Showing posts with label Ranasinghe Premadasa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ranasinghe Premadasa. Show all posts

07 January 2020

The diga-palala of dynastic aspirations




In the year 2014, when Sajith Premadasa tried to overthrow Ranil Wickremesinghe as leader of the United National Party (UNP), I wrote the following observation on dynastic politics (‘Sajith Premadasa’s move(s)’ in the now defunct ‘The Nation’ newspaper).

Dynastic aspiration is something prevalent across the board and at all levels.  We see it in local government bodies, provincial elections and even within political parties.  It can’t be the political fascination of the powerful or those who crave power.  Sure, they tend to have lots of money or draw from moneyed backers and this helps secure votes, but that’s exactly the point – unlike monarchies where there’s no-sweat succession, here you have to be voted in.  Well, it looks like the general public is not averse to dynasty. 

A quick glance at South Asian politics over the 50-60 years clearly shows that the dynastic notion is a compelling factor in electoral politics; we had the Gandhis in India, Bandaranaikes, Wijewardenas and lately the Rajapaksas in Sri Lanka, the Bhuttos in Pakistan and the Zias in Bangladesh.  It’s not a South Asian preserve, though; consider the Kennedys, Clintons and Bushes in the USA. What separates these trends from a classic monarchy is elections. We could even call it democratic feudalism. Dynasty, in other words, is a factor that can sometimes give an edge. In Sri Lanka, at the parliamentary, provincial and local government levels we’ve seen many sons and daughters of political parents being elected. It’s a gene-factor, then.

Gene-factor, however, is not gene-right. In the same article referred to above, I offered the following, referring to the general readiness of the public to affirm ‘gene-right’: 

What this has produced, naturally, is for the progeny of politicians to operate as though they are endowed with some kind of ‘gene right’ to power.  The legitimacy or at least the logic of Sajith Premadasa’s political ambitions can perhaps be explained by the obvious ‘genetic edge’ and an electorate that is confused about monarchy and democracy.  What is important is for Sajith, the United National Party and the nation as a whole to check if the prince-in-waiting has king-credentials on non-genetic counts. 

Five years later, these king-credentials on non-genetic counts were placed before the people of this country. We all know the result — Sajith was roundly defeated. Take away the votes brought in by the Tamil National Alliance and the man merely obtained the UNP’s bloc vote, nothing more. If ‘Premadasaism’ was a factor, one could argue that the more positive elements of Papa Premadasa's legacy (he had many negatives, let us not forget) were embodied not by Sajith but his strongest rival, Gotabaya Rajapaksa. So, while the dynastic element can buttress candidacy in lesser elections, it is unlikely to be sufficient when it comes to a Presidential Election.

How about Chandrika Kumaratunga (daughter of two prime ministers) and Gotabaya Rajapaksa (brother of one of the most popular presidents in the country), one might ask. There’s a difference. Chandrika, in personality, ideology and the company she kept was starkly at odds with her father who was little more than an opportunistic demagogue, and her mother, who was a far more committed nationalist with none of her daughter’s servility to Western powers and their ideological preferences. She was, then, her own woman, more herself than a daughter. 

The circumstances were also in her favor. She broke ranks with the Sri Lanka Freedom Party (SLFP) and returned to seize power, admittedly and essentially citing gene-right, when her mother was ailing and the party needed a charismatic boost. Yes, charisma was something she had, perhaps in her genes but perhaps acquired by herself. Thirdly, the UNP was in decline after President Premadasa got into a tangle thanks to Lalith Athulathmudali and Gamini Dissanayake defecting to the Opposition and initiating impeachment procedures against him. Her stock went up after the assassinations of Athulathmudali and Premadasa in a bloody week at the end of April and beginning of May in 1993. 

How about Gotabaya, then? Would he have won had he not been Mahinda Rajapaksa’s brother? For example, had Dinesh Gunawardena contested under the pohottuwa symbol would he have won? Mahinda’s immense popularity, palpable disenchantment with the yahapalanists (as evidenced by the results of the local government elections on February 10, 2018), a solid party network built over four years and a well-orchestrated grassroots campaign certainly worked in Gotabaya’s favor.  Indeed, such factors are likely to have worked as well for any other candidate, even if he was not a Rajapaksa. 

