Showing posts with label Lakshman Kiriella. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lakshman Kiriella. Show all posts

27 April 2019

Identity and identification of extremists and extremism


Just over a year ago, on March 6, 2018 to be precise, following inter-religious unrest in Digana and elsewhere Lakshman Kiriella (UNP) said in Parliament that ‘a resolution should be brought and Buddhists should apologize to the Muslims in connection with the violence.’ Kiriella has not, as yet, called on Muslims to apologize to Christians and people of other faiths who perished in the Easter Sunday attacks.  

Kiriella was out of order and that is not surprising. He is not alone either. His political bed-mates, ideologically speaking, often use broad brush strokes to vilify Sinhalese and Buddhists. They have not, interestingly, applied the same principle of engagement to other communities. Indeed, some have labored to distinguish communities from extreme elements in that community. As they should, of course. It’s the selectivity that is problematic. 

The people need not be out of order, however. There is folly in conflating a community with either sections of that community or those claiming to speak and act on behalf of that community. 

The white supremacist terrorist group, Ku Klux Klan (KKK), swore to uphold Christian morality. The political leadership in the USA whenever that country unleashes terror across the globe invokes ‘god’ and it is the Christian god whose blessings are asked for. The political leadership in the UK, similarly, has historically spoken and acted ‘in the name of god and king/queen’. The Bodu Bala Sena acts in the name of Buddhism. The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) was and is about Hindu supremacy. None of these organizations or states can claim to reflect the views of the particular religious communities in their relevant entireties.  

The problem is that religious doctrines come with words. Words describe, confuse, distract and mislead. They are also open to multiple interpretation. This makes for pernicious selectivity for purposes arguably at odds with the intent of the prophets; although the selectors will vehemently argue that theirs is a strict adherence to tenets. The Quran as well as the Old and New Testaments, as such, can be read as texts that justify and call for violence. Extremists and pick and choose. Others could also pick and choose, and indeed do so. Differently.


Bishop Duleep De Chickera, at a panel discussion at the Sri Lanka Press Institute six years ago, acknowledged that religions or rather religious communities have caused much grief throughout history. He also pointed out that faith has also been a tremendous source of succor for people throughout history. This is true. People have often turned to their respective faiths and found relief as they contented with the vicissitudes of life, especially the ‘down sides’ of the Eight Worldly Conditions (Ata Lo Dahama) — sorrow, loss, blame and dishonor. Religion helps people come to terms with tragedy. Religion offers pathways to closure. 

It’s all easy on paper, however. The magnitude of the terror and the evil that unleashes it are such that there is hardly any space for sober reflection on philosophical tenets. Words are cheap. They are tossed around at will. They are tied to that explosive called emotion and typically come cased in political expedience. They are seldom wrought of reason. There will be Kiriellas. There will be people ready to point fingers at entire collectives and absolutely reluctant to reflect on their complicities. 

Kiriella’s statement is all about conflation. In the early years of this decade, the late Sunila Abeysekera, moderating (if memory serves) at the Galle Literary Festival a panel made of people disappointed that their outcome preferences with respect to the struggle against terrorism had not materialized, beseeched one and all not to conflate Tamils with the LTTE. When it was suggested that people like her indulge in the same conflation by legitimating the LTTE and being silent about claims that the LTTE was the sole representatives of the Tamil people, she was gracious enough to acknowledge. It can be argued that the anti-Tamil label pinned on the Sinhalese on account of antipathy to the separatist terrorists is printed with the ink of that kind of conflation as well.  

In an ideal world, we wouldn’t have a single Buddhist (outside of the BBS) who would condone or be silent about the BBS and its clear violation of basic Buddhist tenets. Indeed if even one out of 10 Buddhists (outside the BBS) saluted the BBS, it should be cause for shame. It’s the same with respect to the ‘Muslims’ (note: when the Buddhists were vilified and the BBS talked of, there were no quotation-mark-qualifiers) who carried out the Easter Sunday attacks. There are Muslims who have strongly condemned. There are Muslims who have in their own way objected and petitioned authorities to crack down on these extremists.  Nothing is ever ‘enough’ though, especially when politicians think of vote banks and play deaf and dumb when the threat is obvious.

