Showing posts with label Narendra Modi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Narendra Modi. Show all posts

10 August 2023

The 13th Amendment and the Bhutanization project

Rajiv Gandhi and Narendra Modi, united in hegemonic intent

‘This is the beginning of the Bhutanization of Sri Lanka’
— Rajiv Gandhi

President Ranil Wickremesinghe has called on all political parties to submit their views on the 13th Amendment.  He, more than anyone else, should understand that right now the legitimacy of all political parties (including his) and all politicians (including himself) is suspect (and I am being kind here). Nothing illegal about his ascension to the post of president, nothing illegal about 225 persons representing various political parties remaining in Parliament, but legality and legitimacy are two different things.

Of course one may interject, ‘that’s subjective.’ Correct. If subjectivity is key then there was no case against Gotabaya Rajapaksa and those who bring that argument will have to say that the entire aragalaya and all the aragalists were out of order.

We can talk legality though, if that’s what you want. We can point out that the 13th Amendment was illegally ‘enacted.’ It was the product of an agreement signed by J.R. Jayewardene under duress. Rajiv Gandhi’s India (like his mother Indira Gandhi’s India before that) funded, trained and armed Tamil insurgents. This allowed those who had no qualms about frilling grievances in order to pad aspirations willy-nilly to marry fiction and thuggery. India helped up the ante to a point where it could orchestrate pernicious intervention ‘as a friend,’ and ‘to help resolve a problem (which of course India helped create in the first place!).’

The narrative of territory embedded in and which signatures the 13th was clearly based on a piece of fiction propagated by Tamil chauvinists enlarging on S J V Chelvanayakam’s pithy formula, ‘a little now, more later.’ It sought to legitimize a fictional homeland theory replete with well-defined boundaries that were randomly drawn by an invader (the British) with no basis whatsoever in history (or even legend!).

History and heritage don’t support the claims. We can go back to 18th century demographic data through the first official censuses or we could go back to the 10th Century AD and the time of Raja Raja Chola I. India’s Ministry of Culture will testify that the Archaeological Survey of India refers to various temples built by Raja Raja 1 using wealth plundered from various lands along with the names of the conquered territories. This island on which Rajiv Gandhi foisted the 13th Amendment at gunpoint was referred to as ‘The land of the warlike Singalas.’

If all that is ‘in the past,’ and it certainly is, we could go to today’s numbers. Those lines referred to above rebel against demographic reality; almost half the Tamil population live outside the so-called ‘exclusive traditional Tamil homelands.

Those who advocate devolution and have championed the 13th Amendment, even demanding ’13 Plus’ are fond of referring to the Sri Lankan population as being ‘multi ethnic’ and ‘multi religious.’ Correct. Only, they don’t talk about percentages. If they did, they would have to come up with some kind of justification for the fact that as per the current demarcation two thirds of the coastline and a third of the landmass would be controlled in the name of a community that barely makes 15% of the total population of the country. Except that this community, as pointed above, while concentrated in the Northern Province and parts of the Eastern Province (even as of now, more than half this province is made of what in separatist parlance could be called ‘Tradition Homelands of the Sinhalese’). In other words, mixed cultures or cultures amenable to mixing is what has always been the case. That’s not the same thing as assimilation, which of course can  happen. In any direction.

Those who talk of the 13th and even 13th Plus, don’t dare talk about 13 Minus. The 13th precipitated an uprising that led to the death of around 60,000 people in just two years. The 13th prolonged a conflict for a further 22 years. The costs are incalculable. Those who want to hang the ridiculous charge of genocide (the Canadian Prime Minister and the Canadian High Commissioner both need to take Canadian History 101 and Canada Today for the Indegene 101 at some point, the sooner the better) on Sri Lanka talk about hundreds of thousands being massacred. Well, India paved the way for that. If you want to argue it that way.

