Showing posts with label Sri Lanka Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sri Lanka Education. Show all posts

28 November 2019

Education System: is it future-ready?

Is the future ready for them, are they ready for the future?

All presidential candidates came up with plans for the country. Rosy pictures were painted. Promises galore there were. Some of the plans were pragmatic, some idealistic and some downright silly. In all, without exception, there was talk of the future.

Futures are envisioned and policies are designed to turn vision into reality. That’s the overall picture. Identifying flaws and suggesting ways and means of fixing this or that is part of the story, but without an overall frame that could quickly slide into a term-long drudgery.  

What was worrying about the manifestos of the leading candidates was the almost cursory treatment of the subject ‘Education’. Some streamlining proposals were evident. The question of access was addressed. And yet, the ‘why’ of it all and of course ‘for what’ was left to be teased out from overall vision. 

Let’s begin with the future. First of all, we are not (and we never were) a self-contained island. There was commerce. There was travel. There was the cross-fertilization of ideas. The Sinhala language itself testifies to all this if we were to take all the foreign words incorporated into that language. The future will be no different. More challenging, yes. Dangerous, yes. But then again, no one ever inhabited idyllic situations. There can be contestation, there can be engagement. For both, we need to know what we want. National interest, in other words. 

A tomorrow with better opportunities for securing overall well-being would be the necessarily broad frame of reference. The ‘working environment’ as mentioned would be challenging. There is the political and economic play of powerful nations and equally or more powerful corporate entities operating through states both powerful and weak. Capacities always count or/or cost. 

Meeting challenges require, apart from resources and clever strategic maneuvering, a solid complement of human resources. That’s education.  

We are now on the brink of what is called the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Following the first (water and steam power to mechanize production), second (electric power for mass production) and third (electronics and information technology to automate production), the world has been building on the last. We are living in that transformation where a fusion of technologies is essentially erasing the lines between the physical, digital and biological spheres.

Are we ready? Obviously not. The primary and secondary school education systems are archaic. If 80% of schools offering AL subjects cannot teach students subjects outside the Arts Stream, there’s something wrong. Indeed, it cannot be the case that students forced to study arts subjects don’t have what it takes to study medicine, engineering, commerce, IT etc. What’s problematic is that they are often not even aware of such options. They have no clue about their own potential.
  
Encouragingly, there have been moves in recent times to overhaul these systems to ensure that students acquire a more rounded education and are neither straightjacketed into a narrow subject stream nor driven to memorize (and forget) as seems imperative in an exam-based system of assessment.  

Then there’s the education-employment mismatch. This is partly the reason for the proliferation of private degree awarding institutions, some operating with accreditation with the University Grants Commission, and some just as outfits preparing students for foreign examinations or as affiliates of such institutions. There’s very little oversight. Quality-assurance is, well, virtually non-existent. 

Now if there was a comprehensive occupational classification and also a sense of probably skill-needs given inexorable technological advancement, education could be restructured in terms of curricula, training methods and of course resources that produce graduates with requisite skills. Even then, we have to answer the question: who will deliver all this?

Over the years the debate has been ‘private vs public’. There are merits and demerits in both systems. They can complement too. On the other hand it is a patently false dichotomy. On the other hand, there is the reality that the tertiary education system just cannot keep up with the demand for skilled people required by the overall economy.  

Perhaps we can adjust the economy to the education system we have but that would be putting the cart before the horse. We can have a different kind of economy, but that requires a vision absent in our dominant political culture and the backing of a strong, knowledgeable and capable public ready to walk that treacherous path. We might very well have to go there one day if and when the current development bubble along with fixations on industry as deliverer bursts. What do we do until then? It is not really ‘going along’ for lack of alternatives. Technology is not necessarily bad. It’s all about what technology is used for. To use it effectively (whichever way you want to understand ‘effective’) you have to know it. And moreover, you have to have enough people who know it.

