Showing posts with label TULF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TULF. Show all posts

16 May 2018

And it all began with ‘Sinhala Only’ ok?



The root cause. People like to throw that phrase around when talking about problems and their resolutions. It’s a decent enough proposition, the assumption being that if root causes are identified and fixed, not only will the problem be sorted but its reincarnation, so to speak, would be preempted.  

The problem with root causes is that it naturally takes us to the past. That’s about history and archaeology, literally and metaphorically.  This takes us to readings, subjectivity, the distortion caused by outcome preferences and such.  It also comes down to how far down you want to dig, because some roots go a long way down and their excavation can not only be arduous but can reveal truths that make the particular digger uncomfortable.

Take the ‘ethnic’ conflict for example.  Where does one begin? The year 1983 and the July riots is a valid ‘beginning’ to some.  Even that can be written in many ways.  One can focus on the role of the then UNP Government, the deployment of the party’s trade union arm, the Jathika Sevaka Sangamaya (JSS) and the non-deployment of forces that could have effectively prevented or at least minimize loss of life and damage to property.  ‘It was just the Sinhala Buddhists who have racism, chauvinism and intolerance in their DNA doing their thing,’ some can say (as some have said). Recounting is also about exaggeration and down-playing, this too we know.

Was it 1977 when the TULF became the largest party in the Opposition? Was it 1976 and the Batakotte (Vadukkoddai) Resolution of the TULF? Was it 1975 when Prabhakaran murdered the SLFP Mayor of Jaffna Alfred Duraiappah?  How about 1949 when S.J.V. Chelvanayagam founded the Federal Party or 1939 when G.G. Ponnambalam made his (in)famous 50-50 demand? Shouldn’t we begin with the Pan Sinhala Cabinet that was set up under the Donoughmore Constitution in 1936, one might offer. How about how the British elevated the non-Sinhala and non-Buddhist sections of the population as per their divide-and-rule preference? When Ponnambalam Ramanathan demanded in the 1920s that the first university be set up in Jaffna, didn’t it indicated some kind of nascent Tamil chauvinism, one could ask. It was all because of Anagarika Dharmapala, someone might insist. Really, but then Arumugam Navalar’s Hindu Revivalism pre-dates Dharmapala, the latter being just 15 years old when the former died at the age of 57, another could counter.

“Forget all that! It’s Bandaranaike’s ‘Sinhala Only’ business in 1956 that set the country down this mad road to self-destruction. This and nothing else is the root cause. It is the Mother of all Root Causes, in fact!”

Somehow, over the years, this ‘Sinhala Only is the only Root’ has taken root. Now if this were the true root then dealing with it makes absolute sense. If, on the other hand, it is not 'The Root’ or if it is only ‘One of Many Roots’ then rooting for it amounts to barking up the wrong tree, so to speak. 

An exhaustive exploration would have to examine all claims and weigh their weight in the conflict-equation. Each has merit and each, in isolation, tells a partial story. We also need to seek out the less talk of and the absented in all this. Having said that, let’s consider this Sinhala Only Root.

‘Sinhala Only’ is the term used for the Official Language Act No. 33 of 1956.  It replaced English as the official language of Ceylon with Sinhala. A language that’s mother-tongue to almost two-thirds of a population is as ‘national’ as any. When it is spoken by a further 10-15% there’s no question about its primacy. That said, it was not only ill-conceived but went against the grain of the philosophy embedded in the coinage of the name ‘Sinhala’, which comes from Siv-Hela, or the 4 Helas (Yaksha, Raksha, Naga and Deva), essentially speaking of and to integration and accommodation as opposed to exclusivity.  

It is not taken that way by many Sinhalese, this has to be acknowledged.  S.W.R.D. Bandaranaike, a demagog and a political manipulator if ever there was one, played to the worse sentiments of this community. His wife did not, but his daughter went to the other extreme, vilifying Sinhalese and Buddhists in a way that the United National Party has never done; but that’s a different story.

Why did the Sinhalese embrace ‘Sinhala Only’ and why were they ready to drop it and acknowledge that Tamil should also be a national language?  The ‘root cause’ of all that, I offer, is the English Only that preceded that ill-conceived and ill-formulated act in 1956.  

English was the language of the conqueror, who was also a mass murderer, a brigand, sacker of villagers, poisoner of wells and reservoirs, breacher of dams and perpetrator of cultural genocide and ethnic cleansing. Guess who perished in all that? The Sinhalese (god damn them, should we add?)!

English was also the vehicle used by those forces that came along with the gun-toting thugs from Britain ready to ‘civilize the heathens’ not only by making religious conversion a prerequisite for education and employment but even razing temples and kovils to the ground, burning libraries and stealing manuscripts.  

Bandaranaike brought ‘Sinhala Only’ against that history. Naturally the majority of the disenfranchised found in the proposal an opportunity for betterment.  It is easy to say, after the fact,  that he could have included Tamil and need not have dumped English, but that won’t get us anywhere.  