The almost 40 years that have passed clearly indicate that provincial councils are white elephants (during C V Wigneswaran’s watch the Northern Provincial Council couldn’t even spend the budgetary allocation) headed by political thugs. Today, in the year 2023 the provincial councils are dead. No elections. No talk of elections. No ‘aney apoi’ from democracy advocates who can’t stop talking about power-devolution. Not a single protest from any party or community or region over this.

Ranil Wickremesinghe is smart. He’s asking political parties to offer their views. He probably knows none of these parties can come up with anything coherent. Perhaps he has calculated that incoherence would pave the way for him to shrug shoulders and ‘do as India says.’

What India says and what India wants is exactly what Rajiv Gandhi said, wanted and believed he could obtain: the Bhutanization of Sri Lanka.

If political parties are serious (and they are probably not, let us not have illusions here), they can give a response in point form: 1) List all grievances, 2) Evaluate the logic of devolution as 'the only and therefore necessary mechanism to alleviate grievances,' 3) Call for a historical audit to assess the validity of 'exclusive traditional homelands, 4) Assess progress made on resolving grievances enumerated at the time the Indo-Lanka Accord was signed, 5) Revisit the 13th Amendment thereafter and decide whether it should remain, be amended or repealed altogether. 

RELATED ARTICLES

Let's go for 13 PLUS!

If 19 is to equal 13+...

Time to face the music in Geneva  

The 13th Amendment: by thugs, with thugs and for thugs

The forgotten 13th bears upon the 19th and 20th 

The LLRC and devolution: the politics of skipping the caveats

Reconciliation and hallucination 

Representations to the LLRC

LLRC Proposals: let there by no foot dragging 

13, 13+ and 13-

Pluses and minuses of the 13th Amendment 

The 13th Amendment and moral obligations

20th Amendment without repeal of the 13th a recipe for disaster 

Let the court of history summon all perception-peddlers

It is time to abrogate the 13th Amendment 

Narendra Modi spikes the good neighbor drink

India's 'love'

India reconfirms enemy status

India in Geneva: friend, foe or navel-gazer?

Modi as 'gonibilla' and maverick's plaything

First get the lines straightened out Jayampathy!

Devolution talk and devolution talkers  

Physician heal the real and not imagined malady!

02 October 2020

Narendra Modi spikes the good neighbor drink

 


Which country would not be happy if another country said ‘we have a you-first security policy?’ The cynical have the option of retorting ‘most countries would be terrified if, for example, the USA said something like that.’

The world is not flat. Not all countries are equal in terms of financial might and fire power. So when Sri Lanka says that she has an India-first security policy, it’s almost like saying ‘don’t worry, we will align ourselves with your interests and we will not shift loyalty.’ India-first is essentially ‘China is not first.’

India’s Deputy High Commissioner in Colombo Vinod K Jacob has found this ‘encouraging.’ Would India feel encouraged to be still more in-your-face, is that what he means? He could be thinking ‘encouraged by the prospects for better relations,’ but we know that countries love themselves, not others. Others, they use, if they can, and subdue if they can’t.

The generous reading is as follows: Sri Lanka understanding that India, having cottoned on to the Belt and Road Initiative rather late in the day, is jittery about China (so is the USA and this is what the ‘Quad’ which includes Japan and Australian is all about), offers an assurance, a good neighborly gesture.’

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has responded (and how!) in a virtual bilateral summit with the Sri Lankan Prime Minister Mahinda Rajapaksa. Pleasantries were exchanged first. They did the we-are-old-friends number. Rajapaksa listed recent Indian gifts, said ‘thanks.’ Modi eventually got down to business. He called on the new government 'to work towards realizing the expectations of Tamils for equality, justice, peace and dignity within a united Sri Lanka by achieving reconciliation nurtured by implementation of the Constitutional provisions (as in the 13th Amendment).’ This, he believes, is non-negotiable if there’s to be peace and reconciliation.

When ‘should’ is used instead of ‘could,’ it is presumptuous. It’s like Modi saying ‘Thanks for having an us-first policy, but we are not saying “you-first” and neither are we budging from positions we have taken — just do as we say!’

