Showing posts with label Mangala Samaraweera. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mangala Samaraweera. Show all posts

03 July 2020

The MCC Compact: US Embassy should stop being cagey

Maybe Mangala Samaraweera knows what happened to the USD 10 million pledged!


The committee appointed to review the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) Compact has raised serious concerns about the draft agreement. Noting that the document as it stands is detrimental to the national interest and essentially subverts sovereignty while surrendering judicial oversight, the committee clearly recommends that the Government should not sign the document unless such sections are amended. The US Government has not indicated any willingness to alter anything.

Media statements published by the Embassy, comments of Ambassador Alaina B Teplitz and relevant tweets tell an interesting story. When asked to comment on the final report of the Review Committee, the Embassy said ‘no monies were ever transferred to or spent by the Sri Lankan Government under the proposed USD 480 million grant. Obviously ‘spending’ is out of the question if money had not been transferred, but let’s just smile and move on.

Okay. So, no money has been released so far from the grant itself. If there’s no agreement signed, then money cannot be released. Fair enough. Makes sense. The Embassy has however mentioned funds for preparatory activities in a tweet on June 26, 2020: ‘Funds for preparatory activities have been canceled or indefinitely postponed, pending the Government’s decision whether to proceed with the grant.’

Let’s take a look at the subject ‘Funds for preparatory activities.’ The Embassy, in a statement released on July 27, 2017 refers to an MCC delegation led by Fatema Z Sumar, Regional Deputy Vice President for Europe, Asia, the Pacific and Latin America. Sumar, on a visit to Sri Lanka to push the MCC compact pledged USD 7.4 million ‘to support the development of the compact.’

On June 13, 2018 the Embassy issued another statement. Caroline Nguyen, MCC’s Managing Director for the very same regions, and the Embassy’s Deputy Chief of Mission Robert Hilton signed an agreement with the Ministry of Finance to provide an additional USD 2.6 ‘to finalize compact development,’ the statement claimed.

Why should there be a top-up unless funds originally allocated were insufficient? Note the word ‘finalize.’ It indicates that much of the ‘development’ (of the agreement) had been completed.

The final report of the Review Committee however claims that there is no record at the External Resources Department of the Finance Ministry regarding any payments being made for ‘preparatory work’ or ‘feasibility studies’ pertaining to the MCC.  

This raises a few questions. Why should additional monies be pledged if that which was agreed upon previously was not used? If indeed the first tranche of USD 7.4 million was used, where did it go? Could the amount have been used to pay ‘consultants’ hired by MCC? Since an agreement has already been signed shouldn’t approval for payment be obtained from the Government of Sri Lanka? If indeed approval was obtained, why is there no record of it?

There’s another serious issue. Now USD 10 million does seem stiff to write what is essentially a glorified project proposal, but let’s assume that it is a complex agreement requiring extensive research involving data collection and input from a wide range of experts.

Now let’s assume that not one cent of the funds pledged for ‘preparatory work' has been released. If someone said money is needed for preparatory work ‘to develop the compact,’ and if someone else says ‘yes, you are right and I will provide it to you,’ it means that preparation CANNOT happen if money wasn’t forthcoming. Now Teplitz and the US Embassy would have us believe that a) preparation needs bucks, and b) no bucks have been provided.

What then can be said about the draft agreement? Was it ‘developed’ without any money for relevant preparatory work? Was it a half-baked document? Was it just a copy-paste of similar agreements (for example Nepal’s MCC Compact whose ‘development’ was overseen by Teplitz, no less!)? What really happened?

It is on record that local research outfits, Verite and LIRNEasia, have been involved in compact development. Perhaps these organizations will reveal what they did, for whom, for how much and whether or not payments were made. Unless of course it was for gratis.  

The Embassy states that MCC-managed funding to support grant preparatory activities ‘was made available under the same highly transparent and accountable procedures used to enable other US development work.’  It is indeed strange therefore that there’s no evidence of ‘high transparency’ or ‘accountability’ with respect to payments and beneficiaries.

The Embassy and the Ambassador have repeatedly insisted that this was a ‘grant’ and that it’s all about ‘wanting to be a friend and partner.’ The truth is that the USA and indeed outfits such as LIRNEasia and Advocata (which are ideological pals of Washington and have championed the myth of the free market) subscribe to the neoliberal doctrine which insists ‘no free lunches.’ Why offer Sri Lanka a free lunch worth USD 480 million then? Why offer appetizers worth USD 10 million?  What’s in it for the USA? What benefits are anticipated from the ‘partnership’ (since ‘friendship’ cannot really be banked)?

Control. That’s obvious. The Review Committee has spelled out in detail the benefits that would accrue to the USA and what Sri Lanka loses on the flip side of the deal.

The Government has stated that the report would be submitted to Cabinet. Action, one way or the other, would follow, we can expect. The bottom line is that the Review Committee report clearly forbids this government from going ahead with the MCC Compact. We need the details of the process, however. The Government, having pledged to review and having been provided with a review, has to decide and make public the decision. Foot dragging will raise suspicions of ‘deals’ being discussed on the sly.  

The External Resources Department claims to be clueless. The Government, then, must immediately launch an investigation regarding the USD 7.4 million tranche. Mangala Samaraweera was the subject Minister when the Sumar and Nguyen delegations visited Sri Lanka, held talks with ministry officials and signed agreements. He can also show some love for transparency and accountability.

The Embassy and the Ambassador have been cagey over details. If, as Teplitz claims, the USA truly values ‘highly transparent and accountable procedures,’ then the truth about disbursements and recipients needs to be revealed. ‘Suspended or indefinitely postponed,’ is not a satisfactory response because it is opaque.

