still not have won if they continue to have tie-coat heads. On the other hand, if these institutions continue to insist that employees wear Western attire, replete with tie and coat, but the people inside these clothes have a kurahan saatakaya frame of mind, then the November 17 decision would most certainly have produced something we can be proud of as a nation. I humbly submit that this is not impossible.

Here’s the question for the nation and the citizens in the coming months and years (and their entire lifetimes, why not!): ‘Do you want to wear a saatakaya and if so how would you like to wear it?’



Malinda Seneviratne is the Editor-in-Chief of 'The Nation' and can be reached at msenevira@gmail.com.

10 May 2014

The apparent opposition and the real opposition

President Mahinda Rajapaksa knows better than most how to make the best out of a bad situation.  He showed once again what an astute politician he is on May Day when he turned things around after key members of the ruling coalition declined to support what has been dubbed the ‘Casino Bill’.  He said that there is room in the Government for dissent.  More importantly he said that things had come to a point where the only discernible opposition was already within the United People’s Freedom Alliance. 

Now, given his readiness to embrace anyone and everyone, the UPFA certainly looks like a massive bedroom housing strange bedfellows. One would expect this to be a recipe for friction, defection and eventual collapse.  After being in power for more than a decade it is an indictment on the sad state of the opposition that regime-hating commentators have been reduced to clinging to the casino-opposition as evidence of fissure leading to inevitable regime-collapse. 

So far, the UPFA has survived ‘regime-fatigue’, international pressure and regular own-goals at all levels.  If Ranil Wickremesinghe’s biggest weakness, the fact that he has no close friends, is also his biggest strength; Mahinda’s biggest strength, the fact that he has many friends, is also his biggest weakness.  In the play of strengths and weaknesses, so far, Mahinda Rajapaksa has prevailed.  The negatives have not translated to a massive swing to the opposition.  It seems, instead, that contrary to the usual trend of regime-displeasure translating into default-support for the opposition, the lack of a credible opposition reduces the people to back the regime according to a ‘known-devil-is-better’ logic.  As a three-wheel driver recently summed up, ‘api bena bena aanduwatama chande denava’ (we continue to vote for the government even as we curse it). 

This state of affairs, this strange benefitting from the non existence of a default option, is clearly not sustainable.  Perhaps the ‘internal opposition’ is a relatively safe safeguard against collapse.  But is that the only ‘opposition’ to Mahinda Rajapaksa?

A few weeks after Mahinda Rajapaksa was elected President in 2005, in an article titled ‘In search of the kurahan saatakaya’ I made some observations on the challenges he would be confronted with.  The following are some extracts:

‘The kurahan saatakaya is and was essentially defined by what it is not, namely the tie-coat world as one would put it in “Sinhala”. It was the perfect “other” to everything represented by the (adopted) children of the colonial project, the privileges they enjoyed and the elitism they fostered and fought for tooth and nail perhaps never as ferociously as in this election. Its broadest possible articulation covers much political, cultural, economic and philosophical terrain, at least in aspiration if not in concrete ground-reality terms.

‘Rajapakse obviously understands that in real political terms his hard earned victory on November 17 only resulted in the kurahan saatakaya just scratching the politico-cultural edifice it challenged. In this sense it was a very small victory. The 
tie-coat, to use that convenient though not inappropriate short-hand, hangs around the necks of every institution, the vast majority of state officials, and the thinking of important sections of the most influential players in the economy, the hegemonic cultural drives and indeed the dominant ideological and philosophical frames of reference. The difference is that the kurahan saatakaya has executive power and as such has the potential to reform the politico-cultural-ideological edifice. The battle, then, has moved from the electoral register to the larger and more complex terrain of institutions, territories where Mahinda Rajapakse is at a distinct disadvantage.

