Showing posts with label Sarath N Silva. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sarath N Silva. Show all posts

11 November 2014

Conversations with Sarath N Silva

These are moving-around days.  There’s talk of people crossing party lines.  There are people plotting regime-change.  There are people getting ready to counter such moves.  People are talking to people.  We have the Constitution Abolishers.  We have the Constitution Amenders.  Then there are people trying to cobble together parties and other political groups as well as prominent personalities in a grand coalition that would support a ‘Common Candidate from the Opposition’.  These same people are also busy trying to find a ‘Common Candidate’.

These are talking days.  Some people are smelling blood.  Others smell something else, but thinking it has to be blood, are salivating.  Still others are not taking chances and are focusing on closing ranks.  They are keeping partners under check even as they try to woo key members of the other side.  Others are watching.  Some are listening. 

Even the biggest talkers must have a breather.  During a break in a long discussion that had already taken half a day, a man called Sarath N Silva found himself in a parallel universe called ‘Humility’.  He was not alone.   Those present had been discussing the Constitution, its inherent ills, its significant positives and the virtues of amending or abrogating the same.  But in this calmer and less loquacious place, no one wanted to ‘continue the conversation over a cup of tea or coffee’ as one of the key organizers had suggested.  They spoke of other things. 

‘Why did you do it, Sir?’ a green-eyed MP from the Opposition asked the ex Chief Justice. 

Before the man could respond, a man red-eyed from sleep-lack on account of thinking too much about a blunder made in 2005 blurted out, ‘he always played politics!’ 

‘Yes, first with the lady and then with the gent!’ murmured the head of an NGO currently under a massive cloud due to allegations of fraud.

‘Come, come, let us not quarrel here…we have to focus on the objective and we have to put aside our differences.  We can’t afford to dwell on the past.  We must look to the future.’  That was a bikkhu who some thought might be The Answer but others felt could only be a weaker SF.

‘But we are on a break right now,’ the green-eyed one protested.

‘I’ve already said that I was in error.  What more do you want?’ 

‘In error?  Are you serious?  You’ve not only ensured that the Opposition gets weaker by the day but made sure that whoever wins can turn a wafer-thin majority into a two-thirds majority!’

‘Oh that?  I thought you were talking about Helping Hambantota!’ the ex-judge said.

‘That’s history.  I am talking about people crossing over and how the ruling you gave facilitated it.’

‘Yes, yes.  So what was your question again?’

‘Why did you do it?’

‘Well, our rathu sahodaraya, was correct.  Deep down I am a political animal.  Like anyone else.’

‘Oh no.  Don’t flatter yourself.  There have been many CJs who remained untouched by the dirty and crass of politics.’

‘Good for them.  I am a connoisseur of this thing called “The Art of the Possible”.  I did my bit. Indeed that’s what I am doing now too.  People objected when I determined when Chandrika’s term ends.  People objected to the Helping Hambantota decision.  People even objected to my ruling on MPs crossing over.  Look around you.  Most, if not all of these objectors, have either benefited from my decisions or else have become fond of obtaining my advice.  You people should know that there are no permanent enemies of friends.    It’s the same for political positions.’

‘But we expect more from someone like you, Sir!’

‘I didn’t flatter myself, so why are you trying to make out that I ought to behave in a way that is flatter-worthy?’ Silva raised the obvious question.

‘It’s this.  We are confused.  We don’t know who is who.  He or she who is with the Government today may be with us tomorrow, but it’s more likely that the person who we call comrade and with who we plot and plan to oust the regime will be on their side the day after.  We just can’t trust anyone.  It’s ok being in the opposition.  If we have to wait for six years, we will.  But there has to be some basic kind of predictability.  You’ve done away with that!’

‘Son, let me tell you a secret.  People think and I let them think that for all my expertise on constitutions and separation of power, and indeed my self-proclaimed deep study of the scriptures, I remain a creature fascinated by the political.’

‘Go on..’

‘It’s a cover!’

‘What do you mean?’

‘I did all that and do all that I do now because I am at the core a very lonely person leading a humorless life.  I did all that and do all that I do now because I need some entertainment!  Your agitation amuses me.  As for your confusion, what do you think I am laughing off as I roll on the floor when I get home?’