If the first tranche of USD 7.4 million was not used, why was a further USD 2.6 million pledged? Was money spent, yes or no? If ‘yes,’ for what was it spent and who received how much? If, as Teplitz and the US Embassy imply, no money has been released for ‘preparatory work,’ is the final draft ‘unprepared’? Why on earth would the USA expect any Government to sign a half-baked document? It can’t be difficult for Teplitz and/or the US Embassy to answer these simple questions ‘in the interest of transparency and accountability,’ right?

RELATED ARTICLES

The MCC: did the ‘going devil’ break the earthenware crock (koraha)? 

DANGER: The MCC Compact is down, but not out

Finding paths to being enslaved by the USA 

A political reading of the US Ambassador's angst

malindasenevi@gmail.com

02 March 2020

Taking ownership of reconciliation: truths, half-truths and humbuggery

Nothing 'general' about these assemblies, nice visual notwithstanding

Reconciliation. That’s a word that’s been abused much. Just like ‘peace,’ in the heady days of the ‘Ceasefire Agreement’ (CFA) signed by Ranil Wickremesinghe and Velupillai Prabhakaran. The main problem of such terms is that they are open to multiple interpretation. 

What ‘peace’ meant for the LTTE and of course its mouthpieces, including the TNA at the time, was ‘Eelam’. What it meant for the United National Party was ‘space to implement a pro-USA neoliberal agenda.’ Reconciliation is similar. A vague term. Describable in multiple ways. Ideology-framed. Veer from what YOU think it means, and immediately you can say ‘he/she is against peace, is a warmonger,’ or ‘he/she doesn’t want reconciliation.’ 

United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet exploits this definitional vagueness well. She’s unhappy that Sri Lanka withdrew from the ill-conceived and pernicious Resolution 30/1. She says she’s not convinced that yet another commission of inquiry would deliver. Commissions haven’t really delivered, this is true. On the other hand, non-delivery of one commission doesn’t mean another wouldn’t deliver either. Thirdly, what is the ‘deliverable’ here? Bachelet’s understanding of what ‘reconciliation’ means?  

What does she want, really? She has said she’s troubled by a recent trend towards moving civilian functions under the Ministry of Defense or retired military officers. Such trends are certainly a concern, but then again, in a situation where civil administration in certain spheres is at a standstill if not collapsed, that’s a reasonable interim remedy. 

She’s also upset by ‘reports’ of surveillance and harassment of human rights defenders, journalists and victims. She knows that we’ve had terrorist sympathizers masquerading as rights defenders and journalists. As for victims, she probably doesn’t know that every citizen was a victim of terrorism and there’s nothing wrong in a country subject to terrorism from being alert to possible victimization of the same kind. Take context out and she has a point. On the hand, take context out, and it’s a caricatured and even shady narrative that emerges. Use that as foundation and you can extrapolate in any direction you want, naturally framed by your outcome preferences. 

Anyway, none of these ‘reports’ are substantiated. The ‘sources' at best are unreliable. We’ve had a lot of that in the past and that’s what went into the substance of the infamous Darusman Report, based on which the UNHRC needled Sri Lanka at every turn. Eventually, the movers and shakers, principally the USA (which called the UNHRC ‘a cesspool of bias’), got a pliant government to co-sponsor and anti-Sri Lanka resolution (30/1) in 2015.

So she’s upset. She regrets the fact that the new government ‘has announced a very different approach to the commitments previously made in the resolution which risks setting back efforts to advance reconciliation, accountability and human rights.’

Lovely play with words! What ‘reconciliation’? What kind of ‘accountability’? Does throwing in ‘human rights’ purify a cesspool? Why hasn’t she come clean on the utter lack of accountability on the part of the UNHRC with regard to all the falsehoods in the Darusman report? Has she ever asked who fed that ill-willed panel to advise Ban-ki Moon? If she did, was she appalled to find out that the feeders of misinformation happened to be wearing journalistic and rights advocacy garb? 

Bachelet believes that Sri Lanka’s ‘independent institutions’ were strengthened under the 19th Constitutional Amendment and that they are key pillars in its democratic structure. What utter ignorance! Has she read the 19th or is she taking the word of ill-willed, politically and ideologically compromised ‘human rights activists’ and ‘journalists’? The 19th was a piece of trash. It was pushed through ignoring a Supreme Court observation that certain sections were unconstitutional and would require a referendum. The composition of the all important Constitutional Council (which plays a key role in setting up these independent institutions) is so politician-heavy and, given context, was scripted to constitution institutions that were heavily pro-Government. The lady needs to do a bit of reading, obvious. 

Not unexpectedly, the UNHRC’s and USA’s point-man in Colombo, former Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mangala Samaraweera has chirped an echo.



His missive, on the same subject (of withdrawal), is different only in terms of lament-volume. 

He brags about how the then President, Prime Minister, Secretary of the Foreign Affairs Ministry and himself discussed over telephone and decided to go along with the US-scripted (sure, sure, they didn’t sign it — Montenegro, the UK and Macedonia did, but who’s fooling whom here?) Resolution 30/1. He brags that thanks to this move, Sri Lanka obtained ownership of all related processes. What unadulterated rubbish! Sri Lanka tied itself to the agenda of the bullies in Geneva, Sri Lanka ceded in part her sovereignty, Sri Lanka offered co-ownership (that’s sanitized, mind you) of local affairs to outsiders, and that’s obtaining ownership? 

He talks of lost respect and dignity. As though such things figure in the way nations think of one another. They don’t frame not mark multilateral affairs. Just rhetoric. Perhaps for Samaraweera, being in the good books of the USA, UK and EU is what matters most, but that's got nothing to do with sovereignty except conceding it to such global thugs!