And the threat, folks, is read. The enemy is not at the gates. The enemy is within. Among us. We are being attacked from within and without — and not only because the ISIS has claimed responsibility. International vultures are keen-eyed and have a keen sense of smell. They smell blood here. They have already tried to move in, of course wearing the garb of ‘concerned and aggrieved friend and neighbor’. 

Right here, though, freedom is ours to secure or squander. This government, power-drunk and revenge-consumed completely compromised national security. They are shamelessly playing a blame-game. The fact of the matter is that Harin Fernando knew of an attack but didn’t inform anyone. Others knew way before Easter but did nothing. Muslim (should I say ‘Muslim’?) ministers used ‘vote bank’ card (saying it without saying it) to let terrorists off the hook. The police went into numb mode after beefing VIP security. No one cared about the public. The people paid. 

The government’s vanity project of dancing to the tune of its global masters (the USA, UK, UN and its agencies including especially the UNHRC) put the entire population at risk. They played politics with the corpses of Wasim Thajudeen and Lasantha Wickramatunga. They partied with skeletal remains more than 400 years old (The BBC did so too, before the carbon dating results were out, and went dumb-and-dumber when they did). Today there are more than 300 dead bodies at the government’s door. Accessories after the crime of terrorism, that’s what the Yahapalanists are. They include the likes of Nimalka Fernando and her NGO pals who called Sri Lanka ‘A Failed State’. They are quiet now. 

Such are the realities of the murky thing that national security has been turned into by this Government. They trusted everyone except the ordinary people. The ordinary people paid a massive price and might have to continue to pocket out. 

Despite all this, we have to understand that it is the government that is best equipped to deal with the threat. The people have to support the efforts currently under way to eliminate this menace. In this, one can obtain relief from the fact that in times such as this, all Sri Lankans have come out and done the needful for themselves and one another. There’s something Sri Lanka that cuts across ideology, party, religious faith and ethnic identity, something intangible but certainly recognizable. 

It is our baby now, ladies and gentlemen. Victory or defeat will depend on how we conduct ourselves, whether or not we recognize ourselves in each other regardless of labels, whether or not we are kind to one another, and most of all how vigilant and determined we are. It’s about identities we have and identity-elements we privilege. 

I can do no better than quote my niece Duranya Freeman who summed it up thus in a long Facebook post:

Every terrorist has a goal: to make us fear what we love the most. To force us to feel that nowhere is safe. Yet terrorists only truly succeed when they divide us. When our inner fear turns outwards and we start pointing fingers at one another. Sri Lanka is dear to me for how much love can be packed into an island of just 25,000 square miles, roughly the size of West Virginia. An island whose victims of this Sunday will be mourned by everyone. An island which has survived 30 years of deadly political turmoil, and a tsunami that quite literally ripped it apart. An island which will also survive this.

30 October 2016

Words, deeds and devolution-fixations

The Foreign Minister, Mangala Samaraweera, has pleaded that action be taken more seriously than word.  Speaking at a press briefing on the subject of a vote on a UNESCO resolution, Samaraweera referring to controversial remarks made by President Maithripala Siriesna raising questions on the work of agencies investigating corruption allegations, requested that the government be judged on its actions and not on statements made.  

Interestingly, Samaraweera also stated ‘the government has not veered from its mandate to create a dynamic and vibrant democracy in Sri Lanka’.  Mandates are words, not deeds, and mandates, Samaraweera once said, are meaningless after elections.  

But let’s get to deeds, proper.  Lakshman Kiriella, Leader of the House, in a recent interview with the Daily Mirror has said that equal rights of the people should be ensured through power sharing with the periphery.  This brings us to the vexed issue of constitution-making, the Mother of all Deeds, so to speak.  The Father of that process, if you will, Dr Jayampathy Wickramaratne himself has confessed that very little has been done so far by the Committee appointed to handle the subject.  Add to this the other ‘statement’’ by the President where he dismisses provincial boundaries (on which the Eelam map has been traced and which give Kiriella’s ‘peripheries’) as the work of British cartographers (he did not interject ‘arbitrary’, but that’s what they are), and we need not be surprised that the ‘deeds’ are still in the making.    