The sad truth is that if we need an X number of IT graduates by 2025, X+Y by 2030, X+Y+Z by 2035 and so on (where X, Y and Z are each greater than, say, 100,000) and our private-public system can churn out just P by 2025, P+Q by 2030, P+Q+R by 2035 and so on where P, P+Q and P+Q+R are eminently describable as ‘way short of target, then we have a massive problem on our hands, 

This is why being future-ready forces the government to think of alternatives such as the not-for-profit model best exemplified by the Sri Lanka Institute of Information Technology (SLIIT), set up in 1999. The first batch that graduated numbered just 300. All IT graduates. Today, twenty years later, SLIIT offers both undergraduate and graduate programs, 38 in number and 9,500 enrolled. 

Yes, there are fees levied, with the difference that profits get pumped back into the system. The expansion alone says something about demand, demand not catered for by private and state universities. 

That’s just one aspect of it of course. What the government needs to recognize is that students must constantly retrain and upgrade their skills to stay relevant. The education system should be structured in a way that makes it flexible enough to adjust to anticipated and unanticipated technological changes.

The best of our leaders dream of a different future, vibrant and wholesome. Dreams are cheap. Work is hard. It is good that the newly elected president has talked about ‘work’ again and again. There are, however, certain nonnegotiable foundational matters that have to be put in place. Education is key.  Our system is half buried in a past and half wallowing in a confused present. Future-ready is a dream. And yet, we can get there if we are willing to understand the challenge and have the will to transform things.   



06 September 2018

Notes for a Manifesto: Education Reforms



If anyone doubts that the entire education system should be reformed, a quick listen to statements made by the Minister of Higher Education Wijedasa Rajapaksha (WR) would force a re-think. On the one hand he extols the virtues of private education and insists that this way lies the future. Then he submits a Cabinet Paper to take over the Sri Lanka Institute of Information Technology (SLIIT).


The reasons offered are hilarious. WR tells us that SLIIT was initially managed by a private company although owned by the Government (he probably meant ‘state’) with money being released from the Mahapola Trust Fund (MTF) to construct the first building.  Three years ago, WR claims, SLIIT had paid some 400 million rupees to the MTF and purchased a new lease for the property.  

WR is concerned that there are no government officials on the SLIIT board now. He believes that less than half a million rupees is a gross under-valuation considering the worth of SLIIT assets, which by the way were not paid for by the Government. He’s most concerned about the fate of SLIIT students since ‘there is no rightful owner to this institution’!  

That’s WR’s SLIIT story. Another version would give a more comprehensive and detailed picture. It would speak of SLIIT being established in 1999 by a group of eminent academics and professionals as a Company Limited by Guarantee in order to address the demand for IT professionals. It would mention how SLIIT expanded, establishing centers in Matara, Kandy, Jaffna and Kurunegala, while creating opportunities for the study of other fields. 

It is a success story, by and large. If an ‘ownerless’ institution can offer graduate and postgraduate degrees in multiple disciplines, secure accreditation from renowned international certifying authorities in a country where the ‘owned’ universities have little to brag about, it is clear that ownership is not an issue.  PerhapsWR should study how not-for-profit entities operate, assess the track record of SLIIT, compare it with institutions such as the one he wishes to turn SLIIT, and check his tongue before making statements if only to curb contradiction and obtain coherence. 

It’s more than an issue of private versus public (or a mixture). It is about institutional and programmatic coherence and it is also about quality. Let’s consider the current situation.

The state spends billions on education and yet the end product clearly indicates that the return on investment is low.  It appears that the relevant authorities have not updated themselves about the objectives of education, new methodologies and the need for synergy.  

At present the public education system lags behind private systems by as much as two years. It is an exam-oriented system and one which effectively pushes a 15-16 year old into a particular stream. A student that young cannot know what he/she is good at or what would sustain his/her interests. Moreover it makes it impossible for him/her to shift streams in the event it is discovered that he/she chose poorly.  Blinders are imposed early and a student cannot explore other areas of study. For example, the course-rigidity does not allow a mathematics student to learn biology, commerce or literature.  
This needs to be corrected. It cannot be impossible to come up with a system which gives students more flexibility in the combination of subjects, especially at the tertiary level. For example, it should be possible and indeed compulsory for a student focusing on the social sciences to obtain more than rudimentary instruction in commerce, mathematics and biology where the student can select from a basket of subject options.  The entire examination schedule can be restructured to allow for two or more exams that count for the final overall result where a student, if he/she feels that he/she has made a mistake could, after the initial set of exams, shift disciplinary focus.  