He says ‘Resolution 30/1 (helped bring) back home all relevant issues from the international arena.’ Which planet has he been inhabiting all these years? If that was the case, why did the Yahapalana Government get so excited and anxious just before all UNHRC sessions, doing this and that, saying this and that, so Sri Lanka could say ‘said this, did that’ in Geneva? 

The Resolution was tabled in Parliament AFTER it was passed at the UN. Samaraweera's government agreed to stuff without consulting the people or their representatives. It did so knowing well that certain things agreed to were unconstitutional. And now he laments that the then Joint Opposition didn’t provide ideas about how to implement the Resolution! That Joint Opposition was not consulted. Indeed no one was consulted. The opinion of the Permanent Representative in Geneva was unceremoniously brushed aside! And this man calls it a ‘consensus resolution’. Consensus among whom? Anti-Sri Lankan elements in the USA, UK and EU on the one hand, and their local slaves?

Samaraweera goes on to brag about how the Resolution facilitated the USA to ‘support’ Sri Lanka’s military in terms of training, joint-exercises. Clearly he has absolutely no idea about the history of the US military. ‘Normalizing relations with the international community,’ is what it produced.

Normalizing! Another word like ‘reconciliation’ and ‘peace’. What’s normal? For Mangala, ‘friendship with the USA’ (read, submission to US will on all matters, including SOFA and MCC). ‘International Community’ is essential shorthand for NATO and its allies. Indeed, as was aptly put in a Facebook comment, ‘the whole UN and its agencies are Trojan horses deployed post WW2 by NATO and its western allied partners to enable, install and keep intact a mechanism of “systemic barriers (and intrusions)” against a rising Russian and Chinese threat.’

That’s what Resolution 30/1 was all about. A part of THAT story. Bachelet’s and Samaraweera’s ‘disappointments’ and ‘worries’ relate to THAT agenda being derailed somewhat.

Samaraweera believes that a signal has been sent by ‘backtracking on the resolution’.  Now ‘backtracking’ is all about perceptions of direction. Such things are not ideology-free. He believes that it means ‘Sri Lanka cares not for reconciliation, accountability or even democracy.’ Those words again. What’s reconciliation? What’s accountability? What’s democracy? Well, in the Yahapalanists’ lexicon there’s no ‘sovereignty’. As for reconciliation, it’s about pandering to the demands of a particularly pernicious segment of the international community and to communalists back home who, after their masters’ military adventure ended and finding themselves in reduced circumstances, would leverage a spineless government to deliver what terrorism could not. Sorry.  

As for accountability, that government was not accountable to the people, not accountable to the Supreme Court and cared not a hoot for constitutionality. It was undemocratic in the way it went about with respect to Resolution 30/1. Consensus without the citizenry is not consensus, it is subversion of democracy. Such machinations do not produce reconciliation. They subvert reconciliation. 

He is upset that the ‘toil’ has come to naught. Well, that’s understandable. He must be upset. He cannot expect others to be upset too and certainly not people whose opinions were shoved aside to accommodate those of individuals and institutions that obviously knew nothing of Sri Lanka, her people, her history and the context relevant to these machinations. 

Sri Lanka has, it can be argued, rolled back the obstacles to reconciliation, simply by creating room for debate that is not framed by arbitrary and silly understanding of context and definitions of key terms. The people are back in the equation which was under Yahapalanists dominated by the arrogant and stupid.

Any discourse that can yield something positive cannot happen in an environment where outsiders demand that Sri Lankans inhabit their version of Sri Lanka’s reality. It has to happen the other way about. We create room for our story, with all its complexities, contradictions, trauma, despair and hope. That’s something that was ruled out by the Yahapalanists and Resolution 30/1. 

Peddlers of half-truth and humbuggery were voted out. No conspiracy there. That was voice replacing “his/her master’s/mistress’ voice.” 

Consequences! That’s the warning end-note of Samaraweera’s missive and it’s all there in Bachelet’s diplo-speak. Sure. Then again, it’s better not to sweep things under the carpet for that could trip us, and better not to genuflect and get kicked in the teeth for the effort.  

This article was first published in the SUNDAY OBSERVER [March 1, 2020]


Related Articles

27 February 2020

Michelle Bachelet needs a tutor



A year ago, UN Human Rights Commissioner Michelle Bachelet made the following observation in her report on Sri Lanka (tabled on March 8, 2019): 

‘On 29 May 2018, human skeletal remains were discovered at a construction site in Mannar (Northern Province). Excavations, concluded with the support of the Office on Missing Persons, revealed a mass grave from which more than 300 skeletons were recovered. It was the second mass grave found in Mannar following the discovery of a site in 2014. Given that other mass graves might be expected to be found in the future, systematic access to grave sites by the Office as an observer is crucial for it to fully discharge its mandate, particularly with regard to the investigation and identification of remains.’ 

Pointing out that the said mass grave has been dated back to 1499-1719 CE, as per tests done by Beta Analytic Institute, Florida, USA, I made the following observation:

‘Bechelet may have not known (which indicates sloth) or knew very well (which indicates she’s toxic) when she tabled that report. Those who were ecstatic when these graves were discovered and may have uttered equivalents of ‘Pay dirt, baby!’ are playing ostrich right now.’ [Ref: 'When you have a bone to pick....'].

There’s been no apologies or explanations. Not then, not since. Not about the mass grave nor about the blatant lies and tendentious claims she dished out in her report, clearly refuted by then Minister of Foreign Affairs, Tilak Marapana.