‘The establishment suffered a rude shock, true, but only the utterly naĂŻve can expect it to lie down and die on account of that particular poke in the behind. The establishment does not see a 
kurahan saatakaya. It sees an amuda lensuwa or loin cloth and it is a gaze of derision, a looking-down-the-nose, something that should be out of sight, mind and the face of the earth. The establishment operated in according to a by-any-means-necessary logic in trying to defeat Rajapakse and will operate in the same vein in trying to bring him down. The establishment knows the ins and outs of the system and is deeply entrenched too. All mechanisms available for subversion will be employed, rest assured.’

As of now, it appears that the battle between the kurahan saatakaya and the tie-coat is not going in favor of the former. When it comes to policy, the latter has prevailed. It is only the kurahan saatakaya of his natural ways that allows the President to retain mass support.  Within him, then, is the true opposition. The one moment when the kurahan saatakay prevailed was during the operations to defeat terrorism. On that occasion it was not the ‘tie-coats’ that stood by him but those of the kurahan-saataka ideological bent.  Such people have been marginalized or even evicted from relevant circles in the matter of policy formulation.
Nine years ago, I made the following observation:

If there comes a day where every single institution insists that all employees wear a kurahan saatakaya we would still not have won if they continue to have tie-coat heads. On the other hand, if these institutions continue to insist that employees wear Western attire, replete with tie and coat, but the people inside these clothes have a kurahan saatakaya frame of mind, then the November 17 decision would most certainly have produced something we can be proud of as a nation. I humbly 
submit that this is not impossible.


That day has not arrived, clearly.  It has not arrived because the arrival upon which Mahinda Rajapaksa’s political future depends on is being detained.  Detained by Mahinda Rajapaksa himself.  That’s the true opposition.  He cannot deal with it the way he deals with the ‘visible opposition’ but deal with it he must.  His future and that of the UPFA depends on it.  

In search of the kurahan saatakaya

[This was written in December 2005 for the Daily Mirror, a few weeks after Mahinda Rajapaksa was elected President. It outlines what I considered to be his principal challenges.  I believe it is a good re-read base from which to assess performance since this is election time]

If something new entered the lexicon of local politics in the course of the run-up to the last Presidential election, it is the kurahan saatakaya, the piece of cloth that came to symbolize Mahinda Rajapakse.

On the plus side it became the metaphoric rallying point to all those for whom nation and national identity were too important to be subsumed by the sterile economic in this election. Indeed there were many who saw the kurahan saatakaya as a metaphor amenable to multiple application, so much so that even the economy could be wrapped, so to speak, in that elegant piece of fabric.

I have no doubt that we have not heard the last of the kurahan saatakaya even though it has done its work in terms of idiomatic application, at least in the first round of the game of power politics. Mahinda Rajapakse’s detractors (and of these there are many) will continue to cling to it with much desperation and caricaturing intent. So would the sycophants typically drawn to the locus of power who are likely to see it as a lifeline and little else.

What this kurahan saatakaya is, what it means and where it is found, are of course open to all kinds of readings as per the political predilections of the given reader, but an exploratory comment would not be out of place, I believe.

The kurahan saatakaya is and was essentially defined by what it is not, namely the tie-coat world as one would put it in “Sinhala”. It was the perfect “other” to everything represented by the (adopted) children of the colonial project, the privileges they enjoyed and the elitism they fostered and fought for tooth and nail perhaps never as ferociously as in this election. Still, it was not merely a matter of style, preferred clothing, notions of fashion etc. People can vote for any number of reasons but it would be safe to say that few would have factored in the choice of dress in their decision. It was what these things represented and the extent to which the avowed representation was manifest in programme and ideological bent that settled the issue, I believe.

This is why the kurahan saatakaya cannot and should not be read as something that marks the outward persona of the President. In other words, it is not something that hangs around his neck, or not something whose meaning is limited to where it is worn and how. Its broadest possible articulation covers much political, cultural, economic and philosophical terrain, at least in aspiration if not in concrete ground-reality terms.