First, the background. India imposed the 13th Amendment on Sri Lanka. India intervened at a point when the Sri Lankan security forces had cornered the LTTE and the military defeat of terrorism was imminent. All this after India had (perhaps worried about the then Sri Lankan government’s pro-US stand) worked tirelessly to harass Sri Lanka; India funded terrorist outfits, armed and trained them. When Sri Lanka took the hits, didn’t collapse and in fact was about to overcome the threat, India moved in. The terrorist threat, which was hours away from being eliminated, flourished for 22 years more. Tens of thousands perished. India hit national dignity. India cost us dearly.

The fact of the matter is that we’ve functioned without the principal product of the amendment, the provincial councils, for several years. No one is complaining.

And yet, Modi pins Tamil aspirations to the 13th Amendment and insists that this is how we get peace and reconciliation! As though India was ever interested in ‘Tamil aspirations’! The then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi wanted to Bhutanize Sri Lanka. High ups in the Indian Peace Keeping Force said it was a victory to stump Tamil parties and get Trinco and not Jaffna as the capital of the North-East.  It was about Indian foreign policy prerogatives. 

India inserted clauses to subvert Sri Lanka’s right to commerce with other nations on matters of security. The accord sought to concretize random boundary lines in terms of a homeland claim that has no basis in terms of history, archaeological record or demography, effectively helping turn myth into fact. It was illegal to boot.

The bill was presented in part to Parliament.  A 9-member bench of the Supreme Court could not conclude on constitutionality. They were divided 4-4. It took a Chief Justice (who happened to be a Tamil) to interpret the opinion of the 9th member in favor of ‘constitutional’.  The Provincial Council bill was passed immediately after the Indo-Lanka Accord was signed, as though father and son were birthed together!

Most importantly India failed to deliver on its side of the bargain. India failed to get the LTTE to join the democratic process by laying down arms. The disarming was eventually done by Sri Lanka. So, in effect, Sri Lanka did India’s work for her AND Sri Lanka continues to affirm her side of the bargain as scripted in the Indo-Lanka Accord. A win-win situation for India, a coup some would say.

Modi has told Rajapaksa about a ‘united’ Sri Lanka. He believes the 13th would do it. Well, the LTTE rejected it. They wanted more. Modi forgets that constitutional enactment does not necessarily yield unity and more crucially, ‘united’ is not a constitutional term. It’s descriptive of levels of solidarity within a well-defined sphere. Modi, knowingly or unknowingly has adopted the Eelamist vocabulary. Eelamists use the word ‘united’ to mitigate antipathy regarding the term ‘federal.’ It sounds like ‘unitary’ but has nothing to do with such an arrangement.  

So where do we stand now? Sri Lanka has gone the extra mile (the you-first gesture). India has said ‘thank you very much.’ India has not been moved by the gesture. Had India said ‘thanks bro, you do your thing, we won’t interfere — just leave China out of it,’ it would have been enough.

It’s like taking a hand extended in friendship, gripping it firm, emptying the vocabulary of a diplomat’s guidebook and then using the other hand to deliver a slap.
 
It’s all disingenuous. India’s ‘Kashmir Policy’ is a cuss word. One doesn’t have to take sides on the conflict here, but Modi’s moves regarding Kashmir clearly haven’t taken into consideration ‘expectations of Kashmiris for equality, justice, peace and dignity within a united India by achieving reconciliation nurtured by implementation of the Constitutional provisions so necessary for peace and reconciliation.’


Good neighbors often chat during unplanned encounters at property-boundaries. A bad neighbor jumps over the fence, stomps over the flowers and condescendingly tells his/her neighbors that their happiness depends on following his/her blueprint for success, taking care to engineer a situation where the neighbors are hesitant to form/strengthen relations with other neighbors.

Narendra Modi played 'bad neighbor.' It’s not a good thing to play one neighbor against another. There’s a commonly used Sinhala phrase that illuminates: apita apey paaduwe inna denna. ‘Paaduwa’ refers to loss. So, it means, ‘alright, we’ll take the hit, but don’t worry about it….just don’t interfere.’