A year later, Bachelet revisits. No mention of mass graves. Instead she offers a whine. Read on:

‘“A contributing factor to a lack of delays in implementing human rights reform appears to be a lack of common vision among the country’s highest leadership, deadlock on important issues is an addition and an avoidable problem with damaging impact on victims currently from all ethnic and religious groups and society as a whole.

Wordy, much. 

What does she mean by ‘common vision’? Before we answer that, there are a couple of things we need to deal with. First, ‘leadership’. Contrary to her claim, there doesn’t seem to be disunity. The Yahapalana Regime was brought with division. There was a maverick Minister of Foreign Affairs (before Marapana) who was like a law unto himself, bullishly co-sponsoring an anti-Sri Lanka resolution (30/1) on behalf of a Government led by two individuals in a coalition of two parties that had been going hammer and tongs for more than half a century and was too busy with petty political fights to figure out what he was up to.  Indeed THAT government, at THAT time, had all but lost its mandate, having been routed in the local government elections a year before. In stark contrast, the current regime does not seem to be suffering from any vision impairment on account of disunity with regard to these issues. ‘One Voice’ is what we have now. We can tell her something like this: There’s no deadlock miss; ask the UNP’s presidential candidate Sajith Premadasa what his views are on Resolution 30/1.’ 

The disunity we see comes from differences among different political parties/coalitions. That’s natural. That’s why there’s ‘government’ and there’s ‘opposition’. It’s about having power and wanting power. However, today, the main opposition United National Party (UNP) doesn’t seem to have any issues with the position that the ruling party, the SLPP (Sri Lanka Podujana Peramuna) has taken vis-a-vis Resolution 30/1. 

So when Bachelet talks of ‘common vision’ we need to unpack ‘vision’. Whose vision? Is she dismayed because a nation appears to be unwilling to inhabit her version of its reality? Probably. But what’s her vision and what is it based on? 

In her elaboration on Sri Lanka, Bachelet says, ‘the recent appointment to a senior position in the SL army of Major General Shavindra Silva implicated in alleged serious violations of national humanitarian rights law is a worrying development.’ Key word: ‘alleged’. Then she laments ‘lack of progress’ in ‘setting up  special judicial mechanism to deal with the worst crimes committed in the 2009 conflict.’ That’s not allegation, it’s conclusion and condemnation. A quick shift, that. 

She’s also mentioned ‘an important next step’: ‘legislation and the establishment of an independent truth and reconciliation commission.’ Aha! So we need to legislate. This seems to be an acknowledgment of the frivolous and pernicious nature of Resolution 30/1 where Sri Lanka (well, Mangala Samaraweera, actually) pledges to violate her own constitution! Naturally, new laws would have to be made. Now that promise was made without any mandate for constitution-violation. Today, Bachelet says ‘legislate!’  


 There has been minimal progress on accountability, she says. True. Of the UNHRC, sections of the UNP, the Tamil National Alliance and various I/NGOs with absolutely no standing in civil society but whose word has been taken as biblical truth by UN agencies, the USA and the UK. They lied. The lies were picked up and agreed upon by the charlatans commissioned by former UN Secretary General, Ban-ki Moon to advise him on Sri Lanka. Lies were agreed upon. Based on these very same lines, ‘vision’ was produced. Now that the whole edifice is askew on account of a weak foundation, people like Bachelet wail, ‘there’s no unity among leaders in Sri Lanka!’ They use ‘allegation’ and treat it as ‘guilt’. They talk of ‘damaging impact on victims,’ interestingly ‘from ALL ethnic and religious groups and society as a whole.’

Wow!

Has Bachelet done a survey of some sort? And who are these ‘victims’? Yes, all ethnic and religious groups suffered. ‘Society as a whole’ suffered too. Happens when a rabid terrorist outfit holds country and community hostage for decades. The victims are those who suffering has been all but discounted by the UNHRC and people like Bachelet. Resolution 30/1 kicks them in the teeth, so to speak simply because it infringes upon their sovereignty, makes light of their suffering and attempts to force them to submit to someone else’s version of what they’ve suffered.   

So when Bachelet talks of ‘deadlock,’ it is essentially disagreement between the people of Sri Lanka and the UNHRC’s (or should I say ‘Uncle Sam’s’) notions of Sri Lanka’s past, present and future. 

Since she talks of ‘all ethnic and religious groups and society as a whole,’ she needs to understand that Resolution 30/1 panders to the pernicious designs of a small minority of a single ethnic group that has been whipping communalism for decades. That’s what legislation a la Bachelet would do.

When I said Michelle Bachelet needs a tutor it was tongue-in-cheek. She knows stuff. She knows stuff and knows her job. Upholding human rights is her official job, but the United Nations being a creature of North America and Europe, that job is framed, more or less, by the interests of the relevant nations. Sure, the USA has called it a ‘cess pool of bias’. That’s correct. Bias in favor of the global political formations mentioned above. Sure, the USA quit the UNHRC, but no one’s fooling anyone. The US can operate (read, ‘arm-twist’) directly or through proxies. And Bachelet seems to be playing her part in that game. 

This must end. Soon. Sri Lanka has been hauled over the coals by countries that have the worst human rights records and their apologists. Sri Lanka should not be held to ransom on account of the stupidity of an inept government utterly servile to the designs of the USA. Sri Lanka and Sri Lankans should not be held to ransom just because a maverick minister suffers from a postcolonial condition that makes victim hate him/herself and believe fervently in the ‘curative power’ of vilifying and destroying his/her community. 

Enough. We need closure on this. Bachelet, we must not forget, is someone who refused an audience to the victims of the US-sponsored coup that ousted the democratically elected government of Salvadore Allende during two separate terms as  President of Chile. She can’t pretend to shed victim-tears for tears she did not have to shed for victims in her own country. 

