Showing posts with label Raja Raja Chola. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Raja Raja Chola. Show all posts

21 August 2018

How about including ‘Reparations’ in school curricula?



History is version. This is true. And yet, certain versions have a greater degree of believability than others. Dominant narratives do bear upon the present and can get in the way of obtaining inter-communal resolve, but the solution is not to dump history altogether as some have proposed and others have tried in surreptitious ways.  

Dumping history is convenient for those who find it tough to substantiate. It is also convenient for those who want to suppress the inconvenient. The British, for example, have a lot to hide. So too the Christian churches of various denominations.  Some butchers and thieves are smart, some are not. Some are just brash and can't be blamed for slippages of those who would cheer them. Like Raja Raja Chola 1. 

Raja Raja Chola 1 (985 and 1014 CE) is a name associated with the ‘Golden Age of the Cholas’. Raja Raja Chola 1 and his successors were warriors. They invaded, they plundered and they bragged about their exploits. 

It is no wonder that the militant adherents to Tamil Nationalism in Sri Lanka (principally the LTTE), lacking a golden history on the island, borrowed from Raja Raja Chola 1. In addition to unforgiving brutality they took a flag and a name. That’s how they became ‘The Tigers’. As for name, they erred when they from the one the Cholas used for the island, ‘Ila Mandalam’. Raja Raja Chola 1 added a descriptive to the name: ‘The land of the war-like Singalas.’ There was no ‘shared-ownership’ as purveyors of Eelamist myth-modeling such as Wigneswaran and M.A. Sumanthiran would like everyone to believe.

What’s relevant is is not the carelessness of the LTTE, but the braggadocio of Raja Raja Chola 1. The Archaeological Survey of India includes reference to inscriptions at various Hindu temples built with the wealth looted from lands conquered by Raja Raja 1. Just for the incredulous, the temples in Tanjavur and Ukkal were not authored by someone who had any interest in cooking history in favour of the ‘Singalas,’ they were not the observations of some interfering, arrogant and ignorant white man, they are not taken from the Mahawamsa or 21st Century scribblings of a chauvinistic Sinhalese intent on denying property rights to Tamil Sri Lankans.

That’s not what’s relevant. The plunderers bragged and the bragging was inscribed in stone.  And thus, we know that they robbed and what they did with the wealth they plundered. 

Eelamists should study inscriptions at the temples in Tanjavur and Ukkal 


Unlike the British (or the Portuguese or the Dutch).

Three years ago, the Oxford Union held a debate on the motion "This house believes Britain owes reparations to her former colonies". Speakers included Indian politician and writer Shashi Tharoor and British historian John MacKenzie. Mr Tharoor's argument went viral, perhaps because it resonated with Indians, who outnumber the British twenty to one. British historian John MacKenzie offered arguments against the motion.

MacKenzie held that Tharoor was wrong about reparations. His argument was based on the contention that ‘no empires have pursued tender or altruistic policies’ and that the outcomes are a product of ‘imbalances in environmental opportunities, military and technological power, or capacities for state centralization’.

By way of defending British plunder in India, MacKenzie points out that there were elites in India anyway and they were already exploiting the masses. He talked about the benefits that the British brought to Indians such as railways, industrialization, education and a unifying language. In any case, MacKenzie argues, that ‘the calculation of reparations, their payment, ensuring that they went in the direction of the poorer in society, and their contribution to economic growth for all, would all be fraught with difficulties.’

How tough it is for the mathematically and logistically challenged, eh? 

There is a popular myth about the British.  They gave us this, that and the other and we owe them much, it is argued frequently (and typically from those whose ancestors positioned themselves to pick the crumbs the British offered).  So, we are told, they gave us a constitution, rules and regulations, roads and railways, and of course English.  

Right. Taxes and slave labor paid for everything. There was no payment to anyone for everything looted. It was not ‘education’ we got, but a particular kind of education. It is not the case that people in this country (and in other places plundered) were uneducated and ignorant. As for institutions and rule books, they were not put in place out of love for ‘the natives’ but to streamline plunder.  English: there’s a reason it’s referred to as kaduwa (sword).

Was it all bad? No. Was it all good? Hell, no. And the balance? Bad, let there be no doubt. Heavily on the bad side, let us note. Shenali Waduge has sketched out just the actions of one British subject in an article titled ‘The Crimes against humanity by British Governor Robert Brownrigg – Butcher of Uva-Wellassa in Sri Lanka’. There was genocide, ethnic cleansing, outright plunder and a clearing in these and other ways for the continued exploitation of the island’s population and the extraction of its wealth. Facilitators were nurtured through ‘education’ and placement in subordinate administrative and enforcement structures. For the record, Brownrigg was not the only butcher.  