While there are assignments, group projects and such, they do not count towards the final grade that a student receives. Therefore, naturally, what is fostered is a culture of exam-mania. It’s a do or die matter and those who die are buried, as per ‘custom’. 

Ideally, there should be a system which strikes a balance between school based assessment and evaluation through competitive exams. Centers could be set up to facilitate schools and teachers to conduct such assessment and also oversee the integration of new and innovative learning/teaching mechanisms.  

In any event, there has to be a strong civil-education component in the school curriculum especially to ensure that students who benefit from subsidies are made aware of how much is spent on them, who coughs up the money and what this entails in terms of ‘giving back’ at some point. 

Such an initiative would have to be complemented by a licensing system for all those who aspire to be teachers. Having a degree does not mean one is automatically suited to teach. It is unfair to subject children to the supervision by those who are engaged in on-the-job training. That’s like getting a medical student to prescribe medicine.

The overall idea is to ensure that when a student exits school, he/she has a more rounded education, is empowered with the ability to work with others, a healthy curiosity, good communication skills in at least two languages (including English) and an innovative frame of mind among other things. 

There are other issues. International schools operate largely without any supervision. In this case it is not about curriculum, but policies and practices, some of which are highly questionable. What is proposed is of course not policing, but a system of licensing that requires adherence to standards across all areas of operation. 

There are lots of institutes devoted to higher studies, both private and public. There are also institutes that focus on technical education. There’s overlap and there’s sidelining. Such things can be corrected by reviewing and if necessary restructuring the institutional arrangement to obtain a greater degree of coherence and enhance synergy.

Education is obviously a key element of national development. Therefore higher education (subsequent to the empowerment through a reformed school education structure) has to be tied to overall skills requirements. This necessitates a comprehensive occupational classification based on current realities and those that envisaged development could produce.  In other words we need to know what kind of human resources we need, envisage the needs down the line and ensure that these ‘needs’ do not compromise the fundamentals of education — a solid enough foundation in the sciences, mathematics, social sciences and humanities regardless of whether or not direct arrows can be drawn from courses to jobs.  

Unfortunately, we are stuck in a mindset that’s best exemplified by the confusion betrayed by the Minister of Higher Education. The preference has been for uttering truisms, misunderstand and misarticulating the problem, addressing piece of it and in an ad hoc manner, and leaving things by and large unchanged. 

We can and must do better.  Please take note Nagananda Kodituwakku, Rohan Pallewatte, Gotabhaya Rajapaksa, Patali Champika Ranawaka, Ranil Wickremesinghe, Maithripala Sirisena and any other individual entertaining hopes of becoming the next President of Sri Lanka.

Other articles in this series:




Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer. malindasenevi@gmail.com








09 October 2012

And 6% is the new word for ‘No’…



Dr. Nirmal Ranjith Devasiri has already claimed victory.  The President of the Federation of University Teachers’ Associations (FUTA) says that the issue of education and especially allocations for the sector is now a matter of public concern and has been recognized as such by the people. This, he says, is a significant victory.  

It remains to be seen whether such ‘recognition’ is all that FUTA extracts after several months of agitation.  As things stand, it is likely that both FUTA and the Government will reach some kind of compromise.  In the very least the salary issue would be addressed in some way as to satisfy FUTA.   

It is unrealistic to expect that the Government will give in to the much talked of ‘6%’ demand, not least of all for its lack of logic.  However, for the impasse to be broken, the Government will have to give some form of assurance that a greater equivalent portion of the GDP will be allocated for education.  As of now, neither the Government nor FUTA seems interested in a comprehensive overhaul of education policy with a view to more rational resource allocation, so hopes on that account must be shelved for another day, another struggle. 

