Showing posts with label Laksiri Fernando. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Laksiri Fernando. Show all posts

12 November 2012

How about a third Republican Constitution?

I read with interest Laksiri Fernando’s avuncular response (‘Devolution Talk’) to a comment on the 13th Amendment I had written a few weeks ago.  He’s asked me to ponder the 17th and 18th ‘syndrome’ of the Rajapaksa administration.  So, first things first, I will respond to this suggestion.

I have written dozens of articles on the 17th Amendment, from the time it was passed in 2001, pointing out its errors and lacunae and suggesting corrective measures.  As for the 18th, my objections were recorded in the Daily News as well as other newspapers I wrote for at the time.  So the ‘political past’ that he talks of is as much an imagination-figment as the idea as ‘pondering’ is ‘difficult’ for me.  I put it down to ignorance, which of course is no crime.

Fernando believes that the abrogation of the 13th would spell disaster for Sri Lanka’s external relations.  I believe otherwise.  He believes that the 13th ‘appears’ as imposition due to inept legal drafters.  ‘Appears’, he says and it astounds me.  India thrust it down our throats and JR conveniently ignored Supreme Court directive with respect to the referendum clause.  The document was only part read before the vote was taken in Parliament.  Fernando also ignores the fact that the 13th sought to resolve a problem that had nothing to do with territory.

I have written extensively on the ‘white elephant’ element of the 13th.  Two thirds of monies allocated for the Provincial Councils go to maintain them, for instance.  The logic of multiple economic centers in regions that are extremely unequal in terms of resource endowment rebels against devolution.  And if devolution is taken to its logical conclusion, we could have the Western Province (which contributes close to two-thirds of GNP) asking why it should subsidize Uva (for example).  A lot of regional ills can be dealt with by expanding administrative decentralization and does not require power devolution.   

Fernando wants me to admit that my perspective on the subject has little to do with the weaknesses of the present system.  There is nothing to ‘admit’.  I’ve been clear about it.  I oppose the 13th for multiple reasons, the economic ‘logic’ (or rather lack of logic) being but one element of my opposition.  The only logical way to devolve would be in accordance to a model where provincial lines are re-demarcated so as to correct for anomalies in resource endowment.  I’ve spelled this out many times.    

It is a pity that Fernando hangs on to sarcasm and doesn’t get it either.  Indeed he confuses my objections to his gonibilla posturing regarding the international community with contentions about the 13th .  Sad. 

And yet, Fernando is not wrong when he says, ‘The main detractors of proper development, stability and people’s sovereignty, if those are the concerns, are within the country and within the ruling clique itself’.  He could also add the UNP, the JVP and many anti-regime thinkers who are slaves to development paradigm even as they object to its executors.  The whines about the 17th and 18th come from those who have a sorry track record when it comes to democracy and freedom and Fernando strangely doesn’t seem to notice this.

Fernando misses the political implications of horizontal democratization via devolution in a cartography that is nonsensical and pandering to secessionist myth-makers.   It is natural for someone who has blindly accepted the Eelamist position on devolution to be happy about current demarcations.  He won’t use ‘white-drawn’, he says.  It’s white-drawn and brown-accepted.  That’s a brown sahib thing, but Fernando is perhaps not schooled enough in cultural and social politics to understand such things or how the affirmation of a colonial error when cuffed to land-grab logic of myth-mongering communalists necessarily exacerbate problem and postpone resolution.

I am happy that Fernando has put it down in black and white that there’s no connection between Tamil grievances and territory-based solution.  Yes, it is unfortunate that elections for the Northern Provincial Council have not yet been held.  The excuses offered are thin.  Elections need to be held.  It won’t erase the errors of the 13th, but there is (as I have said many times) danger in refusing the implement constitutional provisions (even if they are erroneous) or being selective in implementation.  What is required is the abrogation of the 13th.   

What is required, over and above that, given all the problems of the 13th, the hope and flaws of the 17th , it’s nullification by the 18th , all of which have separately and together turned an already anti-citizen document (the 1978 Constitution) into a made-to-make-and-entrench-dictatorship, not to mention widespread agitation about the Proportional Representation system and decades long calls for doing away with the Executive Presidency, is for a new constitution. 

