Showing posts with label secularism in Sri Lanka. Show all posts
Showing posts with label secularism in Sri Lanka. Show all posts

06 May 2023

Charles’ coronation and secularists’ blues


Sunil Ariyaratne who wrote Nanda Malini’s celebrated song ‘Nidahas Baila’ got it all wrong when he claimed that no blood was shed in the struggle for independence from British rule. He claimed that no one was beaten, as Nehru and Patel were in British India and that no lives were sacrificed (as Mahatma Gandhi did).

Mahatma Gandhi didn’t really sacrifice his life for India’s independence. True, Indian leaders were assaulted and imprisoned, but so were the leaders of Sri Lanka’s independence struggle. Indians were killed, so were Sri Lankans, from before formal subjugation in 1815 right up to February 4, 1948. Tens of thousands were slaughtered. Fields and libraries were torched. Temples were razed to the ground and churches built in their place. Reservoirs and wells were poisoned. Brutes. That's what the British were. And that’s a soft word.

Sunil Ariyaratne got one thing right though. The ‘sudda' left and yet did not: sudda yanna giyeth nae nogihin hitiyeth nae. British diplomats frequently act as though they are unofficial viceroys. When they are not demanding that we subscribe to their version of our reality, they use sway in multilateral organisations to seek punishment for intransigence. There’s insult, humiliation and caustic condescension.    
I don’t blame them. A nation in circumstances so reduced that they operate in international forums as an adjunct of the USA needs some kind of validation. Having claimed that the sun would never set on the empire, it must be hard to accept sunsets. It must be even harder since they have to live with the fact that their current comforts derive from the brigandry of their ancestors who pillaged, sacked cities, enslaved and murdered people. Thieves have to conjure thievery and condemn theft to look good. They have no moral authority. Others do.

I don’t blame those Sri Lankan who still think, talk and act as though the British haven’t left. After all, President Ranil Wickremesinghe feels compelled to leave the country to attend the coronation right in the middle of Vesak. After all, Sajith Premadasa's father wrangled an additional invite for Charles' wedding when he was Prime Minister (President J R Jayawardene had a legit invite as Head of State) in 1982!

Five hundred years of colonialism could leave traces of servility. Moreover, if you and your ancestors played Uncle Tom for a century, deriving benefits in exchange for agreement to inhabit the version of reality authored by the oppressor and, as was common, conversion to the faith of the oppressor, it is not unnatural to look to the ‘mother country’ and its representatives for succour of one kind or another.

Now here’s the problem. Both parties, i.e. the viceroy wannabes and the empire-salaamists can't get enough of democracy. They can’t get enough of secularism. And now they have to deal with Charles’ coronation which makes a mockery of both.

First of all the viceroy wannabes are representing a monarchy which the empire-salaamists, well, all but salaam. Secondly, the whole circus is handled by the Archbishop of Canterbury who, we are told, will say that the Church of England ‘will seek to foster an environment in which people of all faiths may live freely.’  In contrast, Article 9 of Sri Lanka’s constitution (which ensures foremost place for Buddhism and pledges to protect and foster the Buddha Sasana) is effectively negated by Articles 10 and 14(1)(e). Nothing big-brotherly about it.

The monarch, at his coronation on May 6, 2023, will be asked by the archbishop to uphold the Church of England and he will duly pledge to do so while also solemnly stating that he is a faithful Protestant. That faith, by the way, is not adhered to by half the population or more.

Coronation! Medieval!

The jocularity of these individuals and the organisations they represent notwithstanding, there is certainly a case for secularism and democracy. History stands in the way, though. If history counts, that is.

The 1815 Convention included a clear pledge by the British to uphold the foremost place of Buddhism. They ignored this immediately. They not only pillaged temples, they built churches and launched massive proselytisation campaigns complemented by unethical conversion. It makes sense, therefore, for a restoration the moment the British left.

S W R D Bandaranaike’s demagoguery and cunning (to essentially copy-paste the left agenda) aside, the angst that enabled ‘1956’ can be traced to the deliberate, vicious and pernicious crusades against Buddhists orchestrated by the British and by and large consented to by leaders representing or identifying with other faiths or else went along envisaging personal political gain somewhere down the line. Don Baron Jayatilleka was an exception.

