Showing posts with label Victory Day. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Victory Day. Show all posts

19 May 2016

The 18th of May 2009 and the battle over meaning

Thrishantha Nanayakkara once said ‘All wars have been fought twice; once in the battlefield and once down the alleys of memory’.  This is true.  The battle today is about remembrance.  It’s not just about commemoration but about meaning.  It’s about definitions.  It is about post-war language. 

The National Peace Council (NPC) issued a statement in 2014 with a nice line: ‘No wise country celebrates war victory after a civil war’.  Civil war, did they say?  Well, Pabalu Wijegoonawardane is not really responding to the NPC but he offers a valid observation: ‘ආ... දැන් අපේ එක සිවිල් වෝ එකක් ලු.... ඔසාමා බින් ලාර්ඩන් ට ගහපු එක 'වෝ ඔන් ටෙරර්' ලු... නඩුත් හාමුදුරුවන් ගෙ බඩුත් හාමුදුරුවන් ගෙ ලු...” (Alright, it seems that ours was a civil war…attacking Osama bin Laden was [part of] ‘the war on terror’… what this means is that things are defined as pleases the definer).


Whether the NPC likes it or not, whether the other NPC (Northern Provincial Council) likes it or not, whether those whose outcome preferences did not materialize like it or not, the 18th day of May, 2009 was historic.  

 It was a landmark moment in the history of the country and indeed the history of this century.  You can call what preceded a ‘civil war’ and that is up for debate mind you, but it would be hard to deny that what was defeated was terrorism and a terrorist organization. 


Now we can argue whether or not it is appropriate to mark that day with a show of military strength.  I, for one, believe that is silly.  However, in the politics of war-related language and literature, dismissing any celebration as a ‘celebration of war’ or a ‘celebration of killing’ or as ‘triumphalism’ is just that: political.  It is political and politically pernicious, because what that day signifies is not just the defeat of terrorism (a legitimate reason to celebrate, one can argue).


Sri Lanka did not suddenly transform into Paradise on the 18th of May, 2009, this is true. A lot of ugliness that ‘war’ had helped push to the margins of civic consciousness surfaced (naturally) once the blanket called battle was removed.  That too is a cause for celebration. And how was the right and space to celebrate such things was obtained? Why, by defeating the LTTE! Celebrate that!  


Of course there was much that was recovered that warrants celebration.  No more bombs.  Shouldn’t we cheer that?  No more fear for the fate of loved ones we say ‘bye’ to in the morning.  Cause for cheer?  No more wondering all day if when you get home you’ll received some bad news about a child or a parent or a friend.  Shouldn’t we be happy?  No more checkpoints, no more tension when traveling or when in crowded places.  No more having to wonder if every bag, briefcase, school satchel or even what looks like a lunch packet contains or is a bomb.  No more wondering if anyone around you is a suicide bomber.  The list goes on.


But what of those who are crying foul over people remembering and being glad about the military and political drive that gave us that day of relief? And what of the people they claim to represent?

Well, the likes of Wigneswaran, Sampanthan and the rest of the separatist core of the Tamil National Alliance, got their tongues unfettered did they not?  The democratic Tamil nationalist voice even if it prefers to utter chauvinistic and land-grabbing rhetoric have recovered voice.  How? Well, thanks to certain things that happened and which brought about ‘The 18th of May, 2009’.  They can be glad that their Tamil brethren are not being dragged hundreds of miles to provide a human shield for a bunch of thugs, can’t they?  And the children!  They aren’t being abducted and forcibly conscripted to kill and to die, are they?  They can be pleased that it is now possible for people to walk around without wondering if they would fall victim to a landmine.  The Tamil Nadu fishermen notwithstanding, the livelihoods of fisherfolk are now secured. 


There was none of this before May 18, 2009.  Thus there is cause for celebration, with or without caveat as dictated by political preferences. 


Of course if it were only about celebration and doing nothing about grievances (real) and aspirations (reasonable) or about real (as opposed to heavily politicized and therefore people-less) reconciliation, then it would certainly be a hollow exercise.  The hollowness notwithstanding, though, celebration is a right of those who believe there is just cause.  It can be belittled or vilified, as the NPC and the TNA and fellow travelers of politics that talked of talking to terrorists (read: submitting to terrorism) do, respectively, but commemoration there will be.  There’s thanksgiving that has little to do with political colors or personalities, some of it out of the limelight. 


Denying voice does not help.  The Tamils who wish to grieve or call for mourning have the right to do so.  By the same token anyone who believes that the 18th of May, 2009 brought relief, opened the space for democratization, greater freedoms and most of all allowed us to stop worrying about bombs and bullets, has every right to celebrate, one way or another.  


The children of this country are sleeping better now than they did before the 18th of May, 2009.  Parents are worrying less.  Sure, other nightmares and worries will trouble.  Sure, we cannot guarantee that there will be no more wars.  However, we do know that the 18th day of May in the year 2009 made a difference to all our lives. A positive difference, even if we may not have liked those who actually brought about that difference.  

This article was published in the Daily Mirror on May 19, 2016.  

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer.  Email: malindasenevi@gmail.com. Twitter: malindasene.