In these confrontations it is normal for all parties to step back claiming victory.  Humility and a sense of the larger tasks of nation building help, but cannot be counted on.  Politics is a weak, small-minded and insecure creature, after all.  All parties will draw lessons, including those who are not ‘sided’.   Even if there is no resolution, everyone will draw lessons, re-evaluate position and develop strategy to achieve stated or amended ends. 

So what of the ‘6%’?  It is a slogan of the finest order.  It captures some but not the all of the ‘struggle’, is made for multiple use (t-shirts, profile pictures on Facebook for example) and panders to that eminently human attribute of asking for more, or rather, the impossible.  It also served to expand what is a demand that smacks of greed (salary increase) into something that can legitimately be painted with public-interest color.  Brilliant. 

Naturally, even as there are hurrahs for being advertising savvy, there are allegations of irresponsibility and a compromising of the integrity expected of university teachers.  But that’s only one side of the 6% story. 

That number can be debated about, celebrated and reviled, bannered and leafleted.  It can be read as a convenient rallying point for internally displaced politicians. But the Government would be making a monumental blunder if it limited readings of ‘6%’ to this and nothing else.

That one-digit slogan, quite apart from its originality and creative finesse, must also be read as the new word for ‘no’, i.e. for dissent, for disenchantment, for anger, for fear and for hope.  No one, not even the most popular leader or a government that did the ‘impossible’ (defeating the LTTE, for example) is error-free.  Popularity ebbs.  Regime-fatigue gets heavier as the years go by.  In this instance, there are so many things ‘wrong’ about this Government and the way it handles certain issues that only a diehard loyalist or consciously blind individual would claim that it enjoys the support of a vast majority of people. 

In the very least, even those who may have voted for the ruling party would be hard pressed to say ‘everything is great’.  The slogan, ‘6%’, provided an opportunity and continues to be a platform for those who are unhappy to express objection.  It would be foolish if the Government chooses to think that those who took part in the FUTA March were gullible or that they walked for bucks (‘from NGOs’, as some have claimed).

There are many among those who marched (literally) and many among those who march still (figuratively) who while not being card carrying members of the UNP, JVP or any other political party, are certainly not ready to give this Government a blank check. 

The FUTA agitation may or may not end soon.  It may take a different form if resolution evades the parties or the parties evade resolution for whatever reason.  It may end.   With it, the placards and T-shirts carrying the ‘6%’ legend might disappear.  The number followed by the percentage sign, however, will continue to represent something more than what its authors intended, i.e. not just objection to education policy and budgetary allocation, but objection to the way things are and the way things are done (and not done). 

It is a sign.  An ominous sign.  It is a message that must be read and read accurately too.  It would be folly for the President and Government to refuse to do so.  Arrogance costs.  That’s a history lesson that one does not need to attend Dr. Devasiri’s  lectures to learn. 

01 October 2012

Dissolving governments and insoluble people


Look who got the front-row seats at the end of the Long March!

Dr. Nirmal Ranjith Devasiri, President of the Federation of University Teachers’ Association (FUTA) came up with a classic re-quote (i.e. from Bertold Brecht): ‘Although the Government accuses us of falling pretty to the designs of various political parties, our union action is not about regime-change but affecting democratic social transformation, not of bringing a new government to power but to obtain a new public, a new people that can comprehend well the existing social injustice.’

The condescension about public intelligence aside, it is nevertheless an admirable stand to take.  FUTA, for all its many flaws, has made a mark for itself, thanks largely to Devasiri’s leadership.  The march from Galle to Colombo was disciplined and conducted with minimal inconvenience to the general public.  This is all the more significant considering that the parties that marched with FUTA by both habit and intent wanted otherwise and moreover had the arm-twisting options of capital and numbers.  Devasiri is reported to have said that if the lines were broken, they could leave.  That is courage, conviction, the spirit of democracy and exceptional leadership.  Salutations are in order!

The following Facebook status message is symptomatic of public angst and hope: I don’t care (if) FUTA is ‘sensational’ coz it is not just some Silva’s drama, but something worth ‘sensationalizing’ for publicity!’

This was my response: ‘True..it’s not some Silva’s drama, but drama nevertheless.  Not a great script, poor acting, some shady ‘producers’ and all that…but still, there are good people, honest intention and decency. That’s something to cheer.’