Here’s one example. The official list of public and bank holidays, 1910. 


Yes, 1910. Long before ’56. Long before independence. The Christian holidays: Good Friday and the following day, Easter Monday and Tuesday, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day and three subsequent days. That’s nine. Add the 52 Sundays and you get a whopping 61 days. Muslim holidays: Hadji Festival. Hindu holidays: Thai Pongal Day, Vel Festival and Dipawali (bank holidays). Buddhist holidays: Vesak. Get this: April 13th was a holiday: ‘Hindu New Year’s Festival.’  

Now consider the fact that although there were Tamil and Muslim elites (English educated, wealthy, upper caste and of the Christian faith) involved in the formal independence struggle, those who fought and died in their thousands from 1815 to 1948 were almost exclusively Sinhala Buddhists.  

That’s a lot of angst. ‘1956,’ then, one could argue was inevitable. In hindsight erroneous on certain counts though it is, the sheer numbers and the extent and nature of subjugation were sufficient preconditions, sufficient in terms of legitimacy too. Eminently logical in comparison with today’s realities in the UK a la the coronation.

But what of it? History is not cast in stone. We can throw it all away, someone might argue. Throw it all away and go with today’s reality!

Two problems. Today’s reality may change tomorrow. One can’t really legislate for every changed reality. Hey, the representatives of one community could ethnically cleanse another (as the LTTE ethnically cleansed Muslims from the Jaffna Peninsula) and then demand, ‘look, realities have changed, now re-legislate!’

Secondly, if history goes out of the window, so do any claims of ‘traditional.’ No history, no tradition, simple.

Want to secularise holidays even as you show respect to religious faiths? Sure. Designate religious holidays and permit any citizen to claim three (or four or any specific number) per year as religious holidays (like casual leave, sick leave etc). Others work. Take it to its logical conclusion and we might have to think of a weekend that excludes Sunday and Friday. But no holidays for Friday prayers, no leave on account of becoming a widow or widower or a divorcee. No extra maternity leave privileges for a particular community.

We are not a monarchy, but we have religions. There are percentages (without which we really shouldn’t talk about that kind of thing). We can be a country without any religious community having to feel marginalised, neglected or underprivileged. Informed, meaningful and logical secularism.  

Now that’s something for everyone talking about democracy and secularism to think about. 

Meanwhile, good luck Charles and better luck his subjects, his representative in Sri Lanka included. And Sunil Ariyaratne could write a new song about Sri Lanka. 
 

10 February 2020

Time to drop conservatives and conservatism


UNP parliamentarian Mangala Samaraweera is reported to have said that President Gotabaya Rajapaksa should not let conservative forces mislead him. 

Mangala got that one right. Literally. The issue is, it is doubtful that he understood the meaning of the word. So let’s deal with some definitions first. 

‘Conservative’ is an adjective. It means, 'averse to change or innovation and holding traditional values.’ It is also a noun, referring to someone who is averse to change and holds traditional values. So, there are some key words here we need to think about: change, innovation and tradition’

Now ‘tradition’ usually about transmitting customs or beliefs from generation to generation. Not necessarily bad, but in the political discourse that is in part framed by the colonial discourse, it has all kinds of negative connotations. The ‘traditional’ were called barbarians, heathens, philistines, uncivilized, uncultured, unsophisticated, vulgar, you name it. 

All negative. Not much is said about how the ‘civilized’ became civilized, and how in the name of civilization they destroyed cultures, plundered wealth, torched libraries, poisoned water sources, enslaved and massacred. 

Post-independence, the language changed. It was now about development and ‘underdevelopment,’ the latter sanitized as ‘developing’. Instead of ‘civilized’ we now had stuff like high incomes, high growth rates, growth-led development. Sure, they threw in ‘traditional knowledge’ and ‘sustainability’ and these were just words to sanitize above-board plunder, immiserization, wanton destruction of environment. Check out any development-related project proposal and you’ll find all these. Oh yes, they’ve added things like ‘aid effectiveness,’ ‘disaster mitigation’ and ‘climate change protocols.’ And of course ‘democracy,’ that intangible in whose name wars are declared, countries bombed into the middle ages and people slaughtered or corralled into refugee camps.