Let’s get back to MacKenzie’s logic. It can be applied to things other than ‘empires’ and what they did. There are other situations where people not pursuing tender or altruistic policies where there was an imbalance in environmental opportunities, military and technological power and capacities for centralization.  Here are some: theft, embezzlement, resource extraction, pollution, mass murder. Any of these and much more besides can be brushed aside by citing the principle of power differentiation, which is what MacKenzie’s argument boils down to. 

So, reparations is a subject that we need to talk about and indeed include in school curricula.  There are 61 countries which were in terms of territory parts of the British Empire. Some of them have sued Britain, along with France and the Netherlands (for example 14 Caribbean countries demanding reparations for slavery).  The British won’t submit of course. They’ve always talked about ‘improving future relations through funding infrastructure projects.’ Former Prime Minister David Cameron even promised Jamaica a new prison! 

They’ve actually said ‘sorry’ but then again, talk is cheap; sorrow cannot be banked. If saying ‘sorry’ would do then all legal systems would degenerate to the ‘give-take’ of Catholic Confessionary.  Britain did at one point announce that the descendants of Kenyans tortured by British colonial forces during the Mau Mau uprising would receive payouts totaling 20 million pounds. 

But how about the loot itself?  Yale University, Connecticut, USA recently decided to return to Peru a collection of antiquities taken from the Inca site of Machu Picchu almost one hundred years ago.  Richard Burger who has been in charge of these items for 30 years said that the situation is different from classic repatriation because it was not about stolen goods but a contract dispute; things were not clandestinely dug up’. 

That’s lovely. In our case and in most of the 61 countries where the British did their thing, there was no necessity to be clandestine.  Some of the artifacts, all stolen goods, are traceable. 

Well, we can and should talk reparations right now, especially since the British and other such powers with considerable ‘butchering-history’ lecture Sri Lanka about such things. They don’t say ‘It’s enough to say sorry and to build a few prisons’ now, do they?

Raja Raja Chola 1 and other Chola aggressors were not constrained to be cute about plunder and the investment of plundered wealth.  The wealth from all continents that ended up in the British Isles are not all congealed in artifacts that can be named.  They remain unlisted. They’ve transmogrified into capital and that, as we know, is re-transferable to countless things and processes.  

We cannot say if and when reparations will be made. But we can, when the beneficiaries of butchery and plunder lecture us, tell them ‘get us back the known loot, chum.’

‘A catalogue of antiquities and other cultural objects from Sri Lanka (Ceylon) abroad,’ is the title of a book by P.H.D.H. De Silva, published in 1974.  It lists a considerable set of known artifacts stolen from this island.  There are over 15,000 items listed.  The loot it seems has ended up in 23 countries and 140 holding facilities.  The vast majority are in Britain.  Bristol, Cambridge, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Berkshire, Leicester, Liverpool, London, Sheffield, and Windsor all have ‘Little pieces of Ceylon’ so to speak.  

All stolen goods.  For antique and historical value, each and every amulet, the tiniest statuette, the most fragile manuscript with hardly legible lettering, is priceless. The British Museum houses artifacts and manuscripts of incalculable value.  These can be returned as a first step. We can talk reparations later.

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer. malindasenevi@gmail.com. 

11 June 2016

Power-sharing, yes! Devolution, no!

It's an old topic but one which neither goes away nor is marked by reason.  This was published under the same title in the 'Daily News' 5 years ago. 

There are two terms that are used frequently as though they mean the same thing by those who are determined to confuse the people for the vile purpose of pushing agenda that have no legitimacy and do not correspond to any on-the-ground reality: ‘power sharing’ and ‘devolution’. 

There are two kinds of arguments pertaining to ‘power-sharing’. First, there are those who believe that the current configuration of the political space is centralized and centralizing and therefore robs decision-making power from the peripheries.  It is essentially a regionalist argument.  The impetus for proposing a re-configuration is the mistaken or deliberately misleading notion that the current set up is anti-Tamil, the assumption being touted as fact being that two provinces of the above ‘periphery’ are ‘Tamil’, i.e. they (the North and Easy) are exclusive historical and traditional homelands of that community. 