What’s relevant is that this lack of vision only served to alienate Tamils while doing little to uplift the lot of the Sinhalese because the structures of control remained English-laden. Things have not changed over the years. Opportunity is spelled in English, so to speak.  The simple truth that there’s a way to lose culture and self by dropping mother-tongue and there’s a way to deny oneself the advantages of being fluent in other languages by misplaced send of identity and nationalism.  

In any case, it was a landmark for reasons other than this root-cause business (which, arguably, it is not).  And if one was hesitant to accept one cause for multiple problems, if one were ready to consider the multiplicity of causes and the complexities of historical processes and the outcomes they generated, there’s nothing more simplistic, erroneous and dangerous as reducing our ills to ‘Sinhala Only’.  Indeed, I offer, that ‘English Only’ has a better case (though incomplete) for the title ‘Mother of all Root Causes’.

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer. malindasenevi@gmail.com.  www.malindawords.blogspot.com  

17 February 2015

Resolving to hate

C.V. Wigneswaran just another Appapillai Amirthalingam?
The Northern Provincial Council (NPC) has passed a resolution charging successive governments of perpetrating genocide on Tamils in Sri Lanka.  For a Council that has an ex-judge of the Supreme Court as Chief Minister the interjection of the word ‘genocide’ is mischievous at best.  

If language legislation in 1956 amounts to‘genocide’ then clearly Mr Wigneswaran does not understand the meaning of the word.  The point is, Wigneswaran does understand and therefore discredits the document and in the end does much disservice to legitimate grievances of the community he claims to represent.

The resolution is symptomatic of the disease that has always plagued Tamil Nationalism: exaggeration.  It does two things. First it amounts to rabble-rousing and preys on the most base of human sentiments.  It encourages extremism and empowers extremists.   Secondly, it ensures that whatever support you may have from those in other communities will erode simply because you’ve lost the legitimacy that comes from keeping your articulation within the dimensions of reality.  Together, they make for entrenchment of ‘hard lines’.   

There is no argument in the contention that Tamil people in this island suffered.  It would be as hard to dispute that their suffering can be attributed to one community and one community alone.  Wigneswaran who at one time was a member of a panel of judges that sentenced LTTE leader Velupillai Prabhakaran to a 200 year prison term would know that the men who is party (Tamil National Alliance) affirmed were the ‘sole representatives of the Tamil people’ abducted Tamil children, murdered Tamil politicians, professionals and leaders of rival groups. He knows who held hundreds of thousands of Tamils hostage in the last stages of the armed conflict.  He also knows who saved them. 

Pointing the finger in one direction and pretending to be blind to crimes perpetrated by members of one’s own community against others in that very same community makes it hard to embrace such resolutions as being informed by moral and ethical consideration.  Do that and you cannot whine if those in the community you charge with ‘genocide’ decide to treat you as a third-rate rabble-rousing politician who is not interested in things like peace, reconciliation, inter-ethnic harmony and such. 

Wigneswaran and the TNA must not forget that it was not the Tamil community alone that suffered.  They should not forget that it was not only Tamils who spoke about the legitimate grievances of Tamils.  As of now, when the TNA refuses point blank to use existing space for airing legitimate grievances, the claim of being ‘lesser citizens’ does, ironically, gain credence not as something conferred but as something desired or at least acquired by choice. 

Spokespersons of this government, ruled by a coalition of which the TNA is a constituent, have expressed regret over the statement and its tendentious wording.  One might say this is the best the government can do given the tenuous nature of the governing arrangement, but there will be those who call it ‘wimpy’ or worse, ‘an insult to everyone who died in the last 30 years’.  The TNA is clearly sharpening knives of separatism.  And if truth and reconciliation are important (as the regime has often stated) then spades should be called spades. 

Wigneswaran, the so-called ‘moderate,’ is acquiring Tiger stripes at an alarming rate and clearly without his conscience being pricked on account of inconsistency, the shameless uttering of falsehoods, mislabeling of myth as history and conjecture as fact.  It just wrecks the search for truth because few would want to make conversation with such people. 

If this is what a former judge of the Supreme Court can do, what can one expect from others in the NPC?  Those who truly desire to reconcile and move on in the Tamil community are fast being marginalized.  The self-labeled ‘moderates’ of an earlier avatar of Tamil Nationalism, the Tamil United Liberation Front played this very same game.  Wigneswaran knows what happened to them.  Everyone knows the costs incurred by all communities.  We need not go into all that.  We need not walk that path again. 




18 March 2012

Reconciliation cannot be a single-hand clap

Two statements from two high profile US officials caught my eye this week.  The first was by US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, commenting on the brutal massacre of 16 Afghans by a US soldier.  Describing it as ‘awful’ and ‘terrible’, expressing ‘shock and sadness’, Clinton claimed, ‘this is not who we are!’