So when there’s talk of change and innovation, it's about transformation of societies and systems in ways that facilitate the same kind of plunder. In short, the sustained development of classes in places of advantage in an economy. In short, subsidizing capital interests. And when there’s talk of ‘conservatism’ it is about preserving the same system of plunder and destruction that has brought us genocide, cultural erasure, increasingly frequent ‘natural’ disasters, wars and deadly diseases. Mangala, in the process of defending his guarded praise for President Gotabaya Rajapaksa, tellingly, slips in the following caveat: ‘He should mention that there is no alternative but the economic policy of the previous government.’ 

Now THAT encapsulates the conservatism that Mangala is not interested in changing. THAT, also, is tradition now as far as the sway it has over all things economic, environmental and cultural. Innovation to entrench or further expand THAT is not wholesome, rather it is destructive, it diminishes and could even be called barbaric, uncivilized, uncultured, unsophisticated and vulgar. 

So what else has been ‘traditional’ in Sri Lanka, post-independence? Well, quite apart from the vilification of tradition, history, heritage and other things cultural, we have had the fixation about ‘Exclusive Tamil Homelands.’ Now persisting with THAT would not just be conservative but pandering to a downright lie. Interestingly those who champion such myth models, treating them as givens, are as insistence on the thesis, ‘history is version.’ So, some versions are ok, others are not. That’s conservative. 

So, we should not let conservative forces (which includes in these cases the likss of Mangala Samaraweera) mislead us (as they have for decades). There’s a whole lot of bunkum being passed off as god-given ‘solutions’ to all our ills. They include federalism and neoliberalism. Recent ‘traditions’ but traditions nevertheless. Archaic, based on falsehoods and proven to be untenable, unsustainable and even destructive. Advocates of such things are arch conservatives. They mislead. They should be ignored. 

There’s more. Another ‘tradition’ that’s persisted is the ballyhoo about secularism. It can be summarized as follows: bash the Sinhala Buddhists, rant and rave over Article 9 of the Constitution, maintain dead silence about the negation of the same in Articles 10 and 14 and, most importantly refuse to utter a single word about the Muslim Marriage and Divorce Act and other community-specific legislation that subvert all the lovey-dovey rhetoric of equality. Those who are ‘traditional’ in this sense, are also conservatives who have and continue to mislead leaders and the general public. Mangala is one among many.  

There’s more. How about the ‘tradition’ of being servile to the USA, UK and the EU? Mangala (in)famously took THAT conservatism (which is almost an article of faith of the UNP and of course the SLFP under Chandrika Kumaratunga) to a whole new level with Resolution 30/1 of the UNHRC. That kind of genuflection has become a tradition. That’s conservatism we can do without. Indeed it’s conservatism that impedes progress, subverts change and makes innovation impossible. We have had missions from the West acting as though they are de facto viceroys. We have had ‘aid missions’ that have arm twisted or else bribed politicians and officials to tailor national policy in ways that further their interests at the cost of national security (which includes food security, by the way). 

Dumping ‘National Interest’ has been a tradition for decades. Remember how that ‘great’ UNP leader, J.R. Jayewardene sold national interest down the river on July 31, 1987 to India? That’s another kind of conservatism; submitting to the will of India due to the so-called ‘geopolitical realities.’ That India seems to be changing, but we need to be ever-alert. Alertness, however, is inhibited by this ‘conservatism.’ 

It’s all about things that ‘go without saying,’ which, as the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu observed, ‘often come without saying.’  It’s part of colonialism. It’s part of subjugation through direct and indirect means, through threat and execution of threat. 

So yes, such conservatives and conservatism should be called out and comprehensively defeated. No one should be misled by those who have a narrow, misguided or pernicious understanding of what’s conservative and what’s not. President Gotabaya Rajapaksa probably has his advisors. Mangala Samaraweera is obviously not one of them. We can only hope that those he listens to are nothing like Mangala Samaraweera.

This article was first published in the Sunday Observer [February 9, 2020]