First let’s take history.  On February 14, 1766, Kirthi Sri Rajasinha, the King of the Kandyan Kingdom ceded a stretch of land in the Eastern part of the island, 10 miles in width from the coast to the Dutch East India Company.  The relevant maps are contained in Fr. S.G. Perera’s ‘The History of Ceylon’.  Prof. James Crawford refers to this treaty in his book ‘The creation of states in international law’ as one of the earliest such agreements recorded.  Prof. S Arasaratnam’s work on the Dutch Period refers to the details of this treaty and points to the issues pertaining to sovereignty.

The implication is that the KandyanKingdon had the right to cede that portion of land and that it continued to have sovereignty over the rest of the territory until the British obtained full control of the island in 1815. 

In 1766 therefore there was no question of sovereignty of any other polity and when the relinquished sovereignty was recovered and reasserted in 1948 by the State of Ceylon it naturally reverted to the political geography prior to the signing of that treaty. 

That treaty, moreover, is the genesis of the demographic realities of today’s Eastern Province where the bulk of the Tamil population lives on that 10 mile wide strip of coastal land.  Their ancestors were brought there by the Dutch to grow tobacco. Even today the majority of the GramaNiladhari divisions contain a Sinhala majority population. 

If the issue of homeland requires a longer throw back into the past, we can go to the 10th Century, to the golden period of Chola expansion/invasion and the invasion of the island by Raja RajaChola in the year 993.  Raja RajaChola is also known as a builder of Hindu Temples.  The inscriptions at these places, according to the Archaeological Survey of India, resolve all doubts about traditional homelands and sovereignty.  The inscriptions at the temples in Tanjavur and Ukkal speak in glorifying vein that Raja RajaChola conquered many countries, including one ‘Ila-mandalam’.  The inscription elaborates that this ‘was the country of the warlike Singalas’.  The plunder of wealth, one notes, is not from ‘Singalas’ who lived in ‘Ila-mandalam’ (which is a corruption of ‘Sihala’ or ‘Hela’) but the land of the ‘Singalas’, whether they were warlike or not being irrelevant to the issue. 

The archeological evidence shows that what is today called the Northern and Eastern Provinces were at one time the heartland of Buddhist civilization in the island.  Although there have been claims that these were the work of Tamil Buddhists, the thesis is not supported outside the rhetoric. 

Then there is demography.  More than half the Tamil people in Sri Lanka live outside the North and East.  Some argue that this is due to the conflict.  There is some truth in this claim, but there is absolutely nothing to support the thesis that the current demographical pattern will be reversed in the post-conflict scenario.  Indeed, the ‘exodus’ has benefitted the Tamil community/politicians disproportionately, for it has not resulted in an appropriate alteration in the number of parliamentary members allocated to the Northern Province.  

The ‘influx’ into the Western Province has resulted in at least 2 extra MPs for Tamil parties from Colombo in addition to the 9 from Jaffna.  ‘Exodus’, by the way, include all the Sinhalese and Muslims evicted from these areas by way of ethnic cleansing carried out by the LTTE with not even a whimper of protest or murmur of remorse from people like R. Sambandan. 

The bottom line is that devolution to the current provincial demarcations will leave more than half the Tamils in this country ‘high and dry’ while rabidly racist and chauvinistic politicians like Sambandan and Sumanthiran would benefit.

There is more to ‘geography’.  While the Eastern Province is ‘split’ among the Tamils, Sinhalese and Muslims, in terms of area, the largest slice contain Sinhalese, and not Tamils and Muslims, as mentioned above. 

There is a second school of thought regarding ‘power-sharing’.  The objection is the same: concentration of power. The difference is that territory is not the core concern, but the citizen.  The 1978 Constitution was clearly anti-people.  Whatever insulation that the citizen had vis-Ă -vis the politician was effectively compromised by J.R. Jayewardene.  The 17th Amendment sought to win back some space for the citizen, but it was terribly flawed. The 18th threw the baby with the bath water, in my opinion. 

There is, then, power at the centre that needs to be shared.  ‘Devolution’ only puts power in the hands of regional politicians and although this might appear to be empowering since politicians are after all representatives, resource anomalies rebel against the idea when the crucial issue of development is brought into the equation.  An ‘empowered’ Uva cannot demand from a devolved ‘Western’ to let it (Uva) have a slice of the surpluses generated.  Only a ‘Centre’ that is subject to checks and balances as well as held accountable in delivering on national development prerogatives can obtain such distribution.  Only a re-demarcation of provincial boundaries where resource imbalances are corrected can buttress the ‘devolutionist’ school of power-sharing.  As things stand, it is communal, anti-intellectual and politically unfeasible.

