Showing posts with label M.A. Sumanthiran. Show all posts
Showing posts with label M.A. Sumanthiran. Show all posts

24 October 2019

Sajith, the TNA and the Eelamist Compact



It is simple now. The Tamil National Alliance (TNA) is reported to have submitted a set of 13 conditions to be agreed upon as the price for supporting a presidential candidate. The Sri Lanka Podujana Peramuna (SLPP) has refused to bite. The Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP) is reported to be willing to agree to a couple. The United National Party (UNP) has maintain a solid silence. 

The UNP candidate has a steep hill to climb as it is and does not need distractions and kakul-maattu of this kind. First of all, the collectives that voted against Mahinda Rajapaksa (and for Maithripala Sirisena) in 2015 are scattered. The JVP offered tacit support but is going it alone this time. The UNP-backed Sirisena rode on hope. Premadasa has to run against disappointment, disillusionment and even anger and resentment. 

The floating vote that helped Sirisena in 2015 may not back Gotabaya Rajapaksa but if ‘change’ is what prompted them then, it is not something they can expect from Premadasa since he is after all the UNP candidate. To be more precise he was and is a minister in the government that gave us broken promises, the Central Bank heist, a compromised national security regime, nepotism, political patronage, corruption, treachery in Geneva etc., etc.  And ruined the economy to boot.  

The much bragged about ‘Business Forum’ organized to drum up support for Premadasa had a full-house audience, but ‘business’ was sadly not their business. The campaign itself has declined to the point where pictures of the Galle Face rally are cropped and issued as ‘massive crowds attending Sajith’s rally in X, Y or Z’.  

He is struggling to capture the non-UNP sections of the Sinhala vote. The results of the February 2018 local government elections indicate that it is more or less the preserve of the SLPP. Groups fielding people like Mahesh Senanayake and Rohan Pallewatte are more likely to win over anti-Rajapaksa voters who are disgusted with the Yahapalana experiment. 

Sajith needs the Muslim and Tamil vote. It won’t be enough to win, but saving-face is victory enough in diminished circumstances. This is where the TNA’s ‘Eelamist Proposal’ (as we should call it) comes into play.  This is where the support of people like Rauff Hakeem and Rishard Bathiudeen and the parties and community they lead come into play.

Hakeem is in hot water. Rishard always was with his bullish ways. Hakeem’s association with the mastermind of the Easter Sunday attacks, the Islamic cleric Zahran Hashim is scandalous on several counts. First the association itself. Secondly, the fact that Hakeem did not disclose all this. Thirdly, having chosen to keep mum Hakeem sits on a Parliamentary Select Committee appointed to look into the attacks, the worst by any self-defined religious group on ‘non-believers’ in this country since bible-toting colonial rulers destroyed temples and kovils. 

And Hakeem, ladies and gentlemen, along with the SLMC has backed Sajith Premadasa. And Sajith for his part, for all his egotistic chest-beating pronouncements and pledges about national security, has not called Hakeem out on this issue. Sajith is cosy sharing the political stage with Zahran’s buddies. It has been noted. It might not be forgotten. 

The TNA’s Eelamist proposals, however, poses the most vexed of the questions for Sajith.  He has said he is not willing to submit to any conditions, but that was a general statement, applicable to anyone and everyone and therefore no one at all simply because the devil is in the details. One has to be specific about such things. If one is to be taken seriously, that is. That’s hard enough as it is in Sajith’s case. His theatrics may tickle the diehard UNP loyalists, but if that’s what it is all about then he achieves nothing more than getting them to the polling booth, something they would probably have done anyway.  

The conditions put forward by the TNA does much more than tickle, though.  Two options: a) accept them and face the ire of every voter who is against separatism and especially those who are well aware of the multiple calamities spawned by such Eelamist posturing for thirty years, or b) reject them and risk losing the Tamil vote.