This was endorsed: ‘What I meant was it is for a worthy cause’.  And I elaborated, ‘”6%” is part of the sensationalism.  That’s not ‘cause’ but ‘effect’.  There is a lot of MIS-education about this free education business (but) the Government is the FIRST Respondent in this case.

FUTA doesn’t have much of a case when it comes to the salary issue.  This is perhaps why it expanded the political ground by sidelining the legitimate pertaining to union action and choosing a wider platform, free education.  They went further, or perhaps narrower, with the ‘6% demand’ (i.e. a 6% of GDB equivalent as allocation for education).  Out went the details.  Out went sober economic analysis.  In came the matter of throwing more money into a flawed program, an eventuality that would most certainly exacerbate the problem.  FUTA asked for the moon and called it ‘free’.  Good for politics, bad for ethics.  FUTA marketed ‘free education’ and kept mum on responsibility.  Good for politics, bad for the future. 

For all this (perhaps necessary) frilling, there’s something about this agitation that is solid.  Hollow as the slogans are, the spark that might become a fire is real enough.  That spark has been misnamed, but it is about policy or rather the lack of it.  The Government is the First Respondent here.  No question about it.  Just as the 17th Amendment, flawed though it was, was nevertheless the best intervention at obtaining better governance in almost 25 years and therefore deserved salutation, FUTA’s position and action remains the best chance for getting the education policy right.  Sparks can create infernos. They can also light lamp that dispel darkness.  I don’t see the Government getting any lamps ready.

This is what makes Nirmal’s Brechtian an important sentiment that also points to crisis as well as solution.  Politicians just won’t do it, and so the people must.  It is a lovely idea of course.  Where it falls flat is on the uneven map of the political.  At least in this instance.

The March was disciplined, but coherence of objective was absent.  There were UNP supporters screaming ‘Ape anagatha nayakathumaata jayaweva (Victory to our future leader)!’ That’s Sajith Premadasa.  The front seats of the rally were reserved for UNP stalwarts.  Nirmal had center stage of course and as a people’s and power-to-people kind of articulator one can stretch the point and say that the parties (UNP and JVP) were off-staged. 

It also happened in the early 1990s, friends.

Academics, journalists, NGO personalities and other activists took to the streets.  It was not Chandrika Kumaratunga’s party they attended.  She was just one more party to the euphoria of the possible.  In 1994, there was an election.  The party-makers turned into voters.  The ‘backers’ ran for election.  They went to Parliament.  End of story. 

‘Making’ a ‘new’ people is not easy.  Political parties don’t want people to be ‘new’.  Nirmal has got the line right.  He has to get the people right too.  He is getting the Right people and they are not in love with anything but markets and capital.  He has asked for pledges regarding free education.  Chandrika was not asked to pledge, but she did vow to abolish the executive presidency.  Nirmal can count on follower-naivetĂ© but that’s not the way to go about making a ‘new’ people. 
It is the ‘government’ after all that according to Brecht dissolves the people and appoints another one.  Governments can do that.  Insoluble people are rare.  They will be there at the end.  And they are enough.  Innocence is a necessary ingredient in all this.  It is not sufficient. 

23 September 2012

Nobody’s children belong to us all



Vasudeva Nanayakkara, Minister of National Languages and Social Integration, is reported to have made a thought-provoking observation on the current crisis in higher education.  A group of professionals had solicited the minister’s opinion on the tug-o-war between the Government and the Federation of University Teachers’ Associations (FUTA) over multiple grievances and demands articulated by the latter.  Nanayakkara had said that the whole drama reminds him of Bertold Brecht’s celebrated play ‘The Caucasian Chalk Circle’.

The story itself has multiple residences, with various versions of it being articulated in different languages and different cultural settings.  It’s about the ownership of a child.  There are two claimants, the biological mother (who abandoned the child) and the foster-mother who took care of the abandoned child.  The shrewd judge asks the two claimants to pull the child.  The foster-mother, in this instance, not wanting the child hurt, allows the biological mother to ‘win’ the battle.  The judge determines that she loves the child and that she deserves custody. 