‘Power sharing’, therefore is not co-terminous with ‘devolution’.  Moreover in Sri Lanka’s context (taking into account history, geography, demography and citizens’ grievances, including those of minorities), power-sharing if it does not address the issue of citizenship anomalies that cut across the communities, would not only preserve current imbalances but also exacerbate inter-communal tensions. 

If these realities are ignored, it shows intellectual laziness, political arrogance and ideological poverty.  Well, all these plus rabid communalism.  We won’t have ‘unitary’ any more. Neither will we have ‘unity’. We will only have an entrenching of the racism and land-theft as per the Chelvanayakam Option, ‘A little now, more later’; the ‘little’ being the BIG ‘getting legitimacy for the boundaries of the Eelam Map’ for Prabhakarans of the mid to late 21st Century to shed more blood over. 

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer.  Email: malindasenevi@gmail.com. Twitter: malindasene

07 May 2015

Devolution-justification: how about some truth, accountability and reconciliation?*

Truth, accountability and reconciliation are being talked about a lot these days. Interestingly, many who use these terms think ‘truth’ is equal to systemic and deliberation massacre of Tamil civilians by Sri Lankan security forces. They believe ‘accountability’ is about the Government pleading guilty to such charges. Finally, they equate ‘reconciliation’ to ‘power sharing’ which in turn they believe is about devolving power to provinces whose boundaries were arbitrarily drawn by some white men almost two centuries ago and over which they assume Tamil people have exclusive claims (‘traditional homelands’).

There are some ‘truths’ that are disconcerting to those who subscribe to the above rendition of grievance/aspiration.  Less than 50% of the Tamil population actually lives in the Northern and Eastern Provinces.  As such, the North and East (which constitute more than a third of the land mass) is to be handed over to less than 6% of the population and they would get almost half the coast to boot, courtesy ‘reconciliation via devolution’.  Another interesting and damning demographic detail that’s left out by these pundits is that the Tamil population in the East is concentrated in a ten mile wide stretch along the coast.  Given demographic realities, if police powers are devolved, the majority of Tamils in the island would have to live under the generosity of Sinhala or Muslim Chief Ministers. 

There are other ‘truths’ that are footnoted or ignored.  Here are some. On February 14, 1766, Kirthi Sri Rajasinha, the King of the Kandyan Kingdom ceded a stretch of land in the Eastern part of the island, 10 miles in width from the coast to the Dutch East India Company.  Prof. James Crawford refers to this treaty in his book ‘The creation of states in international law’ as one of the earliest such agreements recorded.  The implication is that the Kandyan Kingdon had the right to cede that portion of land and that it continued to have sovereignty over the rest of the territory until the British obtained full control of the island in 1815. 

In 1766 therefore there was no question of sovereignty of any other polity and when the relinquished sovereignty was recovered and reasserted in 1948 by the State of Ceylon it naturally reverted to the political geography prior to the signing of that treaty. 

That treaty, moreover, is the genesis of the demographic realities of today’s Eastern Province, referring to above. The ancestors of the vast majority of Tamils in the Eastern Province were brought there by the Dutch to grow tobacco. Even today the majority of the GramaNiladhari divisions contain a Sinhala majority population. 

Tamil chauvinists and those who have swallowed their myths (which come with ‘fact’ tag) uncritically speak of a ‘Tamil Nation’ that co-existed with the ‘Sinhala Nation’. For ‘centuries’, they add.  Arguments that contradict this thesis are summarily brushed aside as the imaginations of Sinhala racists.  Well, here’s what a celebrated Dravidian monarch and quite a powerful one at that says about this island and to whom it belonged way back in the 10th Century.  This is in the year 993 AD, right in the middle of the golden period of Chola expansion/invasion.   Raja Raja Chola invaded the island in that year.  He is known as a builder of Hindu Temples.  The inscriptions at these places, according to the Archaeological Survey of India, resolve all doubts about traditional homelands and sovereignty.  The inscriptions at the temples in Tanjavur and Ukkal speak in glorifying vein that Raja Raja Chola conquered many countries, including one ‘Ila-mandalam’.  The inscription elaborates that this ‘was the country of the warlike Singalas’.  The plunder of wealth, one notes, is not from ‘Singalas’ who lived in ‘Ila-mandalam’ (‘Ila’ being a corruption of ‘Sihala’ or ‘Hela’) but the land of the ‘Singalas’, whether they were warlike or not being irrelevant to the issue. 