We need closure on spin. No tutors required for that.

This article was first published in the SUNDAY OBSERVER [February 23, 2020]

10 February 2020

Time to drop conservatives and conservatism


UNP parliamentarian Mangala Samaraweera is reported to have said that President Gotabaya Rajapaksa should not let conservative forces mislead him. 

Mangala got that one right. Literally. The issue is, it is doubtful that he understood the meaning of the word. So let’s deal with some definitions first. 

‘Conservative’ is an adjective. It means, 'averse to change or innovation and holding traditional values.’ It is also a noun, referring to someone who is averse to change and holds traditional values. So, there are some key words here we need to think about: change, innovation and tradition’

Now ‘tradition’ usually about transmitting customs or beliefs from generation to generation. Not necessarily bad, but in the political discourse that is in part framed by the colonial discourse, it has all kinds of negative connotations. The ‘traditional’ were called barbarians, heathens, philistines, uncivilized, uncultured, unsophisticated, vulgar, you name it. 

All negative. Not much is said about how the ‘civilized’ became civilized, and how in the name of civilization they destroyed cultures, plundered wealth, torched libraries, poisoned water sources, enslaved and massacred. 

Post-independence, the language changed. It was now about development and ‘underdevelopment,’ the latter sanitized as ‘developing’. Instead of ‘civilized’ we now had stuff like high incomes, high growth rates, growth-led development. Sure, they threw in ‘traditional knowledge’ and ‘sustainability’ and these were just words to sanitize above-board plunder, immiserization, wanton destruction of environment. Check out any development-related project proposal and you’ll find all these. Oh yes, they’ve added things like ‘aid effectiveness,’ ‘disaster mitigation’ and ‘climate change protocols.’ And of course ‘democracy,’ that intangible in whose name wars are declared, countries bombed into the middle ages and people slaughtered or corralled into refugee camps.

So when there’s talk of change and innovation, it's about transformation of societies and systems in ways that facilitate the same kind of plunder. In short, the sustained development of classes in places of advantage in an economy. In short, subsidizing capital interests. And when there’s talk of ‘conservatism’ it is about preserving the same system of plunder and destruction that has brought us genocide, cultural erasure, increasingly frequent ‘natural’ disasters, wars and deadly diseases. Mangala, in the process of defending his guarded praise for President Gotabaya Rajapaksa, tellingly, slips in the following caveat: ‘He should mention that there is no alternative but the economic policy of the previous government.’ 

Now THAT encapsulates the conservatism that Mangala is not interested in changing. THAT, also, is tradition now as far as the sway it has over all things economic, environmental and cultural. Innovation to entrench or further expand THAT is not wholesome, rather it is destructive, it diminishes and could even be called barbaric, uncivilized, uncultured, unsophisticated and vulgar. 

So what else has been ‘traditional’ in Sri Lanka, post-independence? Well, quite apart from the vilification of tradition, history, heritage and other things cultural, we have had the fixation about ‘Exclusive Tamil Homelands.’ Now persisting with THAT would not just be conservative but pandering to a downright lie. Interestingly those who champion such myth models, treating them as givens, are as insistence on the thesis, ‘history is version.’ So, some versions are ok, others are not. That’s conservative. 

So, we should not let conservative forces (which includes in these cases the likss of Mangala Samaraweera) mislead us (as they have for decades). There’s a whole lot of bunkum being passed off as god-given ‘solutions’ to all our ills. They include federalism and neoliberalism. Recent ‘traditions’ but traditions nevertheless. Archaic, based on falsehoods and proven to be untenable, unsustainable and even destructive. Advocates of such things are arch conservatives. They mislead. They should be ignored. 

There’s more. Another ‘tradition’ that’s persisted is the ballyhoo about secularism. It can be summarized as follows: bash the Sinhala Buddhists, rant and rave over Article 9 of the Constitution, maintain dead silence about the negation of the same in Articles 10 and 14 and, most importantly refuse to utter a single word about the Muslim Marriage and Divorce Act and other community-specific legislation that subvert all the lovey-dovey rhetoric of equality. Those who are ‘traditional’ in this sense, are also conservatives who have and continue to mislead leaders and the general public. Mangala is one among many.  

There’s more. How about the ‘tradition’ of being servile to the USA, UK and the EU? Mangala (in)famously took THAT conservatism (which is almost an article of faith of the UNP and of course the SLFP under Chandrika Kumaratunga) to a whole new level with Resolution 30/1 of the UNHRC. That kind of genuflection has become a tradition. That’s conservatism we can do without. Indeed it’s conservatism that impedes progress, subverts change and makes innovation impossible. We have had missions from the West acting as though they are de facto viceroys. We have had ‘aid missions’ that have arm twisted or else bribed politicians and officials to tailor national policy in ways that further their interests at the cost of national security (which includes food security, by the way). 

Dumping ‘National Interest’ has been a tradition for decades. Remember how that ‘great’ UNP leader, J.R. Jayewardene sold national interest down the river on July 31, 1987 to India? That’s another kind of conservatism; submitting to the will of India due to the so-called ‘geopolitical realities.’ That India seems to be changing, but we need to be ever-alert. Alertness, however, is inhibited by this ‘conservatism.’ 

It’s all about things that ‘go without saying,’ which, as the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu observed, ‘often come without saying.’  It’s part of colonialism. It’s part of subjugation through direct and indirect means, through threat and execution of threat. 