‘Break over!’ the bikkhus said.

‘Ehey haamuduruwane,’ the others said in unison.  Sarath N Silva was grinning.  The others were not.  




13 September 2014

On ‘monarchizing' mechanism and afterlife blues*


The 18th Amendment is in the news again, this time sadly as a straw-clutching move by an Opposition which appears to consider any match up with Mahinda Rajapaksa an exercise doomed to fail.  The legal objections posed by former Chief Justice Sarath N Silva have sparked some interest and time will tell if the arguments are robust and if they are whether the judiciary will prevail over the executive and legislative arms of the state.  But what of the 18th Amendment itself?  This was written four years ago, just before the Amendment was passed.  A good revisit, I thought. 

Last week, in an article titled ‘On the Dana clause of the Dasa Raja Dharma’, I promised to explore issues of governance contained in the 10 principles embedded in the above document in order to shed light on ‘where we are as a nation, the crucial challenges we face and the futures we can reasonably imagine’.  Today, I am forced to digress. 

I was due to write about the second principle/article, that of ‘sila’, i.e. ‘virtue’ or maintaining a high moral character, where the ruler observes at least the five precepts, and conduct him/herself in private and public in a manner that is of shining example to the people.  I write instead about the proposed 18th Amendment to the Constitution which seeks among other things to remove the clause of the constitution that imposes a two-term limit on the President. 

No, I am not saying that constitutional amendment (of any kind) is totally unrelated to the issue of sila and the limiting clauses therein.  The Dasa Raja Dharma or the ‘Ten Point Guideline for Rulers’ after all covers all aspects of governance and all political processes including constitutional amendment.  Indeed, it is possible to use any of these 10 points to dissect the proposed amendment.  I fear though that employing my ‘sila’ salaakaya (ration) in this column for that purpose would be a waste since this series is meant to be a general commentary on things political.

The 18th is too in-your-face for me to defer to consideration of the ‘general’.  The Amendment, if passed, will allow a President to be elected an unlimited number of times, and provide an incumbent the opportunity to call for an election upon the completion of 4 years of any given term.  It will see an effective abrogation of the Constitutional Council (enabled via the 17th Amendment) and its replacement by a Parliamentary Council made up of the Prime Minister, Speaker and Leader of the Opposition (ex-officio) as well as one each proposed by the ruling party and the opposition.  The task of appointing individuals to the Independent Commissions (of the 17th) will fall on the President upon the recommendations of the Parliamentary Council.  It is still not clear whether foot-dragging loop-holes have been written into the draft or whether or not such escape clauses will be detected by those who will be called upon to vote on the Amendment.   

I’ll first deal with what someone might say are the trivial (relatively) matters. According to the proposed amendment, the heads of Government institutions will be appointed by cabinet.  If that’s formalizing what is now an on-the-ground reality (politicization of the public service) we can say ‘well, that’s being honest’.  On the other hand legislative enactment has to be more than calling a screw-up a screw-up and making it official.  It should be about discovering error, acknowledging it and seeking correction.  This is therefore disappointing and a serious indictment on the intelligence and integrity of the architects of this amendment.

The President, speaking at the 59th National Convention of the Sri Lanka Freedom Party, has made a quaint observation.  He pointed out that Section 92 of the Constitution prevents those who have mental disorders from contesting the Presidential Election.  An incumbent who is stopped from seeking a third time automatically falls into this same category and this is not right, he believes.  

That’s rubbish. 

An apple is not an orange and vice versa just because they are both fruits and not vegetables.  The imposition of term limit does not imply that no sane person can retain his/her sanity after being in power for twelve years. Indeed a people that sanctions a third time (in principle) and gives it effect by electing a person to the supreme political office could arguably be called ‘mentally unsound’.  Similarly, those in metal institutions are not there because they all served two terms as the President of Sri Lanka. 