 

28 October 2012

Devolution talk and devolution talkers

Are you for 13, 13-minus or 13-plus, someone asked me.  Political circles are a-buzz with the 13th, i.e. the Amendment thrust down the Sri Lankan polity by India in 1987, defended ferociously by Indophiles and non-Tiger separatists and happily used by politicians of all color intent on furthering careers and making bucks.  The pro-13th commentators have all come out of the woodworks, as have those who opposed it and oppose devolution to boot. 

Debate on the matter is not new.  The present buzz follows a statement by Gotabhaya Rajapaksa advocating its repeal.  Context in brief is as follows: a) the 13th is a part of the constitution, b) the President has at various times talked about devolution and pledged to go further, i.e. ’13 Plus’, c) it has no discernible connection with expressed grievances and makes no sense in terms of demographic, developmental and historical realities. 
And yet, those who are dismayed do make some interesting points.  Dharisha Bastians (‘From 13 Plus to 13 Minus’) argues that there is presidential double-speak.  Sumanasiri Liyanage (‘The UPFA government is heading for its first defeat in Parliament’) on the other hand is a victim of his own fantasies and notions of democracy predicated on faulty reading of conflict.  Laksiri Fernando (‘Gotabhaya’s talk about abolishing the 13th Amendment’) is fascinated with status quo (right or wrong) and erroneous in the assertion that a repeal would necessarily wreck language rights. 

Tissa Vitharana’s outburst is perhaps the most clownish, for he sees ‘foreign conspiracy’ in moves to abolish the 13th.  The biggest conspirator with respect to the 13th was India and that’s certainly ‘foreign’, not to mention that the darlings of those intent on dragging his leader to the Haig are also ‘foreign’ or ‘foreign funded’ AND are staunch 12-Plus advocates (their backtracking from separatism to federalism to the 13th corresponds to the decline and fall of terrorism: no coincidence!). 
Fernando’s is nevertheless the most thoughtful of the responses.  He has detailed, for example, pre-13th devolution talk.  He has also referred to the LLRC recommendations pertaining to devolution.  He has conjured a gonibilla factor: ‘Devolution and the 13th Amendment are the ‘trophies’ that the government has been showing the international community and the UN as indications of Sri Lanka’s commitment to resolve the ethnic question in the country. Backtracking on them would undoubtedly spell disaster for the country in the international sphere.’

Now the statements made on devolution from time to time does not necessarily make it logical, necessary, meaningful or sustainable.  These statements could be shot to pieces with the as-is situation of the 13th.  Fernando argues that as-is is mendable.  This is true except for the fact that devolution to provinces is antithetical to current economic theory in terms of resource endowment and allocation.  We have to keep in mind also that the X-Country success is not necessarily replicable in Country-Y.  
As for the ‘trophies’, Fernando misses the blatant truth that Sri Lanka’s detractors are as interested in ‘solutions’ as they are concerned about ‘democracy’ In Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya or the Arctic.  Showcasing ‘achievement’ is simply not going to cut ice unless the relevant lines are toed. 
Grievances (and no one can deny that Tamils have them, as do various other segments of society, including Sinhalese) need to be resolved in different ways, especially through democratization. Here, Fernando’s comments on the 17th and 18th are extremely valid.  But we are not talking about ‘democratization’ here but ‘grievance-addressing’. 

What all these people forget is that the lines we are talking about here are white-drawn.  They have nothing to do with the longer history of the country (where demarcations – Ruhunu, Maya and Pihiti --made political but more than this geographical sense) or make sense in terms of present day prerogatives (economic hub, resource-complement, seaboard and so on).  Secondly, I am willing to wager that if asked to enumerate ‘grievances’ and tie each of them to territory-based ‘resolution’, they would be stumped, particularly given the fact that the majority of Tamils live outside the North and East. 
It is in this sense that the line Fernando quotes from the LLRC Report (‘appropriate system of devolution’) and the one he misses (‘acceptable to all’) need to be considered.  We can have devolution, not to resolve grievances that are not devolution-resolved but for better and more meaningful development.  That would necessitate re-demarcation of provincial boundary.  That’s the ’13 Plus’ we could aim for.  If there’s anything that thumbs a nose at reality, then it is better to scrap.  No 13, no 13 Plus, no 13 Minus.  Zero.