The North and East, taken as a proxy for the ‘Tamil Vote’ is not a bloc as such. In 2010, Sarath Fonseka obtained 67% of the vote from these two provinces whereas Maithripala Sirisena upped the anti-Rajapaksa numbers (if you can call that) to the tune of 75%. The TNA suffered quite a slide at the last local government election. This time there is a Tamil candidate and a Muslim candidate as well. Whatever votes they get are votes that are most likely to have been cast for Sirisena in 2015. That’s a number that is going to feature as a negative in the Sajith-Register.  The general disappointments of the Tamil voter (promised so much in gay abandon by the Yahapalanists and largely neglected thereafter) should also be factored in.  

Regardless of these elements of the electoral equation, Sajith Premadasa needs to respond to the TNA. M.A. Sumanthiran, after all, has said that the party’s conditions would be presented to all the candidates. Sajith has to have a chit-chat with the TNA. The transcripts of that conversation have to be made public. 

At some point, someone will ask Sumanthiran or some other TNA spokesperson what the party’s position is on Sajith Premadasa. At some point someone will ask Sajith if he has agreed to the TNA’s conditions. If there’s no clarity, people will draw their own conclusions. Sajith Premadasa cannot be opaque on this. He just can’t afford it.  

malindasenevi@gmail.com. www.malindawords.blogspot.com

08 May 2019

Ostriches cannot fight terrorists



Immediately after the LTTE was militarily defeated, the peace-brigade that had for years fought tooth and nail for ‘parity of status’ (i.e. for the LTTE vis-a-vis the Government of Sri Lanka) and insisted, inter alia, that the LTTE was the sole representatives of the Tamils, said ‘the government can now dismantle all military camps in the North and East.’

At first glance, this seemed to be a logical suggestion. After all, there was no military threat now. On the other hand, that logic could be applied to all military camps, which ought to be dismantled. One could go further and argue that the entire military establishment should be done away with. Silly. 

Silliness, however, seems to go hand in hand with such people. If, as they have argued, the LTTE was a product of a history (a tale told selectively and with appropriate twists to justify a narrative that is poor on substantiation, by the way), then what is done or not done in the here and now can have consequences. 

In a terrorist-infested world order, dominated by powers that are not adverse to unleashing terrorism, national security is not a suspendible subject. If there were doubts on this, the Easter Sunday attacks would have laid them to rest.  

And yet, we have seen the Colombo Twitterati (Kolumbians, if you will) and of course those who think they’ll get membership in that exclusive and snooty club by parroting their prejudices repeatedly skirting the issue of terrorism. 

We had Phil Miller of the website ‘Morning Star’ (which is ‘for peace and socialism’ no less!) pointing the finger at Gotabhaya Rajapaksa, following the now tired tokenism of flagging the terrorist. Here’s what he says: ‘There are certainly some Muslims in Sri Lanka who may exhibit extremist tendencies.’ Some? May? Talk about downplaying the most terrible single-day execution of terrorist attacks! 

Let’s forgive Phil. He obviously doesn’t know much. The New York Times and the BBC ought to know better than to conjure the now tired ‘billa’ of Sinhala Buddhist extremism, but then again going by the political persuasions of those who provides information at this end, one need not be surprised.  

There are others less forgivable. Prof Jayadeva Uyangoda, in an interview with the Sunday Observer offers two proposals. The first is to defend democracy and human rights. He explains, ‘Slightly similar to the 9/11 attacks on American and global democracy, the Easter Sunday tragedy could be used by certain sections in Sri Lanka to curtail democracy and bring in an authoritarian form of governance.’ He is correct. 

Here’s the second: ‘Restoration of the institutional balance between the President, the Prime Minister and the Cabinet is vital for Sri Lanka to resolve the political crisis which paved the way for the Easter Sunday tragedy.’ Well, some form of clarity is of course useful, and to that extent this is a sensible suggestion.

Is that it, though? It seems that’s it as far as Uyangoda is concerned. In terms of dealing with the threat, all he has to say is ‘[t]he so-called radicalization of Islam has a unique feature, has associated itself with a global armed insurgency, or a global war,’ and ‘what is necessary now is a global conversation about all religions’ secular role.’  So-called? He’s not sure? Well, a conversation is important and that is taking place in various forms, but Uyan talking to Jehan and sharing insights thus obtained with Victor Ivan and Victor briefing Sumanthiran so that Civil Society can take a cue is hardly a conversation and certainly not something that those who plot attacks such as the one on Easter Sunday will lose sleep over. 