And yet, in Gotabaya’s case, it cannot be denied that he was his own man. He had and has an identity that is distinct. He came with a reputation of a hard worker, a man intent on getting the job done. He shares the thrust of his brother’s ideological concerns or rather the general drift of popular sentiments that his brother embraced and/or rode to power. Had he not been endowed with such traits, it is interesting to wonder whether it would have impacted the margin of victory. This we can never know for sure, of course. This is why it is useful and perhaps important to consider Sajith Premadasa’s politics and personality in determining the effect of the gene-factor when it comes to a presidential election. 

Admittedly, we don’t have too many cases to work with. One could also consider the performance of people who did not have the gene-edge. Sarath Fonseka was a monumental failure, but then again he contested in a political situation that was extremely favorable to his opponent. Maithripala Sirisena had nothing close to Gotabaya Rajapaksa when it comes to a distinctive identity, reputation as a doer and for getting things done, etc., and yet he won. In other words, there are circumstances in which gene-factors are less relevant or of close to zero worth.    

What did Sajith Premadasa offer that was made of Sajith Premadasa and Sajith Premadasa alone? What about him was not about his father, Ranasinghe Premadasa? Nothing. His entire campaign was a plea for ‘a showing of gratitude’ to his late father. He failed to understand that his father had died too long ago for an entire generation to remember. He failed to understand that his father left a mixed-bag legacy and that if remembered, both good and bad would be considered. He failed to understand that one’s perceptions regarding parents are not necessarily shared by the electorate. Credentials of the candidate matter, he forgot. They matter as much or more than lineage even in a society where family name and histories are taken into account. 

In short, he had nothing new to offer. He credentials as a forceful, innovative man of vision were pretty thin and that would be a generous assessment. His was an I-Me-and-Myself kind of campaign. Ego was what came up and that probably brought him even further down than he might have slipped had he focused on the basics of electoral politics: solid campaigning at the grassroots with an effective party machinery. Of course the last was a handicap delivered to him by poor leadership and therefore was not exactly in his control, but depending absolutely on Papa-Credentials was certainly not going to take him anywhere. 

There’s a lesson here for anyone who think that Daddy-Mummy being in power makes for shoo-in when it comes to the top political office. It just doesn’t work that way unless other factors are aligned in fortuitous ways, as they were in the cases of Chandrika Kumaratunga and Gotabaya Rajapaksa. In a tight race, they probably won’t count.

What probably would count, on the other hand, if for those who believe they are princes or princess in waiting to acquire king-credentials on non-genetic counts for fortuitous circumstances are marked by unpredictability. A would-be-leader would not chance it. He or she would not count on favorable circumstances to materialize. Instead, he or she, would do the hard yards relevant to being a good legislator, cultivate humility, shed Daddy-Mummy diapers, and blaze his or her own path without any fillip from parents. If all this is done, gene-factor in a society that is marked at times by feudal behavior would be an additional advantage. 

Purely in terms of winnability, it can be put down as a simple question that has to be seriously considered by politicians with gene-aspirations: ‘Do I want to be a Gotabaya or a Sajith?’ It would help obtain the diga-palala or the true dimensions of political fortunes. 

This article was first published in the SUNDAY OBSERVER [January 5, 2020]







03 November 2019

Pad-Man and Flag-Man, Daddy and Sonna Boy




Wild promises and pledges are part and parcel of election campaigns. Sajith Premadasa has certainly been quite liberal in dishing out goodies or rather promising to do so.  And yet, the promise of sanitary pads for women does strike a chord.  Makes sense. 

Of course it would be an insult to all women to believe that any woman would vote for someone just because he or she promised free sanitary pads and thereby allow them to save a few bucks. Sri Lanka, moreover, is now officially an Upper Middle Income Country and such trinkets hardly make saving-waves.  

Still.  Good move.  

Baby Premadasa’s pad-pledge reminded me of something Daddy Premadasa did way back when he was President (the most brutal and bloody presidency ever, let us not forget).  Two days before Independence Day, Ranasinghe Premadasa made an appeal to the entire country: fly a national flag! Out of fear or agreement, many did. That’s not what’s interesting. What is remarkable is that the shops were flooded with national flags the very next morning. Someone had already produced the flags. Someone clearly made a killing on Papa Premadasa’s ‘nationalism’.  Aloysius Mudalali was that someone.  