The President implies that the enactment of a Parliamentary Council would amount to ‘re-instating’ the powers that prevailed before 1978 to Parliament and the Cabinet.  ‘There is nothing wrong in consulting members elected to the Parliament when making appointments (to the Independent Commissions). Well, as long as the President has nothing more than a rubber-stamping task in the appointments, that argument can be made, yes.  This does not mean, however, that we’ve gone back to the 1st Republican Constitution.  We cannot forget that the President has enormous powers, that the legislation pertaining to Independent Commissions was flawed and that there is nothing to prevent appointments to these commissions being skewed in favour of furthering the interests of politicians (as opposed to the general public). 

The 17th envisaged a certain insulation of citizen from politician and political interference.  The rhetoric did not bleed into the paper, unfortunately, and not a single MP who voted for the 17th noted the flaws which, finally, killed it.  This ‘insulation’ does not seem to have been on the authors of the 18th, as things stand. 

This is not the only issue that I have with the 18th of course.  The President, at the SLFP Convention has defended the Amendment saying that it provides the opportunity for anyone to contest the Presidency any number of times and that Sri Lankans will get the opportunity to elect whomever they liked.  What he doesn’t state is the inherent advantage that an incumbent has over a challenger, an ‘advantage’ he is aware of and made use of in January (even though I doubt he needed to, at the time). 

The United National Party has duly objected.  The UNP doesn’t have the moral authority to object, though, not unless there’s full confession that this party, more than any other, is responsible for the constitutional ills we’ve had to suffer for the past 30 years and their terrible consequences.  This however does not give the UPFA or the President the license to engage in ‘do-as-we-please’; it is not enough to say ‘they did it too’ for it is ALWAYS possible to justify anything by taking this route of argument.  

It has been pointed out that if there are no term-limits to other public offices, why should restrictions be imposed on this particular office, that of the President.  The reason is simple: the dimensions of jurisdiction, political and otherwise. A Pradeshiya Sabha member operates within a small circle of influence, territorially and politically. Not so an executive president given powers vested in that office by the 1978 constitution, powers that are hardly curtailed by the 17th (thanks to flaw) or would be by the proposed 18th (as things stand). 

I have argued many times that the 1978 constitution is not made for dictators but is made to make dictators.  Its dictatorial inherence is not lost on Ranil Wickremesinghe, for example. He knows.  He is not too keen on amending the 17th (he likes those flaws, we have to conclude) and has not been pushing for the abolition of the executive presidency (certainly not with the determination with which he pushed for negotiations with the LTTE).  Term limits is a mechanism to retire the constitutional dictator. It doesn’t really increase the operational space for democracy or serve to rekindle the democratic spirit; it just allows for the replacement of one has-to-be-dictator by another has-to-be-dictator.  The removal of term limits can only make things worse because it replaces what I call ‘made to make dictators’ with ‘made to make monarchists’.

The 18th is essentially a ‘monarchising’ mechanism.  What it amounts to is procession: from President, to Re-Elected President, to President-for-Life to a hereditary tenure of the office.   This is not fear-mongering.  This is inferring from constitutional history and deferring to notions of the inherent human quest for immortality.  

I am not disputing the legality of constitutional amendment.  The President can get the necessary votes to pass it in Parliament. If the Supreme Court decides that it requires endorsement through referendum, this too he is likely to obtain, given him popularity and a disturbing public preference for personality over principle.

The issue is that it is not about Mahinda Rajapaksa but the office.  People like Mahinda Rajapaksa and might think it is ok to have him as President for another 10 years or more.  That’s not the point here.  The 18th, if passed, makes it possible for ANYONE to be in power for life (i.e. by getting re-elected every 6 years).  Someone can point out that there’s an ‘if’ in that the person has to get elected, and therefore can be ousted at an election.  That’s on paper. The ‘if’ is not ‘big’.  There is a reason why I’ve claimed often that the 1978 constitution is made for a two-term Presidency.  People get elected for 12, not 6, because re-election is assured unless you die or are killed (President Premadasa) or you choose retirement (President Wijetunga). 

SLFPers who are loyal to Mahinda Rajapaksa and who did not like Chandrika Kumaratunga can ask themselves, ‘what if this term-limiting clause was removed when she was in power?’  People can think of the politician they like least and ask ‘what if he/she was President now?’  They could ask themselves, ‘would we risk giving someone like Prabhakaran or Mervin Silva an opportunity to be President for Life, in effect?’ 