Whose child is education?  Whose children’s future is at stake here?  There are multiple children involved here, one can argue.  Every child is a child that’s being pulled.  Every fetus in every womb is being pulled in different directions.  Part of the tragedy is that even if there was no pulling each and every child is made to suffer multiple anxieties by the very fact that it is born into and grows up in a house that is totally out of order.  Sadder still is the fact that the ‘pullers’ themselves were once children subjected to the very same anxieties. 

This is a sick child in the proverbial chalk circle. Unlike in the story, it is hard to determine which of the contestants is mother and which the foster-mother.  Both claim motherhood and consequent ‘rights’ of ownership.  A hundred and one arguments can be submitted by both claimants to support their respective cases.  The truth is that neither is parent, but both are part-time guardians. Parentage is not what matters but the fact that a sick child is being pulled apart, limb by limb, and for all the love professed by all claimants resolution of the dilemma is as distant as it was when the pulling began.  And for all the claims made and all the love professed, one cannot ignore the fact that the ‘pullers’ are largely self-serving individuals trading barbs and banking on the currency of rhetoric. 

Vasudeva Nanayakkara has opined that it is the Government that really owns the child.  Ownership notwithstanding, the larger responsibility lies with the Government, not FUTA.  If FUTA is a paid nurse, it is the Government that pays its salary and the Government that has to decide how to bring up the child.  The Government does not seem to care how the child grows up. 

The people can vote governments out. Employers can sack errant employees.  But this issue will not be sorted out that way.  A bad rash is not cured by changing nappies or by sacking nurses.   It is a problem of salaries and of fund allocation, yes.  It is also a problem of horrendous mismatches between curriculum and employability, an overemphasis on rights and underplaying of responsibility, politically motivated appointments and the inflation of unreasonable hope, focus on overcoming today’s headache while ignoring a malignant tumor, a fascination with criticism and unpardonable aversion to self-appraisal. 

Four months into the battle the contestants are still engaged in sledging, engaged in various forms of one-upmanship.  We have a case of adults behaving like spoilt brats. They are not fit to take care of children.  The sad thing is that they must.  It is not a case of one party letting go because a) the child is sick, and b) the ‘winner’ is incompetent. 

It is time to start from scratch.  ‘Scratch’ begins with correct diagnosis.  It includes a complete evaluation of the baby’s health and a sober consideration of all treatment options, not just to make one symptom disappear but to cure all ills and make the baby healthy enough to survive in a harsh environment. 

The baby belongs to us all.  And indeed each and every single one of us is that baby being pulled apart. 

Four months into the battle, the child is starving.  Both are convinced that the other is vile.  Both are correct, sadly.  But this is not a matter of figuring out who is the bigger bad wolf.  This child has been neglected and allowed to pick up all kinds of diseases.  This child is dying and when the child dies, the nation dies.  At that point the pulling will cease because corpses are not pulled apart, they are carried.  No one will want this baby at that point. 


16 September 2012

Education: if no one is to be left behind….

Some Advanced Level question papers are set by professors, some not.  The Political Science paper was set by a professor who was once the Head of the Political Science Department in his university.  In this year’s paper the candidates were asked who wrote ‘Das Kapital’.  Within brackets was the Sinhala translation, ‘jaathinge dhanaya’ which, when translated back would be ‘Wealth of Nations’, the classic by Adam Smith.

It was not carelessness.  Before the paper was finalized, someone had pointed out the error.  The professor had re-checked with a senior lecturer in political science who had once been his student.  The ‘approver’ had brought in his assumed knowledge of German to support his former teacher.  The question stood.  The professor obviously doesn’t know his Marx, hasn’t read Das Kapital, has never heard of Adam Smith or ‘Wealth of Nations’.  The professor, interestingly, is a die-hard critic of the ruling party and has for decades been a staunch supporter of the UNP, reaping benefits of position when that party was in power. 
The above is no footnote to the education-salary drama being enacted by the Federation of University Teachers’ Associations (FUTA) and various Government representatives.  It speaks to deeply entrenched problems in the entire education system which will not be resolved by simply pumping more money. 