So now, more than 25 years later, we have Baby for Daddy,  feminism (the terms used by his cheering squad of leftists and liberals) instead of nationalism (‘pseudo’  should be the prefix), and Capital Maharaja instead of Aloysius.  Reminds me of the first paragraph of Karl Marx’s ‘The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte’: ‘Hegel remarks somewhere that all great world-historic facts and personages appear, so to speak, twice. He forgot to add: the first time as tragedy, the second time as farce.’  Daddy Boy’s time was tragic (for the people) and Sonna Boy is an unqualified farce!  

Aloysius helped Daddy and the media stations of the Maharaja helped/helps Sonna Boy.  ‘You help me, I help you’.  Same old, same old.    

Nevertheless, the sanitary pad promise is a good one, let me repeat. To paint it as some kind of championing of women, women’s issues and the promise of a feminist president is on the other hand, laughable.  

Two issues. First, who pays? Daddy didn’t use Treasury funds, but he pulled one over the people. Baby Premadasa is no different.  It could have been worse, of course. For example Baby Premadasa’s yahapalana government made and still makes a big song and dance about insuring all school children.  A good thing on the surface, just like the sanitary pads. Who pays? Why, the people!  And who benefits? Why, the private insurance companies and private hospitals! 

And there’s even more to the sanitary pad story than meets the eye.  Baby Premadasa’s government imposed a tax on sanitary pads. Naturally, this makes for increased demand for ‘free pads’. In moves Premadasa Junior, beating his chest and promising the same. Neat, ain’t it?

A petty retailer’s trick, this pad business, nothing more.  Like father, like son. Not surprising.  After all, Baby Premadasa can’t stop talking about Papa’s genes.  He’s clearly inherited his father’s penchant for such tricks.  

Neat.  And cheap. Not very presidential, though.  


13 October 2019

So what's this 'Premadasa Yugaya (Era)'