So we are forced to go back to words, because ladies and gentlemen words are all that this Government has gives us so far on the issue of ‘reconciliation through constitution-making’.  And we know that words are dangerous things, they are easily tossed around and are what turn myths into facts and what confuses grievances with aspirations.  Kiriella, now, believes he knows the words.  He says that people don’t know history.  Let’s listen to the erudite historian.

“The first people who asked for devolution were the Kandyan Sinhalese. When Lord Soulbury came before Independence to create the new Constitution, Kandyan Sinhalese went before him and said that they had been a separate country for 400 years and that they had a crown and a throne. That was what they said. They asked for a Federal State. What they suggested were three Federal States -Ruhunu, Maya and Pihiti. Their basic argument was to seek devolution on the lines of the Indian constitution that was in the making at that time. The strange thing is that Tamil parties did not want devolution at that time. They preferred the status quo. The problems started after Independence. The parties that came to power offended the sentiments of Tamil people. Voting rights of estate Tamils were taken away. The Sinhala Only Act was introduced. The Federal Party was born after Independence.”

Our historian slips in the birth of the Federal Party after mentioning the issue of voting rights and the Sinhala Only Act, when that ill-birthing predates the other and more frequently mentioned ‘Post-independence’ problems. But let’s ignore such mischief.  The problem of drawing from history is the prejudice of selection.  There was context to what could be called a preposterous demand driven by the self-interest of the Kandyan ‘nobility’, the radalas, as preposterous as the similar demands made by spokespersons for certain castes.  They, like the Tamil ‘nobility’ in the North feared democracy because it threatened privileges enjoyed.  There was no ‘history’ buttressing the demands.  The problem of the Kandyan Sinhalese was ‘sorted’ through marriages which took families such as the Ratwattes, Meedeniyas and Dunuwilles out of the political equation.  The caste-based demand died a natural death.  Tamil chauvinism outlived both thanks, interestingly, to a disavowal of history by all relevant parties for a multiplicity of reasons including the existence of a strong anti-Buddhist political elite and a colonial and post-colonial mentality that cut across class, caste, region and even religion.

The historian does not challenge the claim that the Ruhunu, Maya and Pihiti were federal states.  They were well defined territories of course and far more logical than the 5 provinces that the British first drew and the 9 they came up with later, but they were not states by any stretch of the imagination and certainly not for any length of time that makes an ‘example’ that can support a wishy-washy devolution proposal.  

The truth is that the notions of ‘unitary’ and ‘federal’ were foreign to this island, in name and substance both.  There were times the land was eksesath or under one flag, times of multiple centres of power, times of overloads exacting tithes of one kind or another and other political arrangements.    The logic of ‘unity’ was more defined by specific objectives than by common agreement.  There was more commonality, if you want to argue the point, on the matter of shared notions of cosmology.   

The problem is simply a matter of putting the cart before the horse for reasons of ignorance, sloth, convenience and last but not least pernicious intent; in the case of Kiriella I would go with any or all of the first three, and with Wickramaratne and Samaraweera, the last. 

A process that is determined by a preferred outcome is no process but a political charade.  A process marked by a refusal to audit grievance and assess aspiration is ill-starred, to put it mildly.  Typically they exacerbate inter-communal tensions and fall apart, and if there’s no bloodshed involved we could say ‘lucky’.  Even if ‘devolution’ was a logical outcome of process (rather than the pre-determined ‘solution’ it is and which robs the process of credence), a refusal to revisit relevant boundaries in a context of chauvinistic myth-mongering on territorial claims amounts to rank irresponsibility.  And what we are seeing it now a political charade that is ill-starred and irresponsible.  And we are being generous here.   

Political systems are not cast in stone, sure.  What we were is not what we are and will not be what we will be.  Fixation is a negative.  Fixation coupled to ahistorical balderdash is a double negative.  That’s where we are.  The ABC of a constitution-making process, as we have pointed out many times is about a) obtaining a coherent articulation of grievance, b) assessment of the same to prune out exaggeration, c) review of aspirations to obtain the ‘reasonable’, d) consideration of all relevant factors including demography, geography, economic sense and of course history, and e) an assessment of do-ability.  If and only if all this yields ‘devolution’ as a logical arrangement to resolve grievances (as of now, even with exaggeration, marriage with aspirations and coated with mythology, devolution is a laughable ‘solution’ to the vague utterances of grievances, please note), should such be considered.  Also, if devolution, then and then only should lines be discussed.  