Rajapakse obviously understands that in real political terms his hard earned victory on November 17 only resulted in the kurahan saatakaya just scratching the politico-cultural edifice it challenged. In this sense it was a very small victory. The tie-coat, to use that convenient though not inappropriate short-hand, hangs around the necks of every institution, the vast majority of state officials, the thinking of important sections of the most influential players in the economy, the hegemonic cultural drives and indeed the dominant ideological and philosophical frames of reference. The difference is that the kurahan saatakaya has executive power and as such has the potential to reform the politico-cultural-ideological edifice. The battle, then, has moved from the electoral register to the larger and more complex terrain of institutions, territories where Mahinda Rajapakse is at a distinct disadvantage.

The establishment, as Art Buchwald would put it, is “live and well”. It suffered a rude shock, true, but only the utterly naĂŻve can expect it to lie down and die on account of that particular poke in the behind. The establishment does not see a kurahan saatakaya. It sees an amuda lensuwa and it is a gaze of derision, a looking-down-the-nose, something that should be out of sight, mind and the face of the earth. This is why Rajitha Senaratne’s comment on that dignified and appropriate garment cannot be seen as a simple slip of the tongue but a precise political statement and objective. The establishment operated in according to a by-any-means-necessary logic in trying to defeat Rajapakse and will operate in the same vein in trying to bring him down. The establishment knows the ins and outs of the system and is deeply entrenched too. All mechanisms available for subversion will be employed, rest assured. These can take the form of from subtle foot-dragging, vilification in the media, positioning of saboteurs in key locations, fostering unrest, feeding terrorism, arm-twisting courtesy the World Bank, IMF, WTO, ADB, USAID and other agencies and other forms of political subterfuge. I would not put assassination past the establishment for there is much to lose and a lot to gain by burning the kurahan saatakaya.

It will be interesting to see how Mahinda responses to these challenges, how he plans to infuse the deshaye suwanda into tie-coat infested institutions, hearts and minds and wrap it all up with the kurahan saatakaya. It will be interesting to see if he succeeds. He has demonstrated, looking back, an admirable ability to suffer humiliation after humiliation especially from those in the party he represents and fought to protect, some of who left and returned at will. He has shown patience and knows the virtue of biding his time. He has shown that he has remarkable powers of persuasion and an ability to bring together and keep together divergent political forces. In offering a ministerial post to Anura Bandaranaike and people like Sarath Amunugama who were clearly at odds with him during the campaign, he has shown that he is not vindictive. In short, he is a skillful politician. As such he can be expected to pursue a path of reform and not purging in trying to correct the tie-coat edifice that stands between him and bringing to fruition the programme for which he won a mandate.

One thing is certain. He has a monumental human resource problem to overcome. He has very few he can trust and even fewer who have the skills necessary to out-smart the establishment that besieges him, Executive President though he is. He has one asset. The people who voted for him, those who made the kurahan saatakaya the 21st century symbol of a 500-year struggle to free the country from the shackles of colonialism.

He would do well to understand that we have come 49 years since ’56, which was an upturning that was ill-informed and poorly, very poorly and injudiciously executed. Today we know that a switch to swabhasha would not solve all our problems overnight. We know that “the nation” does not exist in a national dress, a national flag or a national anthem and will not be obtained simply by changing name boards from English to Sinhala.

We know that there can be a vast difference between appearance and substance, that the fault lies not in the tie-coat that is the preferred dress coat, but in the tie-coats of the mind, that lie in the ideological realm, in lifestyle and demeanour. We know that the kurahan saatakaya around the neck of an Executive President will not by itself deliver the nation to us, ourselves to us. We know that the struggle is to establish the validity and practicality of the kurahan saatakaya in all things subject to the caveat that there is nothing to say that the tie-coat universe has nothing to offer to us.

If there comes a day where every single institution insists that all employees wear a kurahan saatakaya we would still not have won if they continue to have tie-coat heads. On the other hand, if these institutions continue to insist that employees wear Western attire, replete with tie and coat, but the people inside these clothes have a kurahan saatakaya frame of mind, then the November 17 decision would most certainly have produced something we can be proud of as a nation. I humbly submit that this is not impossible.


msenevira@gmail.com