 

malindasenevi@gmail.com  

09 December 2019

The 13th Amendment and moral obligations




Mano Ganesan, leader of the Tamil Progressive Alliance (TPA) believes that ‘India has the moral duty and political right towards the Tamils of the North and East since the 13th Amendment is the child of the Indo-Lanka Accord.’

Prime Minister Modi, when he met President Gotabaya Rajapaksa in Delhi, flagged the 13th Amendment. That ‘flagging’ (of a dead horse, should we add?) has excited Tamil politicians. M.A. Sumanthiran and S Sritharan of the Tamil National Alliance have spoken about ‘Indian pressure’ almost as a given, something wholesome and necessary. They, like others, have often talked of the 13th Amendment as ‘just a start’. That’s Chelvanayakam’s ghost talking, ‘a little now, more later’.

Well, we’ve had the 13th Amendment for 30 years now. It was not an Indian baby nor an Indo-Lankan baby. In real terms it was Rajiv Gandhi’s first step in extending India’s hegemony in the region. He famously said ‘This is the beginning of the Bhutanization of Sri Lanka!’ But then again, arm-twisting aside, the accord certainly carries the Indian signature.  Does that give India a ‘moral authority’ to see it implemented?

If we talk moral authority, then we need to consider the Indo-Lanka Accord not as an inflation of favorite parts but its entirety. Part of the agreement was for India to disarm the LTTE. India didn’t hold up that end of the bargain. The moral authority argument ends just there.  

Now all provincial councils, set up in accordance with the Indo-Lanka Accord and the 13th Amendment, are dissolved. Indeed, some were dissolved a couple of years ago. The administrative arm of the state continued to function, however. So far, no complaints. No agitation for elections, not from the democracy-darlings fronting for the United National Party (UNP) whenever its political fortunes seemed to be going down the tube and not even from the raucous Tamil communalist politicians screaming ‘India’s Baby, India’s Baby!’ 

It is not, let us repeat, India’s baby. The people of Sri Lanka never wanted it. Their views weren’t obtained. The 13th Amendment was illegally enacted and in a scandalous rush to boot. To claim that India still has some stake on account of an Accord that died the day the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) left the island, is silly or else sycophantic. To plead for Indian ‘pressure’ so that Sri Lanka’s political landscape can be altered can be read, if one were generous, as a sign of helplessness.  Another reading is possible: par for the course of Tamil communal politicians. 

The Tamil nationalist formula would retire for a considerable period of time any chance of inter-communal reconciliation. That’s a recipe for political instability. A weak, unstable state is of course something that may make certain Indians salivate, but Narendra Modi would know that desperate leaders could willingly barter sovereignty and much else besides to the highest bidder. Indians talk about China’s footprint in Sri Lanka. Indians aren’t exactly cheering on USA’s designs via SOFA and the MCC Compact either. 

All that is external. There’s an internal element here. Sri Lanka. Sri Lankans. Defunct provincial councils that’s not inspiring any whines from any quarter.  A Tamil nationalist project based on a myth model that has served only the petty projects of two-bit Tamil politicians. A war waged by warriors spawned less by Sinhala chauvinism than Tamil nationalist who nurtured in THAT baby unrealistic aspirations. A nation that requires healing.  

Interestingly, the communalism and the anti Sinhala and anti Buddhist rhetoric have all been couched in the language of oneness, secularism and almost an erasure of identity. Well, erasure of all identities except those of the non Sinhala and non Buddhist sections of the population. ‘ONE SRI LANKA!’ they shout, but not exactly in undertones interject ‘Tamil National Identity,’ and Religious Identity (yes, all religious communities except Buddhists). Having the cake and eating it. Trying to ride two donkeys with one backside. 
The abolition of the 13th is necessary on account of its unholy enactment and failure to resolve issues that have been mislabeled. Would that sort matters out? Obviously not. Neither will ‘development.’ There’s an issue of belonging which the ‘full implementation of the13th’ cannot resolve (because it was ill-conceived and utterly out of sync with geographic, economic, demographic and historical realities). It is nevertheless an issue that requires priority attention.