Victor Ivan, writing a guest column for the Daily FT titled ‘Sri Lanka: our of the frying pan into the fire,’ talks about the history of Muslims in Sri Lanka, the political conundrum of a president and premier at loggerheads, throws in the bogey of Sinhala Buddhists (as the villains of the piece, obviously) and glosses over the terrorists and the ideas, ideals, identities and faith they profess and affirmed. All he has to say is that it has ‘caused shock and shame among the Muslim community.’ That’s in all of 2,698 words! At least Jehan Perera, in his initial responses to the attacks (published in international media) was not so verbose in the usual vilification of Sinhala Buddhists. Jehan, though, demonstrated once again that he was all at sea when it comes to identifying threats. Still, one would have expected him to advocate a negotiated settlement with the perpetrators. He did not. Is it because churches were attacked, one wonders!

Sumanthiran, TNA Member of Parliament, speaking at an event organized by people who could be described as Wannabe Kolombians, offers that the Easter Sunday attack is a result of Sri Lanka’s failure to address minority grievances. Yeah right! Is he saying that removing the tokenist privileging of Buddhism from and scripting Eelamist devolution into the constitution would have stopped the terrorists who claim to be doing the work of Allah (and not necessarily delivering the aspirations of all Muslims)? 

‘Civil Society’ had to issue a statement (see ‘We cannot afford a second breach’ in The Island,  May 1, 2019). They were ‘appalled by the carnage.  They are, like Uyan, upset about the President and Prime Minister not being united. Naturally, for most of the signatories were gung-ho about the yahapalana lie. They don’t want another ‘carnage’ but apart from a cursory and dismayed allusion to the need for emergency regulations, they’ve focused primarily on possible vigilante violence.  

We don’t need vigilante violence. That would be a tragedy and would play into the hands of the terrorists. Agreed. But is that what everything boils down to?  

Many such people were and are horrified about elephants being used in peraheras. They were quite vocal about elephants being kept in Buddhist temples. They’ve not been upset about swords being found in mosques. They are not questioning the Minister of Muslim Affairs explaining swords as garden tools. They don’t see the truth. They don’t see the threat.  

They are ostriches. And they want the rest of us to play ostrich too. Such an eventuality would be the closest thing to heaven as far as the ISIS, the NTJ and other Jihadists can experience. 

They were like this with the LTTE too.  Indeed, the LTTE may have been defeated much earlier and much carnage avoided had these people not diverted attention from the matter at hand (defeating the LTTE). Red herrings is what they are all about (when they are not being ostriches, that is). It’s not too hard to figure out that the terrorists will have to be defeated, with or without the ostriches. 


05 February 2019

Provincial Councils and the silence of the federalist ‘lambs’

M.A. Sumanthiran of the Tamil National Alliance (TNA) makes much of caveats in the proposed constitution that makes ‘division impossible’. The call then is for a new constitution where ‘indivisibility’ is scripted in. 


That’s lovely. On paper. Politics doesn’t happen on paper and neither are constitutional proclamations worth the ink they are written on (if you have doubts, think ‘19th Amendment’). 

Loveliness on paper can be misleading. In this instance it is a clear sign to be cautious simply because it is Sumanthiran who is doing the decorations.  Let me elaborate.

A little over a year ago, Prof S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole, in an article titled ‘On wise verbal concessions in the art of negotiations’ published in the Colombo Telegraph, salutes Sumanthiran for being clever with words.  Hoole, the TNA’s nominee to the Election Commission, noted that Sumanthiran had told him privately that ‘problems of negotiation should be approached judiciously without being hung up on words that can be inflammatory’.  

Sumanthiran had pointed to Article 18 of the constitution as an example of this ‘brilliance’: ‘While 18(1) says Sinhalese shall be the official language of Sri Lanka, Article 18(2) brilliantly goes on to subvert it saying that Tamil shall also be an official language. If we had been stuck on objecting to 18(1), Tamils could never have been liberated through 18(2). It is an oxymoron like 18(2) that can make Tamils get powers to take decision on those matters that concern our well-being through participatory governance.’