So yes, such conservatives and conservatism should be called out and comprehensively defeated. No one should be misled by those who have a narrow, misguided or pernicious understanding of what’s conservative and what’s not. President Gotabaya Rajapaksa probably has his advisors. Mangala Samaraweera is obviously not one of them. We can only hope that those he listens to are nothing like Mangala Samaraweera.

This article was first published in the Sunday Observer [February 9, 2020]

06 June 2019

The politics of alienation and isolation

And they resigned in solidarity with people accused of Jihaadist association! 

Ajith Fernando, an old friend and an incredibly good and humble human being, got it right when he said, ‘Terrorist don’t win when they manage to kill 200, 300 innocent people. They win when they manage to alienate and isolate the entire Muslim population.’

Now, broadly speaking, there are two ways in which a community can become alienated and isolated. First, if the rest of the population, out of fear, prejudice or for some other reason, conflates that community with the terrorists, in this case the National Thawheed Jamaath (NTJ) or the ISIS or in general terms, the ‘Jihaadists’ (of whom there can be and are many variants), all acting in the name of Allah, the greater Islamic community and as per their reading of the Quran. Secondly, the community can for reasons of security (closing of the ranks so to speak, operating on the notion ‘me against my brother, but my brother and I against others’) or conviction alienate and isolate itself.  Where alienation and isolation do occur we tend to see one of the above two or both in varying degrees of intensity.  

Strangely, in Sri Lanka, at least in views expressed in English, the dominant view is that a) there IS alienation and isolation of Muslims, and b) it is a condition imposed on the Muslims, one in which they have not played any role.  

These views have gained a lot of credence thanks to some very tangential and even pernicious statements. Today we have the US House Committee on Foreign Affairs expressing concerns about ‘the demonizing of Muslims in Sri Lanka’. That’s rich, coming from one of the world’s most racist countries where Muslim-demonization is almost an article of faith. 

We also have Mangala Samaraweera’s multiple tweets: a) ‘Hatred is never appeased by hatred. By non-hatred alone is hatred appease. This is a law eternal.’ Today it was left to our Muslim Ministers to exhibit this sacred teaching of Lord Buddha while imposters in robes incited hatred in his name. A shameful day for our beloved #lka; and b) #Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith fanning the flames of hatred and communalism by visiting fasting robed MP Rathana. #Vatican TAKE NOTE! Perhaps he is feigning ignorance (unlikely) but this is quintessential Mangala: he can’t help attacking the Buddhist Order and the Buddhist community while at the same time sweeping under the carpet the context. One notes that he has never once tweeted about ‘imposters in the clothing worn by Islamic clerics,’ when referring to the NTJ. 

So we have, all of a sudden, a ‘situation’ where the Cardinal is ‘fanning the flames of communalism and racism.’ We have the ‘Muslims being demonized’. Perhaps we should talk of all demonizations and delve into the real demonizers.  

The New York Times quotes Rauff Hakeem, leader of the Sri Lanka Muslim Congress: ‘our people fear a blood bath.’ Existential fears are not the preserve of the Muslim community though: if people are terrified in ways they have not been for 10 years, it is because of the Easter Sunday attacks, carried out, let us repeat, in the name of Allah, with the expressed affirmation of a reading of the Quran and of course the Islamic faith. THAT was a bloodbath (and not FEAR of a bloodbath) Wariness can make people imagine all kinds of doom’s day scenarios. Given the affirmed religious identity of the terrorists, it is not unnatural for people to be wary of that community. 

That said, to use words such as ‘demonization’ and to vilify efforts that seek justice as a means to a quick resolution and thereby the creation of a situation where mutual respect, trust etc., can take root, does not help. In fact it can have the opposite effect. The Buddhist community did not carry out or sanction a terrorist attack. Neither did the Muslim community as a whole. There was an attack that killed hundreds of people; it was not done in the name of the Buddha. If people don’t want a sense of proportion, if they want to play the margins, make mountains out of molehills etc., they are not helping. They are fanning the flames of discontent, they are feeding extremisms.  

The New York Times news report (‘All 9 of Sri Lanka’s Muslim Ministers Resign as Bombing Backlash Intensifies’) carried the following bylines: Dharisha Bastians and Mujib Mashal. The second, going by name, seems to be a Muslim. The first is the Editor of a state-owned newspaper. Well, no one asked ‘All 9’ to resign. They were not made to resign. They did so of their own accord. That’s not backlash. That’s choice. The NYT has not uttered a word about the tendentious comments made by the three whose eviction was sought nor Bathiudeen’s association with the NTJ. No, but the NYT feels fit to use the title ‘Mr’ when referring to Bikkhus. Bastians, even when she takes issue with him, says Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith and not Mr Malcolm Ranjith. It is disrespectful and odious. It is quite antithetical to the rhetoric of coexistence and reconciliation indulged in by the Government that hand-picked her for a state-sector job.  

What’s the truth here? Here are the facts. First. The call was for the removal of three persons. The resignation of six persons whose removal was not sought in solidarity with three persons who are under a cloud (on account of statements made and close association with terrorist suspects) raises a simple question: identification with that very same ‘cloud’? A wit quipped, ‘if a Parliamentarian is accused of raping a woman and called on to resign or it sought to be removed, should all men resign in solidarity?’ 

They’ve offered an explanation of sorts: it was because they felt that Rathana Thero’s hunger strike had raised fears among their community regarding imminent violence, an explanation which of course helps the ever-ready vilifiers of the majority community.  