Mahinda Rajapaksa had only one thing to worry about: how history remembers him.  He was on a high when the LTTE was defeated during his first term as President.  The 18th, if passed will take him higher in terms of political power.  History was waiting to smile on Mahinda Rajapaksa.  I don’t that smile now though. In fact I see disappointment right now and it looks as though it is shifting to ‘annoyance’. 

Mahinda Rajapaksa should not worry about the frowns of the international community, so-called, or LTTE-lovers masquerading as good-governance gurus.  The people, though, are different. They don’t write the official history, but theirs is the transcript that endures the long centuries. 

Kuveni is loved, Vijaya is not; Ravana is admired, Rama is seen as a fop.  It would be good to wonder why this is so.  There’s a frown waiting to greet Mahinda Rajapaksa in the year 2050 (by which time he and I would probably be dead and gone).  He still has time to secure for himself a happier afterlife.  And a rest-of-this-life where he can go to sleep with a clear conscience. 

*First published in the 'Daily Mirror,' September 6, 2010.

Malinda Seneviratne is the Chief Editor of 'The Nation' and can be reached at msenevira@gmail.com




04 November 2012

Constitution impeached!

It is now official.  The Executive-Judicial clash is heading towards denouement and one that is not hard to call.  We’ll get to that later. 

Chief Justice Neville Samarakoon escaped the ignominy of impeachment by resigning.  Chief Justice Sarath N Silva was spared by the Parliament being prorogued first and then dissolved.  In the case of the former, the Executive had sway over the necessary numbers in Parliament.  In the case of the latter, the mover, Ranil Wickremesinghe didn’t have the numbers and didn’t have the support of the Executive, Chandrika Kumaratunga.  When Silva ruled to snub Kumaratunga, she couldn’t think impeachment because she didn’t have impeaching numbers. 
Today it is Chief Justice Shiranee Bandaranayake who is in the dock.   In a context where regime popularity is hinged on the popularity of the President and therefore the political fortunes of ruling party MPs are tied to him remaining in power, the Executive has a vice like grip on the legislative branch.  The Executive, moreover, has the numbers that neither Wickremesinghe nor Kumaratunga had.  As such, things look bleak for the Chief Justice.

There are howls of protests of course but not all the protestors have moral right on their side.  Silva himself had his ups and downs as well as his sideways ways including encroachment on executive territory.  Among those who object to the current moves against the Chief Justice are those who sought to bring down Silva but forgave and forgot the moment Silva fell out with the Executive following the classic ‘my enemy’s enemy is my friend’ formula.
Many who are shedding tears for the Chief Justice today, howled in protest when she was first appointed to the Supreme Court.  ‘Political appointee!’ was the scream back then.  Morality was cited by the objectors who pointed out that the lady’s husband was a high ranking government servant.  They later even salivated when her husband, who was Chairman of the National Savings Bank, was implicated in a 390 million rupee deal in the stock market. 

On the other hand, the current investigation of the husband, following the much publicized Executive-Judicial spat and the subsequent impeachment move, says a lot about selectivity and even revenge-intent.   The message that is not spelled out but is nevertheless clear is, ‘We can just get along, but if we can’t, there’ll be arm-twisting, and if that doesn’t work, well, we have the numbers and the law’. 
It doesn’t make it morally right though.  It is morally wrong to subject the Chief Justice to a witch hunt, for that is what is has amounted to.  It may be legal, but still the use of available mechanism to get rid of her without any mention of ‘reason’ or transgression on her part, makes a bad, bad, bad precedent.  The howlers don’t have the moral authority either, given their flip-flopping nature on issues of this kind and the fact that they’ve been consistently motivated by matters of political expediency and not issues of legality and morality.  

If indeed, as alleged, the Chief Justice is inept or guilty of wrongdoing, the process that seated her in that august office must be flawed.  If unseating is simply a matter of leveraging numerical edge, that too indicates mechanism-flaw. 
Perhaps these developments, in the end, serve only to strip the 1978 Constitution to its iron-like bones, demonstrating that for all the sway and punch of the judicial and legislative arms, the executive can be too a heavy a weight to budge. 