The historian is wrong about the federal claims associated with Ruhunu, Maya and Pihiti, of course, but if devolution is an outcome of a (far more transparent and ideologically-free) process of deliberation, then such demarcation makes far more sense than the arbitrary lines drawn by a thief who was also a mass murderer operating with the intent to ethnically cleanse vast swathes of the island of Sinhalese, i.e. the British, folks.  

As for words and deeds, if you get the former wrong you are not going to get much of the latter.  Indeed you end up talking nonsense.  If nonsense is the talk, need we even debate possible outcomes?



Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer.  Email: malindasenevi@gmail.com.  Twitter: malindasene

02 March 2016

සංඛ අමරජිත් වෙනුවට ලක්ෂ්මන් කිරිඇල්ල

"කැකිරිලන්තයේ මීළඟ පුවත්" ශීර්ෂය යටතේ මූණු පොතේ විටින් විට පළ කරන ලද 'ප්‍රවෘති' එකතුවකි මෙලෙස ඉදිරිපත් කරන්නේ 

"කිරිඇල්ල ගේ දේශපාලන විද්‍යාව" කෘතිය විශ්ව විද්‍යාල සඳහා නිර්දේශ වේ 
උසස් අධ්‍යාපන ඇමති ලක්ෂ්මන් කිරිඇල්ල කැළණි විශ්වවිද්‍යාලයේ දේශපාලන අංශ ප්‍රධානියා ට ලියා ඇත්තේ එම අංශයේ 'තාවකාලික කථිකාචාර්ය' තනතුරක් ඔහුගේ හිතවතෙකුට ලබා දෙන ලෙසයි. මේ වනාහී කිරිඇල්ල මහතා දන්නා දේශපාලනය ද නැතහොත් දේශපාලන විද්‍යාව දැයි පැහැදිලි නැති මුත් ඔහු හොර රහසේ රචනා කල "කිරිඇල්ල ගේ දේශපාලන විද්‍යාව" කෘතිය විශ්ව විද්‍යාල සඳහා නිර්දේශ වී ඇති බව විශ්වාස කටයුතු ආරංචි මාර්ග සඳහන් කර ඇත.

බළල් කතා වක් කියූ සංඛ ට බල්ලා කියමින් යහපාලනය බලුපාලනයක් සේ රනිල් අර්ථකථනය කරද්දී 'ගොන් කතා' ඇද බාන කිරිඇල්ල නාගන්න එක අහන්නත් දෙයක් ද?

සංඛ වෙනුවට කිරිඇල්ල 
දෙරණ රූපවාහිනී සමාගම සංඛ ඉවත් කිරීමෙන් ඇති වූ පුරප්පාඩුව ලක්ෂ්මන් කිරිඇල්ල විසින් පිරවීමට නියමිතයි. මාධ්‍යය භාවිතය පිලිබඳ හසල දැනුමක් ඇති කිරිඇල්ල මහතා සංඛ ට නොදෙවෙනි කාර්යභාරයක් ඉටු කරතැයි දෙරණ පාලකයෝ විශ්වාස කරන බව වාර්තා වේ. විශේෂයෙන් ම කිරිඇල්ල මහතා බලුපාලන ආණ්ඩුවේ අගමැති රනිල් වික්‍රමසිංහ මහතාගේ සමීපතම හිතවතෙක් වීම මෙම තනතුර ඔහුට ම පිරිනැමීමට ඉවහල් වී ඇත. ඒ සඳහා වික්‍රමසිංහ මහතා ගයන්ත කරුණාතිලක ඇමති හරහා දිලිත් ජයවීරට 'සුදුසුකම් ඇතොත්, වයස නොසලකා සේවයට ගන්න' කියා ලිපියක් එව්වේ ද නැද්ද යන්න තවමත් එලි වී නැත.