This notion has got a bit of carry due to a statement made by Rev Gnanasara Thero of the Bodu Bala Sena (BBS) about serious action to be taken in the event the President did not accede to Rathana Thero’s demands. Gnanasara Thero and the BBS, however, were hardly part of the agitation. Moreover, Salley and Hizbullah are known to have pleased with Maithripala Sirisena to obtain the release of the thero through a presidential pardon. Interestingly, Gnanasara Thero has since castigated Rathana Thero for causing a distraction in the struggle against the struggle to overcome the threat of Islamic extremism!  In any event, translating a peripheral fact into fear-mongering is playing politics, nothing less. Probably, one surmises, in order to congeal a Muslim vote bloc in a future election. 

Second. Rathana Thero’s efforts, as mentioned above, drew the support of all communities, Muslims included. Sure, there were a lot of snide comments about Rathana Thero joining Muslims in their fast with hardly any comments on his demands or the context in which they were made, but there were many who were in complete agreement with the Thero’s position.  There was absolutely no conflation of Muslims and the Jihaadists. Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith in supporting the Thero put the full weight of the Catholic Church behind the effort. Tamil politicians joined the fast. In short there was solidarity of the kind rarely seen in recent times for protests of this kind.

Third. There is a strange reluctance to address the real and terrible threat to all Sri Lankans: jihaadist terrorism. Nothing has threatened to tear this country apart and rendered the entire citizenry vulnerable in the last ten years as the Jihaadist attacks. That threat is real. The entire drama about some kind of Sinhala Buddhist ‘backlash’ is in this context a distraction. It plays into the hands of the Jihaadists. 

What can one expect to happen when the terrorists are spoken of in tokenist terms or ignored altogether and at the same time those who have not conflated terrorists and the community they belong to are vilified, just because they happen to belong to a majority community? Is that not pernicious conflation? Does it not alienate Sinhalese and Buddhists? And if and when that happens, would you expect Sinhalese and Buddhists to pretend to be asleep or unconscious? 

Well, that’s what one can call the ‘Mangala Sutra’, ‘Mangala’ as a symbol and representative of all those whose passion has been to vilify the Sinhala Buddhists. Well, now it seems that this phenomenon can be trumped by what one may call the ‘Rathana Sutra’ but only if Ven Athureliye Rathana Thero says a lot of things, which need to be prefaced as follows: 

‘The greatest threat to unity, reconciliation, co-existence and peace among all communities, at this particular moment is Islamic extremism. The people must unite to fight this threat. However, we must not forget that if we do not do our utmost now and always to make sure that everyone feels safe, if we do not protect one another, if we directly or indirectly feed other extremisms, this task will only become that much more difficult.’  

Yes, Ajith Fernando has raised a pertinent point. Isolation and alienation never helps. Let us not push anyone or let anyone push us to such dreadful places.

malindasenevi@gmail.com


23 May 2019

And here comes the Equivalency Circus



M.S. Fouzul Ameen should have been alive today. The furniture shop owner from Kottaramulla, Nattandiya was killed by a mob on May 13, 2019. Many shops owned by Muslims should still be standing. They are not. No one should have or should show any apprehension of any Muslim, regardless of attire or appearance. Non-Muslims are wary and Muslims are apprehensive of one another. Should not be that way, but that’s what things have come to. 

After Fouzul Ameen was killed, a Facebook post with a picture of his ID card tagged to it, raised a question.  "මේ මනුස්සයා ගේ දරුවන් අන්තවාදීන් නොවී සිටීමට අපට කළ හැකි දේ මොකක්ද? -ඔව් අර ලේ ඉල්ලපු අයගෙන් තමයි අහන්නේ?-“ (what can we do to stop the children of this man from becoming extremists — yes, the questions is for those who were demanding blood).  

Legit. As legit as this response to the post: ‘තව්වො මරපු මිනිස්සුන්ගෙ ID හොයාගන්න බැරිවෙන්න ඇති නේද? බී කොන්සිස්ටන්ට් ඕ බී සයිලෙන්ට් කිව්වලු.’ (Perhaps you couldn’t find IDs of those who the NTJ killed? Be consistent or be silent, they say). 

Perhaps as response to the observation, a clarification followed: බෝම්බ ප්‍රහාර වලින් මිය ගිය ජනයා ගැන මෙසේ ලීවෙමි "මම ආරක්ෂාවෙන් පසු නොවෙමි, මියගියේ මගේ මිනිසුන් ය. මා සයිලන්ට් නොවෙන අතර කන්සිස්ටන්ට් බව සහතිකය’ (This is what I wrote about those who died in the bomb attacks, ‘I am not safe, those who died are my people.’ I am not silent and I am convinced of my consistency.’ And here’s the response: ‘හරිම ලයාන්විතයි බෝම්බකරුව්න් විශයෙහි. ඔබ කොන්සිස්ටන්ට් නැත.’ (Very tender are you with respect to the suicide bombers; consistent you are not.’

The violence in the North Western Province is unlike what we saw on Easter Sunday in that the latter was a product of long-term strategizing including the setting up of terrorist training camps, stockpiling arms and ammunition, and systematic indoctrination. But we can and should talk about the equivalencies.

The law enforcement authorities were clearly complicit in the case of the Easter Sunday attacks and in the mob violence led by people outside the particular areas that erupted three weeks later that took the life of Fouzul Ameen. Politicians offered support, direct or indirect, or were silently complicit. Theoretically, both could have been prevented provided warning signs noted, warnings heeded and relevant measures put in place.

Issues of identity marked both. In the one, terrorism for the purpose of faith-affirmation. In the other, the targeting of a community. In the one, some argue, the rise of a movement as response to existentialist angst. In the other, although the same people will not acknowledge, a similar angst, at least in the outward expression, never mind the clear hand of bankrupt politicians.    