Crises are moments that can be used and abused.  FUTA is for overall reform and not just salary hikes, apparently.  So far, apart from a few cursory and unfleshed recommendations, the fixation has been on obtaining the equivalent of 6% of the GDP for education.  The Government is operating as though it wants the strike ended by hook or by crook.  We don’t see any sign of anyone in the Government using the opportunity to review the entire education policy.  There are, however, things that both parties ought to think about.
We have three kinds of health care and three kinds of education: primary, secondary and tertiary.  In the health sector, Sri Lanka is way ahead of most of the world in terms of access to health care and education.  It’s not only about how much money is spent or the equivalent of the GDP percentage spent, but also about how many people benefit.  It is about affordability.  It is about a mix of private and public that makes for the maximum coverage of the population.

The private sector provides primary, secondary and tertiary health care.  In education, the private sector has had a marked presence in primary and secondary areas, albeit largely unregulated with little concern on the part of the relevant state agencies about quality.  Quality-lack is of course not limited to private educational institutions.  The reason for private sector play is not just policy-sanction but the inability of the state to provide for all.  It applies to health and it applies to education. 
It is inexplicable then that the idea of private sector involvement in tertiary education is violently rejected by some.  The state can do better, yes.  Better streamlining and better investment of resources (including the injection of more funds of course) can see more students entering state run degree awarding institutions. That’s part solution, though.  An overall policy that upgrades all tertiary education facilities to degree awarding status perhaps by affiliating with relevant universities is a possible ‘easy’ (or ‘easier’) step in the right direction.  It must however be accompanied by a restructuring of courses based on an occupational classification that identifies and details the human resources needed well into the future given economic realities. 

Even that will provide space only for a fraction of those who qualify to enter university (through the A/Ls).  What are the others to do?  Neither the Government nor FUTA can say ‘hard luck!’ for no one should be ‘left behind’.  That would be akin to limiting surgeries only to state hospitals and telling about 80% of patient who really need surgery, ‘sorry, roll over a die!’ 
The truth is that many university lecturers don’t have the moral right to oppose private education because they benefit from it.  They engage in ‘private practice’ (reaching, research etc).  Just like doctors.  Even if the Government agreed to the FUTA demands and if all the additional money is used to expand the university system to accommodate more students, the vast majority of students who qualify to enter university will be left behind. 

The Government might not be interested in education (as FUTA claims), but FUTA cannot say ‘not our problem’ for it purports to be less interested in salary than in education (for all).  It must come up with some answers or be seen as just another set of self-serving, poorly qualified, ill-educated operators who complement well the self-serving, poorly qualified, ill-educated lot that make up the Government.
[Published in 'The Nation', September 16, 2012]

22 August 2012

The moral economy of academics

‘Governments are held to higher standards than terrorists’ is a line that was often used by LTTE apologists who routinely brushed aside criticism of the terrorists even as they demanded and conferred parity of status.  The proposition makes sense though.  By the same token, judges should be held to higher standards than ordinary citizens.  Academics should be more academic than non-academics.  Teachers and teachers’ unions should not behave like students and student unions.  From academics, moreover, by dint of professional training, one expects a greater degree of objectivity, close-to-comprehensive analysis, sober reflection and even more sober self-appraisal and so on. 

One expects more from academics (than from the government) because at this point FUTA (Federation of University Teachers’ Associations) is playing holier-than-thou.  This does not follow the logic of the LTTE-backers referred to above because government policy on education (and much else besides) is deplorable, a point which we have made frequently.  These thoughts are written down therefore in the firm belief that a FUTA with more integrity would not only be a boost to the larger struggle to obtain more allocations and better policy, but help bring some semblance of a scholar-culture to the university system.