Sajith Premadasa has promised to take us back to the ‘Premadasa Yugaya (Era)’. He has not said ‘I mean, only the good parts of that time’. I mean, he hasn’t acknowledged anywhere that there was any wrongdoing during his father’s watch or the time when his father was the Prime Minister in J.R.Jayewardene’s government. 
With that statement, however, he rules out any dismissal of any reference to ‘that time’ and the good, the bad and the ugly of it all. 
He had his positives of course. He planted trees. He built houses. He introduced Janasaviya as a recipe for poverty alleviation.  That was, remember, the era of IMF reforms. It was called ‘Structural Adjustment’. That was followed by ‘Structural Adjustment with a human face’ (the ‘human face’ was picked by by Chandrika Kumaratunga in 1994 — ‘Open Economy with a Human Face’). Then came ‘Structural Adjustment with poverty alleviation’. That transition tells a story. In short ‘structural adjustment exacerbated poverty’. Anyway, the man wanted to move out from ‘handouts’.  The program however was politicized. Apparently ‘the poor’ were green, so to speak. Patronage continued to rule. 
Ranasinghe Premadasa quashed the second JVP uprising. Now that’s an interesting story. Let’s recap. 
Rohana Wijeweera and the JVP were, according to the Old Left, creatures of the right wing. Some even said ‘the CIA’. Let’s assume they were not. JR, ‘magnanimously’ released the lot from prison. Thereafter the JVP rhetoric was all about attacking the SLFP and Mrs Bandaranaike. The JVP ‘stole’ some votes, it could be argued, from Hector Kobbekaduwa in the rigged 1982 presidential election (as was the Referendum making a mockery of democracy with 50%+1 vote allowing the UNP to retain a 5/6 parliamentary majority). In 1983, JR sent the JVP underground by claiming the JVP was responsible for the anti-Tamil riots, which as we now know were orchestrated by the JSS (the Jathika Sevaka Sangamaya, the UNP’s trade union arm). 
Was the 88-89 insurrection and all the violence just a natural outcome of Wijeweera being a megalomaniac, though? Let’s trace.
During the time Premadasa was Prime Minister, the UNP government stripped SLFP leader Sirimavo Bandaranaike of her civic rights. Premadasa voted for the draconian 1978 constitution which, according to many, is the main reason for the democracy-deficit that has plagued Sri Lanka for more than 40 years.   In 1980 striking workers were thrown out in their thousands. Several dozens would later commit suicide. Two university students were shot dead in June 1984 (Rohana Ratnayake and Padmasiri Abeysekera). That was a ‘Rathupaswala’ that greens disguised as born-again democrats have chosen to forget. They’ve forgotten other things too. 
In 1987 JR capitulated to Rajiv Gandhi’s plans for the ‘Bhutanization of Sri Lanka,’ a project which gave us devolution as a solution for a misnamed and misrepresented problem (Note: all 9 provincial councils are not dissolved, some have been so for more than two years, but get this: no one is protesting, not even the ‘democracy-fixated’ nor the Eelamists who have reinvented themselves as devolutionists). Premadasa was part of that government. The JVP rode the resultant disenchantment. 
In September 1988 a 15 year old student of Nugawela Central College was shot dead. The ‘kids’ were protesting. The protests were instigated by the JVP. Killed, let me repeat. Now think: what if this happened anytime between 2005 and 2015? Get the drift? Well, it’s more than a drift. 
In the period 1988-90 around 60,000 people killed. Most of it under President Premadasa’s watch. 
We saw proxy arrests, abduction, torture, K-Points (Killing Points), tyre pyres, people burnt alive (including Rohana Wijeweera in the crematorium of the Borella Cemetery), billas (masked informants deployed to identify JVPers who would then be ‘bumped off’ — yes, tens of thousands of Ekneligodas), and vigilante groups (Kalu Balallu, Kaha Balallu, Kola Koti, the People’s Revolutionary Red Army [no less] and Ukussas among other creatures bent on dispensing terror).  We didn’t have ‘white van abductions’ back then. They came in all kinds of vehicles, painted in all kinds of colors. 
There’s more. Censorship. Newspaper content had to be passed by a ‘competent (sic) authority’. So too scripts for stage plays. Entire swathes of news pages came out in black by way of editors protesting these moves. Journalists were killed for the most trivial of reasons. Only Richard De Soyza’s name is remembered and that’s the privilege of social class. 
The JVP and UNP went on a killing spree at a rate unseen in this country since the massacres by the British in the 19th Century. Premadasa came out victor in that battle to decide the most pernicious political brute of the century.    
The JR-Premadasa era saw the worst violations of human rights, all in the name of battling terrorism. No Navi Pillais, Marzuki Darusmans or Yasmin Sookas back then. For Premadasa, after he became President, the LTTE were ‘kid brothers’ (mallilaa). He ordered 600 police officers to surrender to the LTTE. They were all shot dead in cold blood. He armed the LTTE (to fight the IPKF, we were told). India quit and that was a good thing, but those guns were turned on the entire nation and citizenry by the LTTE. 
The ‘Premadasa Time’ was when politicization of the public service reached its height (it’s remained there and that’s a black mark on his successors as well). Cabinet-bloating to ensure parliamentary arithmetic remained favorable was his brainchild. Corruption? Had a free rein. 
That’s the Premadasas Yugaya ladies and gentlemen.      
Sajith Premadasa should talk about these things. Just as his loyalists (rightfully) demand that Gotabhaya Rajapaksa speak of disappearances and murders that took place under his brother’s watch.  
All of that was ‘fascist’. And if Sajith Premadasa wants a repeat, a second-innings, well then we can call his proposal ‘Neo-Fascism’ can’t we? 
Sajith Premadasa wants that past. Does the UNP want it too? Do the people want THAT era back?  
If not, we could limit discussion to the 21st Century, to what was done and remained undone, what was said and left unsaid, the track records of the previous regime and the yahapalana government who crimes of omission and commission about which Sajith Premadasa has been strangely silent these past five years.    
We could talk about creating the conditions for economic development versus stagnation produced by rank incompetence and daylight robbery. We could talk of ridding the country of the terrorist menace and a similar monster with a different name emerging from the fertile soil of pseudo reconciliation. 
We could also talk about the Premadasa Era, if THAT’S what Sajith is all about.  

31 May 2018

The truth and dare of presidents, presidencies and the presidential



If anyone has carefully read the Second Republican Constitution 1978, also known as the JRJ Constitution, he or she would conclude that it’s all about the Executive Presidency. If powers described in the Constitution is likened to a tree, the Executive Presidency is the root, the trunk, the branches, leaves, flowers, fruit and bark.  It was about centralizing power. It was dictatorial or put another way it was a constitution that was made to make dictators.  

So, since 1978 people have ranted and raved about the anti-democratic nature of the JRJ Constitution. ‘Draconian’ was a frequently used descriptive. The call was for its abolition. The promise of the various Oppositions was abolition. It was a promise that was made and forgotten.  