The archeological evidence shows that what is today called the Northern and Eastern Provinces were at one time the heartland of Buddhist civilization in the island.  Although there have been claims that these were the work of Tamil Buddhists, the thesis is not supported outside the rhetoric.

It is a strange fact isn’t it that Tamil chauvinists have no reliable historical tract they can reference to buttress homeland-claim?  They have to twist-read the Sinhala chronicles.  Or else bank on a lyrical fantasy whose value as even a supplementary source for obtaining historical transcript is negligible if not zero. 

These are the thoughts that came to mind when I read N. Satya Moorthy’s column in the Daily Mirror (May 9, 2011).  The name means ‘Mirror of Truth’, and I am sure the columnist would pardon and correct me if I am wrong.   His assertions were astounding and betrayed a rank ignorance of the history of this country and more seriously the demographic, geographic and economic realities upon which ‘solution’ must be planted.  Misread terrain and you get crop failure or worse, a weed that invades and corrupts. 

The term he uses is ‘incremental devolution’.  This is C.J.V. Chelvanayakam all over again, nothing else. ‘Chelva’ a non-native Tamil who is one of the key architects of Tamil chauvinism and marauding separatism, opined that bit-by-bit was the best way to get Eelam, viz., ‘A little now, more later’.  This is why ‘devolution’ is not the ‘moderation’ sweet that Satya Moorthy claims it is.  In fact, he is advocating ‘Asymmetrical Devolution’, which gives legitimacy to the fantastic claims made by Tamil chauvinism.  Once done, history will not be referenced again, for Tamil Chauvinism can claim thus: ‘The Sinhala Buddhist dominated (hardly!) state of its own accord recognized implicitly the veracity of our traditional homeland claim by resolving to devolve power to the relevant boundaries as a solution to expressed grievance’.  Throw in asymmetry, as SatyaMoorthy advocates, and it will buttress this argument even further.
 
He uses an interesting term: ‘victim community’.  Now there is no argument that there are citizenship anomalies and that grievances do exist. The key issue is to identify the true dimension of these grievances, in other words, obtain truth by un-frilling claim of rhetoric and fantasy.  The Sinhalese too are a victim community. So too the Buddhists.  How about some ‘redress’ for the poor, while we are at it?  SatyaMoorthy is engaging in a deft exercise of obfuscation here.  

A sense of belonging is needed.  It is needed by every citizen.  This is what constitutional reform should keep in mind.  Truth is of great value here.  Accountability too. Those who make wild claims must substantiate. And those, like SatyaMoorthy, who in ignorance and/or arrogance advocate without substantiating argument must be held accountable for they are the architects of future mistrust among communities.   That’s how we can get to ‘reconciliation’. 
The bottom line is ‘truth’.  Hard to digest, I know, but it will emerge again and again to trump the ignorant, the chauvinist and the conscious or unconscious meddler.


msenevira@gmail.com

*This was first published in the 'Daily Mirror' on December 10, 2011.  Re-posting here because some lies are repeated so often that they have to be responded to as frequently. 

08 February 2014

Raja Raja Chola 1 and the quicksand of Tamil chauvinism*

The history of this island can be read as an account of invasion, resistance, conquering and routing the enemy.  It is also a history of migratory waves and, in recent times, emigration as well. There are of course all kinds of histories.  There are those written by the winners which some claim make their authenticity questionable. There are histories embedded in folk traditions.  Histories can be read through careful perusal of archaeological record.  There are claims of place in history, some substantiated and others not.

Some say history is version, but no one will dispute that this assertion makes the version that the Ruwanweliseya is a Catholic Church anything but ridiculous. There are people who are scared of the word history
and they tend to be those who make grand claims without substantiation or have little or no history to talk about. 

These are the ones who murmur the ‘multi-ethnic, multi-religious’ mantra not so much as a desired or desirable resolution as a manifest aversion to acknowledgment that certain peoples and certain religious traditions have contributed overwhelmingly to the admittedly problematic composites called Sri Lanka and Sri Lankans.
 
We remain products of who we were, who our ancestors were and what they did, whether we like it or not. In other words, history sits at the head table of the present and in ways that are disconcerting to some.
 