The problem with Sumanthiran is that he says one thing in one place and something else somewhere else, says something and says something else later. For all his ‘unitary’ posturing, he did state vehemently at the Parliament debate on the interim report of the Steering Committee of the Constitutional Assembly (as reported in the Daily Mirror on November 2, 2017) that the TNA wants a secular and federal Sri Lanka. He has not pointed out, as he did with respect to Article 18, that the non-secular clause (Article 9) is made meaningless by Articles 10 and 14(1)(e).

Anyway, it seems a bit confusing. An indivisible federal state doesn’t sound right, especially when the indivisibility is marketed as keeping the unitary nature intact. Sumanthiran is word-playing here and we don’t need Hoole’s congratulatory observation to know it. 

Federalism comes from the late Latin word foedus, which means treaty, compact or contract. Interestingly, it comes from an older Latin word, fides, which means ‘trust’. Trust is not something we have here, Sumanthiran as Hoole explains unwittingly is not to be trusted, or rather, his words are oxymoronic and deliberately so. 

Politically, a federation refers the coming together (ok, on the basis of an agreement, based again on some degree of trust) of two or more distinct political entities. While we have the problem of Tamil nationalists, wide-eyed liberals (many of whom are rabidly anti-Sinhala or anti-Buddhist) of using demarcation lines that have no basis in history and are not derived from any important geographical factors, there are other issues that rebel against such an arrangement: a) demography (almost half the Tamils live outside the so-called exclusive traditional homelands), b) vast sections of the Eastern Province and considerable territory in the Northern Province are traditional homelands of Sinhalese, c) the archaeological evidence indicates that the North and East constitute the heartland of Buddhism in the island, and d) the alleviation of grievances (shorn of embellishment and exaggeration) does not necessarily require devolution. 

Importantly, the ‘coming together’ of it immediately creates the logic for ‘coming apart,’ never mind ambiguous caveats about indivisibility. We could have court determining that the ‘indivisible’ clause (stand-alone) is subservient to the ‘divisibility’ encrypted in the very definitions of division of power (context). Yes, like the 19th Amendment, where court determined that the power to dissolve is made meaningless by the removal of the power to devolve in the very same piece of paper! 

So we are compelled to suspect that the following are the key components of Sumanthiran’s game plan: 1) ‘Oxymoronize’ the constitution, 2) Get it approved through a referendum, banking on seemingly harmless wording (in isolation), 3) Get the Supreme Court to see it in context and not isolation, 4) a constitutionally federal Sri Lanka, and 5) separation (following the time-tested Chelvanayakam mantra: ‘a little now, more later’). Maybe Sumanthiran will not be around to wave the indivisibility flag by that time or maybe he will be silent and say ‘I simply changed my mind because, as any lawyer would tell you, circumstances alter cases’. Hoole, tellingly observes, ‘words do not matter so long as we get what we need!’ That’s Hoole on Sumanthiran. Need we say more?

We do. 

Why is Sumanthiran and the TNA silent on Provincial Council elections not being held? Why is the Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP) silent? Why are the born-again democrats, candlelight ladies and funded-voices silent? Are elections, in their minds, anathema to them? Are they not important elements of democracy? Is it that they are more camouflaged UNPers than anything else and are hell-bent on saving their political masters/heroes the blushes? 

That’s an aside, by the way. What’s pertinent is that the devolution-voices are dead silent when it comes to the provincial councils. We’ve gone more than a year since term-expiration in relation to three councils and several months in relation to three more. The country hasn’t collapsed. The people have not protested about the relevant representational-deficit.  In short, PCs or no PCs, things are fine. They weren’t needed in the first place (India stuffed them down our throats). They served only politicians and political parties. They were veritable training grounds in crookery for politicians seeking even better pastures. 

We can do without them, Sumanthiran, the TNA, the JVP and the UNP have in their silence and their complicity in the non-holding of election, have proven. The President wants them but let’s not fool ourselves that he believes in the virtues of power-devolution. The same goes for the Sri Lanka  Podujana Peramuna (SLPP). They are looking for legitimacy and political momentum, nothing else. 