President Rajapaksa has referred to ‘inclusive nationalism’. What’s inclusive here? Is it for the subjugation of all identities, communal and religious, to some vague notion of ‘Sri Lanka’ and ‘Sri Lankanness’? Is it some kind of ethnic assimilation, which is another term for gradual and/or coerced dissolution of minority identity in that of the majority community? Is it a celebration of all identity communities? He has not spelled it all out. Not yet. 

However, if there is to be a Sri Lanka which is inclusive, then an important non-negotiable would be the full restoration of Rule of Law and ensuring the absolute independence of the judiciary, quite apart from addressing and resolving representational anomalies (and not just on the subject of identity).  

This country is made of a lot of things and people are one element. There are resources that have to be protected and used in ways that are wholesome. There is talent that goes unnoticed and eventually wasted because the talented are not ‘properly’ positioned or are made invisible by certain structures and processes. There are notions of ‘development’ that are inclusive and those that result in costs that are not counted or are ignored out of boorishness, ignorance or simply because people don’t want to deal with inconvenient truths. 

President Rajapaksa may or may not have a comprehensive understanding of ‘nation’. One hopes he does, because that would be a good thing. Then he would not ‘forget’ anyone. He would not forget things like carbon neutrality. He would not forget history and heritage. He would not make anyone feel a lesser citizen or one who has to depend on the largesse of someone else. 

He has told Prime Minister Modi (and also others who take note) that he will speak his mind. This is a good thing. We’ve had politicians of all hues promising the undeliverable, to one and all. The UNP in particular has hoodwinked the Tamils (going by patterns of loyalty in elections) into believing that their grievances will be redressed and aspirations realized. 

In any event, obtaining such inclusivity will be difficult because of the 13th Amendment (among other things). Simply because it was a monumental blunder and an affront to reason. Thirty years is long enough for people to realize this. Keep it, and Tamil communalists will stand on it and scream. Take it out and the true dimensions of grievance have a chance of being articulated, i.e. the frills will be done away with.  

It’s not India’s baby now, anyway. India is out of the equation and can claim equation-residence only on account of nostalgia or hegemonic intent. Modi is obviously far too intelligent for such puerile indulgences. No, it is not India’s baby. It’s Sri Lanka’s irrational irritation.  

If India insists on the 13th or some version along those lines as price for ‘help’ then Sri Lanka, which cannot really declare war on India, should say ‘udau epa….vadath epaa’ (Help? Thank you, but no. Just don’t harass us).  

Sumanthiran has expressed hope that the new President will engage with his party. Nothing wrong in that. Indeed, it would be good for the President to meet the TNA and other parties representing districts that rejected him in favor of Sajith Premadasa. He can listen to them. He can tell him his story and his plans.  

Those plans, whatever they are, cannot be about the Tamils and Muslims only. They will have to be about the Sinhalese too. And they will tell us what he thinks about categories of people outside of ethnic and religious colors. The ‘ethnic’ and ‘religious’ let us not forget have stolen center-stage to the point that many subjugated and neglected communities have been made invisible. A nationalism that includes Tamils, Muslims, Sinhalese and other identity based groups but excludes the many underclasses whose woes are forgotten or imagined not to exist, will be partial inclusivity. That won’t do.  

India has certain moral obligations, I’m sure. Indians would know them. Gotabaya Rajapaksa has moral obligations. That’s obtained from manifesto and tested in implementation of the same. He’s known to be a workaholic. Let’s see how he works and whether or not it will work.



This article was first published in the Sunday Observer [December 8, 2019]


   

02 September 2019

Narendra Modi, Imran Khan and the search for new republics



‘Romesh Kaluwitharana ct Sachin Tendulkar, b Wasim Akram.’ Remember this? You probably would if you were an ardent cricket fan. You would, even if you were not, being an Indian and a Pakistani, old enough and interested enough (obviously) in shared subcontinental history.  