Astounding!  It can’t be that Clinton has been blind to what US Foreign Policy has been and is.  She knows that this particular crime against humanity is just one of thousands. She knows that if there was ‘randomness’ here and if it was about an errant soldier, for each such random act by each erring private, there are a thousand policy-driven, deliberate and horrendous crimes against humanity. War crimes, all. 

Staff Sgt Robet Bales, the man who perpetrated the butchery, is a highly decorated American soldier. ISAF Deputy Commander, Lt. Gen. Adrian Bradshaw said, ‘I cannot explain the motivation behind such callous acts, but they were in no way part of authorized ISAF military activity’.  Bales is said to have ‘left Base without authorization’.  There’s a palpable downplaying and refuge-seeking in the doctrine of ‘errant soldiering’. 

The fact is that when US Drones ‘left base’ it was POLICY.  When they targetted ‘perceived terrorists’ and claimed that it was legitimate even when the said target was in the midst of a high-density civilian population, it was POLICY.  It was POLICY, also, when a million Iraqi children were MADE TO DIE courtesy sanctions on that country.  Torture in Guantanamo Bay is POLICY.  Two quotes will explain it all. 

Madeline Albright, one time US Secretary of State, commenting on US-led sanctions causing the death of so many children, said, ‘it was worth it’.  US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, commenting on the Afghan incident said, ‘War is hell, these things happen’.  

The truth is, for the USA, random acts of butchery and policy-driven crimes against humanity are both ‘part of the story’.  Obama famously said, after all, ‘we do what we have to do, let’s not talk about it’.  It is a criminal policy regime where perception is treated as fact and any amount of collateral is acceptable. 
The second quote comes from the US Assistant Secretary of State for South and Central Asian Affairs, Robert O Blake.  He says, ‘unless Sri Lanka's government reconciles with minority Tamils and addresses allegations of war crimes it risks renewed conflict’.

This comes in the context of a US sponsored resolution in the UN Human Rights Council clearly seeking to open the door for direct interference in Sri Lanka by the USA, in complete violation of the spirit and regulations of that assembly.  It also coincided with a ‘new’ video released by Channel 4 on Sri Lanka. 

The Channel 4 ‘new’ footage is actually a re-hash of its earlier ‘production’ and mostly made up of material that has been in the public domain for several years, including in the Defence Ministry website.  Comment would be a waste of words at this point.   

Reconciliation, though, is our business.  Suggestions are welcome of course, but a fist in the pie usually takes away all and leaves just the crumbs.  Secondly, reconciliation is not a single-hand clap.  Even if one were to be out-of-mind democratic about it, then there are at least two parties here.  The LTTE committed horrendous crimes against humanity and its still-alive-proxies (TNA, GTF, BTF and people like Paikiasothy Saravanamuttu who is dining with the cassocked terrorist Fr (sic) Emmannuel in Geneva and getting character certificates to boot) know what the LTTE did.  All communities suffered at the hands of the LTTE.  If Eelam Tamils need ‘closure’ then other do too.  If you want accountability, it cannot be part accountability.  If you want to investigate, you cannot investigate just one part of the story. 

The evidence about ‘policy-led’ excesses by the Government forces makes a pretty thin portfolio.  Nothing like Obama and Clinton watching (live) the murder of an unarmed Osama bin Laden along with the point-blank shooting of a child in Pakistan where ‘chain of command’ is established beyond a shadow of doubt. 

Reconciliation is our business, let me reiterate.  The LLRC gives the road map and action has been taken immediately, via the AG’s Department and the Courts of Inquiry appointed by the Army and Navy.  How about something from the TNA, now?  They could submit a dossier of LTTE atrocities and a sober apology on account of complicity, perhaps.  

The ‘this side’ hand has shown far more willingness to clap, but the TNA hand is hidden.  You don’t get reconciliation that way, Mr. Blake.  All atrocities need to be investigated fully and the perpetrators brought to book.  Suresh Premachandra, for example, was in charge of a military arm of a militant group that recruited 2500 children and caused 700 of them to be murdered in cold blood by the LTTE, from whom R. Sampanthan took his orders (willingly and happily). 

There may very well be a renewal of conflict.  Everyone will suffer, the Tamils in the North and East the most.  It won’t even pinch the pro-Eelam sections of Tamils in other countries.  It will hurt only Sri Lankans.  And that, Bob, would not be because of anything this government does or does not do, because this government for all its faults has done a lot more than its predecessors to get this country back on track.  The TNA is not helping.  You are not, either.  It won’t cost you sleep, we know.  We know that sleep-loss is not possible for those who think nothing of perpetrating crimes against humanity, those war-is-war people. 

Reconciliation is our business.  It involves honesty.  By all parties.  The country is waiting on the TNA to get out of its LTTE shell.  Sampanthan and Sumanthiran are putting together a show. It is called, ironically, ‘no show’.  You don’t get reconciliation that way.  

[First published in The Nation, March 18, 2012]