What’s clear is that the people are not interested in devolution. As of now, only Sumanthiran is keen on it. All moves for a new constitution, therefore, need to be seen as being key elements of Sumanthiran’s political agenda, and subscription to it by Tamil Nationalists can only be surmised by their silence and tacit agreement. And, in his case, it’s not just any kind of devolution he’s proposing.  He’s going for broke. He’s batting for federalism as a necessary precondition for division. It’s easier, compared to armed insurrection, let us not forget. 

Let us not forget and let us not be swayed by flowery language and assurances made meaningless by a virtually acknowledged strategy of subterfuge. As for provincial councils, it’s high time that the truth is recognized: they never worked and they are not needed. Out with them, and with the pernicious 13th Amendment to the Constitution! 

RELATED ARTICLES

24 January 2019

Oxymoronic Sumanthiran



This (third) version of ‘Yahapalanism’ appears to be Sumanthiran’s baby. That’s Mathiaparanan Abraham Sumanthiran. One might have even said that it’s the TNA’s baby, if one went by a news story where  TNA Parliamentarian and Leader of the Illankai Tamil Arasu Kachchi (ITAK) Mavai Senathirajah was reported to have said ‘at present, there is a joint mechanism in place where discussions are held with the Tamil National Alliance (TNA) prior to Cabinet of Ministers decisions being by the Government.’  

Sumanthiran has since taken to task the relevant media institution. He clarified thus:  ‘The TNA asked that the Government consult with MPs of the area before taking cabinet decisions regarding those areas, and the Government agreed to do so. This is what the Hon. Mavai Senathiraja said. The news report states that he says there is an agreement between the TNA and Government and that no cabinet decisions can be taken without consulting with the TNA! I said that the Tamil areas in the East should also be included in this mechanism of consultation, but the news item says that I said there will be a North East merger!’ We shall return to that claim, shortly. 

In any event, it’s good that he clarified for otherwise, it would mean that the TNA is an authority that sits higher than the cabinet when it comes to decision-making, which among other things would make senior TNA parliamentarian R Sampanthan’s claims to the Opposition Leader’s post rather silly.  

And yet, he was clearly spearheading the moves to reinstate Ranil Wickremesinghe as Prime Minister after he was unceremoniously ousted by President Maithripala Sirisena on October 26, 2018. He called the shots and the calling as well as the shots are captured on camera.  Does that make him de-factor Prime Minister? Close, but we cannot make that claim.

One claim that can be made is that Sumanthran is a crafty operator when it comes to constitutional affairs, if one were to paraphrase a laudatory observation by Prof S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole (see ‘Sumanthiran on wise verbal concessions in the art of negotiations’ published in the Colombo Telegraph in September 2018). The admiration is understandable; Hoole was the TNA’s nominee to the Election Commission. They are misplaced because sleight of hand is pernicious and not a mark of wisdom. 

The article is a comment on Sumanthiran’s ‘C.W. Thamotharampillai Memorial Lecture on September 18, 2018 but Hoole offers an aside: ‘Privately, Sumanthiran once told me that these problems of negotiation should be approached judiciously without being hung up on words that can be inflammatory. He gave the example of the brilliance in Article 18 of the Constitution. While 18(1) says Sinhalese shall be the official language of Sri Lanka, Article 18(2) brilliantly goes on to subvert it saying that Tamil shall also be an official language. If we had been stuck on objecting to 18(1), Tamils could never have been liberated through 18(2). It is an oxymoron like 18(2) that can make Tamils get powers to take decision on those matters that concern our well-being through participatory governance.’

Hoole reports that someone asked Sumanthiran the following questions: ‘Why do you say that federalism is not required? Why are you taking the party against what the people wanted and voted for?’  He then claims that Sumanthiran’s lecture on ‘The extent of federalism today’ was essentially a denial of the the allegations couched in the questions. Hoole makes the argument that Sumanthiran was being smart (or rather, devious) about it the federalist posturing. 