The 17th Amendment sought to prune presidential powers. The 18th effectively restored those ‘draconian’ powers. The 19th was tabled by a political coalition, the yahapalanists, that promised to abolish the Executive Presidency; it made some cosmetic changes, nothing more. Even today, as power vested in offices go, the presidency is where power is resident. It is the president, more than anyone else, who can cause the most amount of change with the least amount of effort. 

The preponderance of power in that office means that the President is directly or indirectly responsible for all wrongdoing. This is why J.R. Jayewardene, Ranasinghe Premadasa, Chandrika Kumaratunga and Mahinda Rajapaksa (D.B. Wijetunga’s tenure was an accident and short) are blamed for all the bad things that happened during their respective presidencies. By the same token, they deserve credit for whatever positives of the relevant periods.  

As such, President Premadasa is applauded for building houses, planting trees and the Janasaviya even as he is blamed for the worst two-year period of terror that Sri Lanka has suffered since Independence, the bheeshanaya of 1988-89. He is blamed even though it was his predecessor who planted its seeds through many undemocratic acts including the scandalous referendum of 1982, the rigging of the 1982 presidential election, attacks on workers and students, abuse of parliamentary majority to pass partisan legislation and so on.  

Kumaratunga’s reign was marked by ‘nothing-done’ and marred by the murder of a newspaper editor, shameless election malpractice and intimidation including the stripping of a woman.  

Rajapaksa’s case is more interesting. He did not have the ‘baggage’ that Premadasa had to contend with, in no small part because his predecessor did not disguise her absolute antipathy.  He started with a clean slate, then.  All wrongdoing during his tenure get credited to him and him alone, either on account of indulgence or else complicity or incompetence.  

His detractors called him a hawk. The ‘hawk’ was accused of purchasing LTTE support to win the election by stopping Tamils in LTTE-controlled areas from voting. The ‘hawk’ chose to ‘talk’ with the LTTE. The ‘hawk’ opted for a military offensive only after the LTTE attempted to assassinate the Army Commander.  During the tenure of the ‘hawk’ what his predecessors promised but could not deliver was achieved. The LTTE was militarily defeated. The war came to an end. 

The ‘hawk’ was by constitutional edict a dictator and he chose to exercise the dictatorial powers vested in his office, for good and bad.  Regardless, the ‘hawk’ by very dint of constitutional reality, deserves credit for defeating the LTTE. Those who vilify him for his excesses and wrongdoing under his watch, and of course benefit from the wiping out of terrorism, do not dare whisper ‘thank you’ even if they add ‘but, you also did this that and the other and therefore we think you are a terrible, terrible person and were a bad President’.  In Sinhala, we call it ‘kuhakakama’, roughly translatable as ‘hypocrisy’.

In other words, you can’t confer the karumaya while denying the urumaya. You can’t vilify and withhold the praise.  That’s hypocritical.  Hypocrisy, however, is one of the most prominent features of our political culture, so we need not be surprised or alarmed. It’s how things are, simply.

Now we have Maithripala Sirisena, who regardless of powers vested in his office decided that he would ‘share power’ with Ranil Wickremesinghe.  The one is politically tied, for better or worse, to the other. Crimes of omission and commission are therefore attributable to both; both the karumaya and the urumaya, although one would be strained to find things that could come under the latter.  

All this is history. Now, we are looking to 2020 or 2019 as the case could be. It’s the season for vilification. It’s hypocrisy season in full bloom.  Amusingly, it is those who ardently called for legislation to combat hate speech (a measure that would outlaw more than one book that certain religious communities swear by, by the way) who are indulging in all this.  

Out: innocent until proven guilty. In: vilification. Out: acknowledgment of accomplishment. In: praising non-performers. Out: brand-building of preferred choice (perhaps on account of there being certain things that are not in the realm of the possible). In: inadvertently raising the profile of the feared opponent through vilification, giving the ‘enemy’ a visibility free of charge. Out: all the ethics associated with Yahapalanaya. In: same old, same old.  Out: looking for a winnable candidate. In: silly attempts to do away with the office since victory is a hopeless proposition.  

Welcome to Sri Lanka, land of liberal double-speak, nation of uncivilized charlatans who are loathe to look at the mirror.  At the end of the day, we still have a made-to-make-dictators constitution.  Let’s just enjoy the spectacle of pots and kettles trying to convince they are white-as-snow spotless.      

Malinda Seneviratne is a freelance writer. malindasenevi@gmail.com. Twitter: malindasene.