Who in the subcontinent hasn’t heard of Wasim Akram? Who hasn’t heard of Sachin Tendulkar? Both legends, one Indian and the other Pakistani. Two countries. Two different national flags, two different national anthems, one proud to be Indian and the other a proud Pakistani. 

But how on earth did they end up in the same team? Well, in a word, ‘solidarity’. Solidarity not with one another, apart from the obvious togetherness of being in the same team, but a celebration and support of, ironically, an opponent. Sri Lanka.

Here’s that history in a nutshell. 

India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka hosted the 1996 ‘Wills’ Cricket World Cup. Australia and the West Indies, drawn in Group A, along with Sri Lanka, refused to play in the island ‘due to security issues’. Cricket authorities in India and Pakistan, immediately decided to play a friendly match against Sri Lanka. In Sri Lanka. Just to tell the world, ‘it is safe’. Australia and West Indies didn’t budge. They conceded walkovers. India would later beat Pakistan in a Quarterfinal and Sri Lanka would beat India in a Semifinal and go on to win the World Cup defeating Australia in the final.

The Indo-Pak vs SL match had no bearing on the World Cup real. It was a moment though. A moment when nationality was bested by solidarity, history was made irrelevant by humanity. Ironically, truly historic.  

Rivers flow across lines drawn on paper by men for reasons that have little to do with the earth. Winds blow across borders, sand shifts and birds fly back and forth, oblivious to such designs. People, who know now where they came from and are clueless about where they would go, live and die. Time passes. Continents shift. In the long history of the earth, nations, much like all of us, are both, go into decay and perish. These things are known. These things are forgotten.  

Twenty three years have passed since that day in February 1996 when an Indo-Pak team beat Sri Lanka in a friendly 40-over match, but all three countries were victorious. Today, solidarity is under fire from nationality. ‘History’ threatens humanity. That too could be historic, but for lamentable reasons.  

India. Pakistan. The biggest countries in South Asia. Sri Lanka is a tiny island. I am a Sri Lankan citizen, one of 21.44 million. If a butterfly can cause a hurricane, a speck of dust could, theoretically, turn the earth. Turn back time. Make borders irrelevant. 

Perhaps we should explore our true nationality. Perhaps we need to talk of different kinds of republics, not the ones that make for cartography with lines and colors, but those less tangible and far more sustainable. Republics of feeling. The kinds that do not impose visa requirements for music and laughter, where Shiv Kumar Sharma can gather the stories of a valley and coax the santoor to relate them all in languages that require no translation. 

There are skies from which death descend, there’s earth which breaks into weeping, there are winds that carry bad news and music has been replaced by war drums and war whoops. There are also skies that rain poetry, earth that yields benevolent harvests, winds that whisper lullabies and music that is, well, music. 

There comes moments, once every several centuries, when a child armed with a divine eraser and a potent pencil sits before a map of the world and diligently re-orders the earth in ways hitherto unimagined. Perhaps we have been adults too long and should strive to rediscover a childhood that life was allowed to take away from us.   

It is a journey, then. A journey that takes us from familiar to unfamiliar and at the end a state of being that is wholesome. It is about a place, a history and multiple narratives, laced with arrogance and ego, ‘national pride’ in a world where we have lost all sense of ‘nation’ but for all the wrong reasons. A place, that exists and yet does not; a place that is token and trope where people and humanity count only to the extent that they feed political rhetoric.

I shall not name it for it is a place that does not exist. Yet.  And that’s why we need to journey towards it and with it.   And right now, in this subcontinent that is home to us all, I cannot think of two better companions on this journey that Narendra Singh Modi and Imran Khan.  

It is about wandering into hearts. Our own and each other’s.  We are one, and as Rumi said, consequently there’s room for another. Room for the other.  For all of us. As we all found on the 13th day of February in the year 1996. As we could rediscover.



malindasenevi@gmail.com. www.malindawords.blogspot.com