17 May 2016

Truth and reconciliation must begin with truth, not myth

This article was published in 'The Nation' on May 18, 2010, one year after the LTTE was militarily defeated.  The end of terrorism did not coincide with the end of separatist moves of course.  That project whose military articulation was defeated is alive.  What the end of the war did was to create a space for the necessary conversation about claims and substantiation.  That's an important part of reconciliation.  Today, 6 years later, the key spokespersons for the politics that the LTTE buttressed with terrorism, still prefer myth to truth.  [Read 'The NPC Resolution: both a threat and an opportunity' ]

Pic courtesy irinnews.org
Last week marked a year after the war ended.  There’s been some dispute regarding the exact date and it is quite unbecoming of the claimants to be quibbling about whether it happened on the 18th or 19th of May.  What is important is that it happened, it ended, that our children are safe from suicide bombs and explosions, from forced conscription, dismemberment, displacement and death in a war that achieved precious little.  Yes, the celebrations were put off due to inclement weather, but that’s nothing to be sad about.  There are a million reasons to be thankful and a million ways to show gratitude. 

We are talking about a war that dragged on for 30 years.  We are talking about a situation where academics (sic!) argued even as recently as a little more than a year ago that it is wrong to talk of a post-LTTE Sri Lanka.  Some columnists were so ostrich-like (like Kumar David) that they refused to entertain the thought that the LTTE could be defeated. 

Denial is a sign, a symptom of a malady.  It’s about what one wants so badly or is so used to that its absence or non-arrival will not be talked about, thought of or heard.  Eelamists of the ‘Eelam Now’ mode of thinking and operating suffered from this ailment for some time.  They’re slowly getting cured.  Indeed they are more likely to drop Eelam and go for something more realistic and rewarding such as better governance and enhanced citizenship rights for all, irrespective of ethnic identity that that other and more pernicious set in the lunatic fringe of political discourse: those of the ‘Litte-Now, More-Later’ persuasion among the Eelamists. 

I count among these latter set everyone who argues for an ethnic-based and/or language-based system of power-devolution without referring to relevant history, on-the-ground realities (including the fact that some 53% of Tamils live outside the North and East, 64% of allocations for the Provincial Councils go for their upkeep and the salaries of politicians and staff, and claims of historical habitation that are full of holes) and indeed the fact that ‘devolution’ was essentially the TNA manifesto and not that of the UPFA or Mahinda Rajapaksa.

Today, one year later, the focus should be on realities and not myths.  The Tamil community in the North and East have suffered enough without having to become footballs in political soccer games played by their so-called representatives and political scientists (so-called) who would be hard pressed to differentiate between ‘unitary’ and ‘federal’ and would hee-haw if asked which type the Sri Lankan state is, with examples to buttress claim.

The question that remains unanswered with reasonable substantiation is the following: ‘what are the root causes of the conflict?’  A lot of books have been written on this issue.  Discrimination, non-addressing of grievance/aspiration etc have been cited. Left out has been the exploitation of the ‘ethnic card’ by communalists on all sides, the manufacturing of grievance, the exaggeration of claim, the holding to ransom at gun-point and the articulation of aspiration in dimensions that preclude resolution. 

A second important consideration that is fudged by devolution-wallahs is this: what is the connection between grievance(s) that can be established to be real and devolution?  If the territorial claims cannot be backed by history, if the demographic data shows that self-determination issues have spilled over the boundaries of the North and East (or indeed were never contained therein), then shouldn’t reason dictate that resolution must take a form that is non-territorial, and therefore non-devolutionary?

Conflict-End is a good place to soul-search, so to speak.  It is a good place to ask how we got to where we were and how come close to 100,000 people had to die to get there.  It is the place to begin, paradoxically.  And the beginning, as always, is called ‘Root Cause’.  This is where you will encounter grievance and aspiration.  This is where the intellectually slow and politically lazy politician (and political analyst of course) comes to excavate matter that can be abused for petty political gain.  Today, after 30 years, we have to chip away the frills that have got stitched on to root-cause and recover the real article. 

Today there is talk of truth and reconciliation.  We have our own truth-and-reconciliation methods, but that’s ok.  Truth is the key word here.  We’ve had so much embellishment and extrapolation, myth-making and myth-modelling, that it is ridiculous to try and re-coexist on the unsteady foundation that all this has served to set up over the past thirty years.  We have to re-lay the foundation of co-existence. And this can be done only by being honest.  That honesty, given claims have been as much about discrimination as about traditional homeland claim, requires a historical audit as well as an audit about citizenship anomalies.  It is then that we can figure out what kind of measures need to be put in place to correct flaws and prevent extrapolations that lead to the kind of tragedy that took us 30 years to bring to an end.

We must revisit all the pacts that were made, what held and what was fudged and by whom, all the underlying premises and their tenability in terms of historical, demographic and economic worth. In other words we have to find a way of divesting process of the most pernicious elements of politicking, which unfortunately seem to have dominated our post-Independence history.

Are we ready to face the truth, as individual, community and nation?  Are we ready to place contention on table along with substantiation and have a conversation? Or are we going to wobble along on that unsteady and eventually tragedy-facilitating thing called preferred ‘perception’?

If we cannot get past this, we cannot talk about devolution or any ‘lution’ and certainly not solution and revolution. 

The devolutionists must now put up and shut up.  Bring your history, bring the economic logic, bring the relevant demographic data and bring a comprehensive performance assessment of provincial councils.  Leave behind rhetoric, myth, fantasy and relevant models based on these things.  Bring grievance, not whine.  Let grievance wear its true clothes (i.e. skin) and not the disguises it has been decked with for purposes of political efficacy.  The nation is waiting. 


   

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer who can be reached at malinsene@gmail.com