A placard raised at recent FUTA protest a placard carried the legend ‘Prevent brain drain’, implying that if salaries weren’t raised, academics would migrate to greener pastures abroad.  No mention of the millions spent on FUTA members from cradle to academic position by way of midwife care, delivery, healthcare, education and loans at next-to-nothing interest rates.  Nothing on pay-back.   FUTA has joined hands with the JVP, a party that has caused untold damage to university property and wrecked education in ways that make them seem like blood-brothers of those who oppose free education for they make a huge case for privatization by their acts of vandalism and other antics.  The ghosts of Vice Chancellor, Colombo University, Prof. Stanley Wijesundera and Prof. Patuwatawithana, murdered for the ’in of trying to keep the universities open against the will of the JVP, have not haunted FUTA and this says a lot about FUTA’s integrity and politics.  

 Even as FUTA spokespersons rant and rave about the incompetency of the UGC and Examinations Department it was found recently that A/L papers set by academics have contained errors.  FUTA, in union-mode, is naturally silent about these things, but it is heartening to note that FUTA President, Dr. Dewasiri has acknowledged that those who set the papers must take responsibility for any errors therein.   

That’s hardly the story though.  I am wondering why no one in academe have ventured to speak on the gross happening within the fold as laid out in ‘Mage Naduwa Iwarai’ (My case is over), a no holds barred account of academe authored by Dr. Sarath Wijesuriya, Senior Lecturer, Sinhalese Department of the University of Colombo.  The sloth that pervades academe, the aversion to reading and research, manipulation for perks, misuse of research grants, promotion of favorites, rampant cases of conflict of interest in setting and marking papers for the near and dear and much more is laid out in the book, which was banned by the university until Wijesuriya sued and obtained redress.  It was a work of fiction, officially, but every member of FUTA knows that Wijesuriya’s ‘story’ is true. 

There are people who tweak the rules for personal benefit, even wrangling circulars to say that no MSc (except from AIT, Bangkok) can be considered for position of Senior Lecturer.  No guesses for who had the AIT degree!  FUTA has the scholar-ability to tell us that it is no coincidence and not about love-at-first-sight when academics marry recently appointed junior lecturers.  Much time is spent on getting ‘nominated’ for scholarships offered to the particular institution.  That politics is more important than the politics of ‘free education’.   There are faculties which are full of academics who obtained doctorates from Japan simply because JICA dishes out loans.  If JICA generosity was absent, one wonders who many would end up with PhDs!

Academics have been caught leaking exam papers to their blue eyed boys and girls. Some were caught stealing microscopes from the very faculty they work. Some were caught fixing video cameras in girls’ toilets. Hard disks of the university computers have made one way journeys to the homes of academics. Many ‘academics’ were found guilty of using their research grant money to buy furniture and build houses.  Many have produced documents little better than toilet paper in order to secure promotions and professorships.  In one instance a ‘preliminary’ study was submitted to secure professorial points!

The Internal Audit unit of Peradeniya has reports asking some Senior Lecturers to pay as much as Rs. 6 million ‘misappropriated’ during the medical exhibition.  Indeed, some sociologist could peruse the records of the internal audit units of all universities and write a classic about the culture of theft, misappropriation, loss of dignity and intellectual dishonesty that pervades the university system.  Those who study literature might even consider dislodging some fiction and replacing some fact in the syllabus for more informed and insightful perusal by students. FUTA can tell us how many of its members were investigated by these internal audit departments. 

FUTA is fighting for moral high ground. Why then is this community so terrified of scrutiny?  Forget scrutiny, shouldn’t FUTA start with sober self-appraisal?  Cannot FUTA tell us how many of its members got their jobs courtesy of political clout, sexual favors and other non-academic ways?  How many have been caught, will FUTA say, submitting false or fraudulent certificates to prove they have higher degrees (Remember 13 day PhD?)? How many go behind politicians for consultancies, advisory posts etc?

FUTA is in competition with itself in this moral-high-ground match.  The university depends on the public.  FUTA is seeking public support.  The honest and decent thing to do is to come clean.  Until then, FUTA will flounder in its battle with the Ministry, the UGC and the Treasury, all institution which, we can safely say, are made up of people who can rub shoulders with the academics as same-clan fellows. 

FUTA can and must lead the way for education reform, for among its members are those who have the minds and the hearts.  They are being dragged down by the mediocre, slothful and dishonest.  Pity. 

[a version of this article was published in 'The Nation', August 19, 2012]