රටකට අපමණ අගයක් ඕනෑ වුනත් විසම්මුතියට දෙන අගය බිංදුවයි 
ඩී.ජේ (ඩිෆෝල්ට් ජනපති) වෛරී සිරිසේන ඒ දවස්වල 'රටකට ඕනෑ අපමණ අගයක්,' සහ 'මෛත්‍රී යුගයක්' ගැන කතා කලත් තමන්ගේ මතයට එරෙහි වෙන සියලු දෙනා ගෙන් පලිගන්න පිළිවෙතක් අනුගමනය කරමින් සිටී. බලුපාලන ආණ්ඩුවේ අගමැති රනිල් වික්‍රමසිංහ අප්පො සහ ඔහුගේ අනුගාමිකයින් මේවා ගැන මීක් නැත්තේ 'යහපාලනය', 'මෛත්‍රිය' වගේ වචන වල තේරුම් නොදන්නා නිසා නොව, අදාළ නැති නිසාය.


තිලංගගේ සදාචාර ඌනතාවය පියවන්න ග්‍රැහැම් ෆෝඩ් ඉවතට!
මහේල ජයවර්ධන එංගලන්ත ක්‍රිකට් කණ්ඩායමට උපදෙස් දීම සදාචාර විරෝධී බව පවසා මහේල ගෙන් කනේ පාරක් කෑ ක්‍රිකට් පාලක මණ්ඩලයේ සභාපති තිලංග සුමතිපාල මහතා කණ්ඩායමේ වත්මන් පුහුණුකරු ග්‍රැහැම් ෆෝඩ් එම තනතුරෙන් ඉවත් කිරීමට කටයතු කරන බව ආරංචි වී ඇත. 
තමා එංගලන්ත කණ්ඩායමට උපදෙස් දීම වැරදි නම් ග්‍රැහැම් ෆෝඩ් ශ්‍රී ලංකා කණ්ඩායම පුහුණු කිරීම ප්‍රශ්නයක් නොවන්නේ කෙසේද යන්න මහේල අසා තිබිණ. 
ලැජ්ජාවට පත් තිලංග තමා ගේ සදාචාරාත්මකභාවය ඔප්පු කිරීම සඳහා ග්‍රැහැම් ෆෝඩ් ඉවත් කිරීමට යන බව ක්විශ්වාස කටයුතු ආරංචි මාර්ග සඳහන් කරති.

විශ්‍රාමිකයින්ට සහ පරාජිතයින්ට 'සීතල සමයක්'
ඉදිරියට කෙනෙක් කාන් රැකියාවෙන් විශ්‍රාම යන්නට සිදුවුවහොත් එසේත් නැත්නම් රැකියාවෙන් නෙරපා දමන ලද්දේනම්, වසර 2 ක අනිවාර්ය 'සීතල සමයක්' ගතකරන්නට සිදුවනු ඇත. මීට අදාල පනත් කෙටුම්පත් සූදානම් කරමින් පවතී. මෙම සීතල කාලය තුල එතෙක් සේවය කල සංවිධානයට කුමන හෝ ආකාරයකින් විරුද්ධ කිසිම සංවිධානයට අදාළ පුද්ගලයාට සේවය කල නොහැකි බව ඉහත පනත වෙනුවෙන් කටයුතු කරන අයගේ මතය වේ. 

මෙම තත්ත්වයට ප්‍රධාන වශයෙන් බලපෑ කරුණ වන්නේ තිලංග සුමතිපාල පහුගියදා මහේල ජයවර්ධන පිලිබඳ කළ ප්‍රකාශය වේ. තිලංග පවසන්නේ මහේල එංගලන්තය ට ගොස් එම රටේ ක්‍රිකට් ක්‍රීඩකයින්ට පුහුණු කිරීම වැරදි බවයි. ඔහුගේ මතය වුයේ, "ක්රෙදකයෙක් කණ්ඩායමෙන් ඉවත් වී වෙන කණ්ඩායමකට උදව් කිරීමට පෙර'සීතල සමයක්' ගත කල යුතු බවයි.'

මෙම පනත මගින් පාර්ලිමේන්තුවේ පිල් මාරු සීමා වනු ඇති විද්වතුන් පවසති. එවන් පනතක් එවකට තිබුනේ නම් මෛත්‍රිපාල සිරිසේන කිසිදා ජනපති නොවනු ඇත. මහින්ද ප්‍රධාන 'ඒකාබද්ධ විපක්ෂය ට.' මේ තරම් රඟන්න වන්නේද නැත.