The equivalency has been given credence by many commentators, mostly from Colombo’s Twitterati (aka Kolombians and Colombots) made up of Born Again Democrats and Funded Voices. The Easter Sunday bombs shocked them, naturally. So did the violence in the North Western Province. In the first case, they were quick to say ‘Terrorism has no religion’ (never mind that the terrorists were affirming a faith and not forgetting, following that logic, the fact that we have many religion-less mosques and Islamic educational institutes! In the latter case, the perpetrators were labeled: ‘Sinhala Buddhists’ (with or without the ‘extremist’ tag).

Some, correctly, pointed out the long history of patriotism affirmed by Muslims. The names of officers who laid down their lives in the war against terror were mentioned. And yet, interestingly, the very same people who make this point also claim that ‘Sinhala Buddhist majoritarianism’ caused the war which, again they say, was fought by Sinhala Buddhists against Tamils! Strange. 

Dr Harsha De Silva went an extra mile, claiming that the Kuliyapitiya violence cost the economy more than the Easter Sunday attacks. Yes, ‘Doctor’ Harsha De Silva. Economist. Someone called Taylor Dibbert was more specific. He penned a piece for www.foreignpolicy.com titled ‘Buddhist anger could tear Sri Lanka apart’. At least he’s said out loud what the aforementioned twitterati only whispers in private. Yep. Buddhists are the villains of the piece. They are who could tear Sri Lanka apart. What that to-be-torn country is, of course, is up for debate.

For a long time, we have had this anti-Buddhist sentiment finding expression in various ways. It takes the form of advocating a secular state without mentioning history, without talking about all the privileges enjoyed by non-Buddhist religious fraternities (compared, for example, to what religious minorities enjoy in Muslim or Christian nations). Mangala Samaraweera and his ilk say ‘We are Sri Lankans’. Correct. But then again, why don’t this One Sri Lanka folk work tirelessly to advocate and constitutionally concretize the ‘One Nation, One Law’ thesis? Why not scream for the abrogation of customary laws? 

But we are in a season of equivalency here and that calls for a vilification of Buddhists and of course Sinhala Buddhists. In the long history, we have had villainy. Magha of Kalinga: was he a Buddhist? The Portuguese who destroyed temples: were they Buddhists? The British who perpetrated genocide (a word oft mis-used by its users), ethnic cleansing and whose rule was marked by religious persecution and, again, the vandalizing of temples and kovils: Buddhists? Then there is the recent history. Velupillai Prabhakaran, goaded by Tamil racists: a Buddhist? The NTJ/ISIS: products of Buddhist extremism? 

Back to equivalency. The Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP). They were quiet for three whole weeks and were quite shy about explaining off the fact that they entered the name of a top rung NTJ operative in their national list. Then, Kuliyapitiya happened. Then came the poster, condemning all extremisms. Correct. But late. And selective, strangely. 

And now we have both the United National Party (UNP) and the JVP in navel-gazing mode regarding the vote of no confidence on Rishard Bathiudeen. We know the charges. We know that the near and dear, blood-wise, faith-wise and political loyalty wise, were right up there among the bigwigs of the NTJ terrorists. Sure, we can and should ask why a similar vote is not taken on Dayasiri Jayasekera for some actions that were similar to the lesser charges against Bathiudeen. That aside, it is nothing less than scandalous for Navin Dissanayake to say that the move on Bathiudeen is racist. That’s almost saying ‘if you are not a Sinhalese or a Buddhist and you engage in any kind of hanky panky, you get a wide berth because, well, you belong to a minority and therefore any action against you has to be racist.’

There’s equivalency of other kinds. Recent history. Tamil racists persuaded  hotheaded Tamil youth to take up arms. They introduced a kind of vulnerability that the Tamil community had not hitherto experienced. Look what the NTJ did. The same. And yet, behind the shield called ‘religious freedom’ we saw the rise of a doctrine among whose key tenets are elements that are in contravention of basic democratic norms and seek to bend the penal code. Yep. Wahhabism. That’s a religion. It fathered the NTJ. But we are not allowed to say it, are we? Oops, I just did! So sue me!  

Equivalency is the word here. I think I might have got it wrong. It might be better to talk about wild extrapolation. As another social media commentator observed, ‘Those very same losers who were silent when 250 plus people were killed by some nutters, are now so vociferous about some politically staged crap about the majority of the country being racists; if that were so, this place should be worse than Syria.’

Last weekend we saw Muslims and Christians in their thousands celebrating Vesak. That’s not going to deliver reconciliation, but it will not hurt it either. Indeed, even though the gesture was warm and warmly received, I don’t think anyone should feel compelled to celebrate some other faith on account of penitence (on behalf of ‘nutters’ professing the same faith) or fear. I say this knowing well that many among them did it for reasons more wholesome than fear and which went beyond ‘penitence’.  What is more important, and I believe it is happening in the Muslim community in a big way, is determined objection to all forms of teaching that buttress extremism of the kind we saw on Easter Sunday. 

At a recent media conference, some Muslim leaders were outspoken about the need for the Muslim community to indulge in introspection. Ali Saby observed that a historic opportunity has arisen to reform Muslim Law and customs in Sri Lanka. I offer that this opportunity can be squandered by the equivalency hordes referred to above.  

There are two ways to trip. One is to sweep the truth under the carpet. The other is to spin a web of lies or half-truths. Such things are not the preserve of any single community, religious or otherwise, of course, but the Equivalency Clowns are certainly doing it full time. Doesn’t help. If indeed we get to reconciliation and civilization it will not be because of them but in spite of them. We owe it to every single victim of the Easter Sunday attack and to the good furniture shop owner, the late M.S. Fouzul Ameen.

malindasenevi@gmail.com