It boils down to presidential discretion and that shows constitutional error and poverty.  We can curse the Second Republican Constitution and its architects.  We can find the gripe of its never-envisaged victims (the UNP) amusing.  None of this requires us to cheer the current and principal beneficiary. 
Simply, the constitution and by extension, its props and beneficiaries stand impeached.  Morally.   

15 October 2012

Sorting out Executive-Judicial tensions


There is the executive.  Then the legislative. And there is the judiciary.  ‘Separation of powers’ refers to lines demarcating territory and jurisdiction.  These are certainly not hard lines, but nevertheless the very existence of boundary makes for checks and balances.  When the lines are soft and pliable, when they are porous, it means that anarchy of the worst kind is around the corner.  Thankfully we are nowhere close to that.  There are tensions, yes, and there always have been, not just in Sri Lanka but all over the world.  When tensions are not sorted out through established procedures, democracy inevitably suffers. 

A ‘situation’ has arisen with respect to this ‘territoriality’.  The Judicial Services Commission (JSC) perturbed by allegations that the Chief Justice (CJ) had been ‘summoned’ by the President, issued a statement demanding that the executive keep its hands off the judiciary.  The Secretary of the JSC, who authored that demand, was later beaten up by unidentified assailants.  The response from Government spokespersons have ranged from condemnation to trivializing. 

It has been pointed out (see ‘This is my nation’, September 30, 2012) that ‘if there was a concerted effort to undermine the independence of the judiciary, this would not be the first occasion and more pertinently, this is a government that has the least need to do so’. 

It is not common for the executive to be peeved by the judiciary and vice versa.  J.R. Jayewardene’s hand-picked CJ, Neville Samarakoon, upon appointment steered clear of executive reach, prompting harassment from JR.  Samarakoon was brought in from nowhere in 1978, when the 2nd Republican Constitution came into effect.  JR brought down the number of Supreme Court judges from 19 to 7, effective demoting 12 of them to the Court of Appeal.  At the time, he let them retain the ‘Justice’ title and dismissed demotion-complaint by saying it was part of the new constitution.  Seven of these twelve were in a ‘pool’ of judges.  When the executive brushed aside a salary hike request, Samarakoon responded by detailing the President’s salary while addressing a gathering at the Raja Sinnathurai Educations Institute at Mile Post Avenue, Colombo 3.  JR retorted that the CJ was out of order.  When JR was sworn in for his second term, the CJ not only arrived late, but looked askance during the ceremony.  After Samarakoon retired, JR appointed Parinda Ranasinghe ahead of the more senior and reputedly ‘harder’ Justice Mark Fernando.

Sarath N Silva, who was similarly hand-picked by Chandrika Kumaratunga, was certainly not a yes-man.  His determinations certainly helped Mahinda Rajapaksa win the Presidential Election, even though they may not have been designed to facilitate this outcome.  Silva was not just independent to a fault, he even transgressed boundaries, venturing on several occasions into executive territory. 

There are two points that need to be made.  First, that even though the President does the appointing, once appointed, the CJ, on account of position-stature and probably acquired standing warranting appointment in the first place, comes into his/her own.  It is not impossible to remove a CJ constitutionally, but quite about the legality of such an eventuality, good faith needs to be established and obtain general public approval.  The latter is easier said than done.  Impeaching a CJ is out of order for many reasons and it is heartening that Minister Nimal Siripala Silva has effectively squashed such rumors. 

Secondly, Chief Justices show a pattern of being more assertive and less concerned about hurting executive sentiments when the relevant President is at term-end.  Sarath N Silva’s ruling on when Kumaratunga ends her term came late in the day.  Similarly, he started chewing on executive territory only when there appeared to be a possibility of Rajapaksa being defeated by Sarath Fonseka.  The current tension may be traced to similar perceptions.

These tensions are therefore not abnormal or unprecedented.  A sense of responsibility, especially with respect to the need to separate powers, by all parties generally helps iron out issues which also tend to be subject to media-inflation.  Harassment is possible by both parties but is best avoided.
One thing is clear.  Problems between the Executive and Judicial arms of the state should not be resolved by Choppe Aiya.  That would spell doom for both spheres and the general public too. 
 
 [First published in 'The Nation', October 14, 2012]