ලෝකයේ පරිත්‍යාගශීලිම රට ඉන්දියාව 
ලෝකයේ පරිත්‍යාගශීලිම රට ඉන්දියාව බව විමල් වීරවංශ ඔප්පු කර ඇත. ඉන්දියාවේ වෙසෙන රෝගීන්ට ප්‍රතිකාර කිරීමටද, එම රෝගීන් රෝහලකට ගෙන යාමට හැකියාවක් නොමැති තත්ත්වයක පසුවුවත් ශ්‍රී ලංකාවට ගිලන් රථ සේවාවක් පරිත්‍යාග කිරීම ට ඉන්දියාවේ ඇති සූදානම පුදුමසහගත බව ඔහු පවසයි.

අත්හැර දැමූ සියලු 'මඩ ඉඩම්' වල මහින්දලා නිධන් සඟවා ඇත 
විවිධ හේතු මත වගා නොකරන කුඹුරු ඉඩම් වල මහින්ද රාජපක්ෂ සහ ඔහුගේ ලඟම ඥාතීන් ඉතා රහසිගතව නිධන් සඟවා ඇති බව ඉතා රහසිගත පරීක්ෂණයකින් හෙළි වී ඇත. රට පුරා විහිද ඇති මෙවැනි ඉඩම් සියල්ලකම භාණ්ඩාගාරයෙන් හොරකම් කල මුදල් සහ එල්.ටී.ටී.ඊ. සංවිධානය විවිධාකාරයෙන් රැස් කරගත් රත්තරන් ඇතුළු මහා ධනස්කන්ධයක් සඟවා ඇතැයි විශ්වාස කටයුතු ආරංචි මාර්ග පවසා ඇත. ඒ සියලු ඉඩම් හාරා ජනතාව සතු විය යුතු මෙම ධනය මතු කර ගැනීමට ඉන්දියාවෙන් ශ්‍රමය ගෙන්වා ගැනීමට සිදුවන බව ද වාර්තා වේ. එම කාරණයද විවාදයට තුඩු දී ඇති 'ඉක්කා ගිවිසුමට' ඇතුලත් කිරීමට අදාළ පාර්ශවයන් දැන් දැන් සූදානම් වෙමින් සිටිති.

දින (හාර)සීයක් ගෙවිලත් පිළිතුරු නොමැති ප්‍රශ්ණ ඇත 
දින 100" මතකද? දින සීයේ කයිවාරුවේ වයස අදට දින 400 ත් පැනලා, 
කෝ ඉතින් මැතිවරණ ක්‍රමය ප්‍රතිසංස්කරණය කෙරුවද? තොරතුරු දැනගැනීමේ අයිතිය පිලිබඳ පනත කෝ? (දින 100 ට නොවුනත්) පුංචි ඡන්දයට ඇයි ඔච්චර බය? (දින 100 ට නොවුනත්) ඉක්කා ගිවිසුමේ කෙටුම්පත හදන්නේ කවුද, එලි දක්වන්නේ කවද්ද?


රනිල්ගෙන් හර්ෂට ටොක්කක් 
ඉන්දියාව සමග අත්සන් කිරීමට නියමිත 'ඉක්කා ගිවිසුම' ට එරෙහි වෙන අයට බැන වදිමින් බලුපාලන අගමැති රනිල් වික්‍රමසිංහ මහතා සඳහන් කලේ එම ගිවිසුමේ කෙටුම්පත වත් තවම සකස්කොට නැති බවයි. නැති ඉක්කාවකට විරුද්ද වන්නේ කෙසේද යනුවෙන් ඉතා සාධාරණ ප්‍රශ්නයක් ඔහු මතු කරයි. එහෙත් නැති ඉක්කාව සාධාරණය කරන්නේ කෙසේද යන පැනය රනිල් තමන් ගෙන් අසන්නේ ද නැත. නැති ඉක්කාව වෙනුවෙන් එඩිතරව පෙනී සිටින හර්ෂ ද සිල්වා ට රනිල් ටොකු අනින තෙක් ජනතාව නොඉවසිල්ලෙන් බලා සිටියි.