One easy escape from historical discomfiture is the construction of more comforting narratives of event, personality and associated metaphors. It takes much effort, a lot of money, a lot of purchasing, myth-models and propaganda. In my view that
’s an option that Tamil nationalism was forced to embrace.

The success of that particular effort is indicated in the fact that Eelamists have managed to convince some that
‘north’ is Tamil and ‘south’ Sinhala, that devolution (which includes federalist and secessionist options) makes sense because the North and East (they don’t say Northern and Eastern Provinces, because the demarcation-less articulation makes for further inflation of territorial claim) are ‘the traditional homelands of the Tamils’.

They do not unpack these terms because doing so would force them to swallow the hard facts of demographic reality (over half the Tamils live outside these two provinces) and geographical factors (most of the Eastern Province is made of Grama Niladhari Divisions with majority Sinhala populations).
Then there is also history
.
They dare not talk of archaeological evidence. They will say the Mahawamsa was written by racist Buddhist monks but do not have anything close to a shred of evidence to counter what
’s on the ground in these areas (even if one were to discount the Mahawamsa).  They cannot talk about a permanent Tamil presence in demographically significant terms. At best it is about Tamils who chose to stay behind after the occasional South India invasion was turned back.

There is one exception: the golden age of Chola aggression. The 10th Century AD.

This was the time the Cholas invaded not just this island but vast swathes of the subcontinent as well as territories in what is now known as South-East Asia. The LTTE adopted the Tiger emblem from the flag of the glory days of Chola domination.
 
Tamil nationalism, desperately seeking a historical prop, picked a derivative of the name that the Cholas used for the island,
‘Ila-Mandalam’. They were careless. Raja Raja 1, during whose time the Chola empire reached its zenith of glory, not only invaded but plundered and bragged about the plundering.
The Archaeological Survey of India, for example, includes reference to inscriptions at various Hindu temples built with the wealth looted from lands conquered by Raja Raja 1.  These inscriptions list the names of lands he conquered and refers to the island we today call Sri Lanka as ‘Ila-Mandalam’. ‘Ila’ is a corruption of ‘Hela’ or its four-part elaboration ‘Sihala’ (from ‘Siv-Hela’, made up of Yaksha, Naga, Deva and Raksha, each associated with a vocational sphere) and it is indeed the ultimate irony that the LTTE and its Tamil nationalist precursors used this to coin ‘Eelam’.

If this too is version, then Tamil nationalists could have all doubts erased by reading the elaboration that Raja Raja 1, no less, offers:
‘the land of the warlike Singalas’.
Whether the Singalas are/were warlike is not relevant to the issue of historical claim.
What matters is that Raja Raja 1 had no doubt whatsoever that this land belonged to the Singalas.
If it was the case that Singalas shared ownership with some other community, this fact would have been articulated especially if military intervention sought to buttress claim of or defend a kindred community.

In other words. it was a clear statement that ownership of territory had been wrested from the Singalas.

Now the inscriptions at the temples in Tanjavur and Ukkal were not authored by someone who had any interest in cooking history in favour of the Singalas.
These were not the observations of some interfering, arrogant and ignorant white man.
They are not taken from the Mahawamsa. Nor are they the 21st Century scribblings of a chauvinistic Sinhalese intent on deny property rights to Tamil Sri Lankans.

They are straight forward and matter-of-fact articulations of a particular political reality, authored in passing by someone who had absolutely no stake in conceding anything to those he conquered.

The claims about history put forward by Eelamists are eminently debunkable by a lot of archaeological and other evidence, but what shoots these to pieces is ironically the very source that they draw inspiration from: Raja Raja Chola I.

Does this mean that Tamils are not part of this polity or that they are or need to reconcile themselves to being second class citizens? No! It merely means that they do not have any privileged claim on historical grounds to any part of the territory that is called Sri Lanka. As citizens they have every right to expect the same privileges that citizenships bestow on all other communities and all anomalies relating to these needs to be corrected.

Such correction as is necessary cannot be territory based as history, geography and demography do not support such arrangements. Devolution is out, therefore.

As for those Eelam-fixated sections of Tamil nationalists, they can relax now: Raja Raja Chola I has taken a huge load off their shoulders. Had they realised this several decades ago, this country would have been spared a lot of death, destruction and dispossession. Time to move on, though. Raja Raja Chola I demands this.

*First published in 'The Nation' in January 2011.

Malinda Seneviratne is the Editor-in-Chief of 'The Nation' and can be reached at msenevira@gmail.com