In his response to the fake news item referred to above, Sumanthiran observes the following: ‘[it was] falsely reported that I had stated that with the new Constitution, a separate state would be a possibility. That is completely false, and directly contradictory to what I said! One of the main things I said in that speech was that we should give up the Eelam dream.’

However, Hoole believes that Sumanthiran is ‘hoping for an oxymoron [(like 18(2)]’. He believes that ‘Sumanthiran is gambling on further oxymorons on federalism and the foremost status for Buddhism’ which according to him are necessary ‘to make minorities fell less oppressed and this country more democratic.’ In other words, Hoole is asking the Tamils to understand that Sumanthiran is playing a game, that he’s batting for federalism without using the F-word.  

What Hoole seems to have missed is that Sumanthiran has not balked at using the F-word. Here’s what he said at the Parliament debate on the interim report of the Steering Committee of the Constitutional Assembly (as reported in the Daily Mirror on November 2, 2017: We have very clearly stated that Sri Lanka shall be a secular state, and that Sri Lanka must be federation.’

Let’s observe that the Prime Minister has stated that the status of Buddhism (Article 9) will not be amended in any constitutional amendment.  Let’s note also that Articles 10 and 14(1)(e) effectively negate Article 9, very much like 18(2) making 18(1) meaningless.

What’s important here is that even as he denies federalism, Sumanthiran affirms it. Why? Well, Hoole gives us the explanation: Sumanthiran has a penchant to be oxymoronic and it is deliberate, not an accident. Hoole is stretching the meaning of the word, but we’ll let that pass — the intention is clear. 

In that same speech, Sumanthiran argues for the merger of the Northern and Eastern provinces — so much for his self-righteous posturing on people being mislead with false news!  In that speech, following what has become customary in Tamil nationalist rhetoric, insisted on being for ‘a united, undivided country’. Indeed, he said ‘we have gone one step further and said, an indivisible country even in the future.’

So what? Hoole ends his article with the following key observation on which rests the subterfuge of Sumanthiran and his ilk: ‘Words do not matter so long as we get what we need.’

Hoole knows, as Sumanthiran obviously does, that you can throw in words that negate previous wording. Yes, like 18(1) and 18(2). We saw that in the 19th Amendment with respect to the dissolution of Parliament as well and Sumanthiran, interestingly, had a lot to say in the drafting of the 9th, it is reported.

He knows what’s what, Sumanthiran does. He knows he can say one thing and do something else. He knows that it is substance that will count at the end of the day, not rhetoric and not misleading, grey, vague and weak articles in the constitution. 

He does het his knickers in a twist, though. He got them twisted when he said that Buddhists, as per the doctrine, cannot support Article 9, forgetting that as a Christian, following Matthew 5:39, he should not be in politics, arguing for the redressing of perceived grievances through federalism. Maybe he’s actually read the Gospel According Matthew closer than we think, noting perhaps that 10:34 contradicts 5:39 and ‘wise’ about the fact that there’s a lot in the Old Testament to justify horror and the horrific, even terrorism and terrorists (as the TNA did for decades).  

In this instance, though, we must take cognizance only of one fact: Sumanthiran is a master at subterfuge, a man absolutely lacking in integrity. He’s a good politician in this sense. He knows what he wants. He has the Prime Minister’s ear or indeed, he is in a position to manipulate the Prime Minister or twist his arm. He is counting on a play with oxymorons delivering federalism in a way that sets the stage for separation later as per the Chelvanayakam Doctrine (‘A little now, more later’), for federalism in essence refers to disparate entities coming together, implying that they can, if so desired, come apart.  

Hoole is correct, ‘words do not matter’ if desired outcome is obtained. It is clear what Sumanthiran wants. All the more reason to be wary of his words.

Related articles:



malindasenevi@gmail.com. www.malindawordsblogspot.com

22 January 2019

Sophomoric legislators cannot fix constitutional flaws



Constitutional reforms is a serious business, whether it is an amendment or a new document altogether. Even ordinary bills and acts of parliament are serious affairs. Such things require lawmakers, the Attorney General’s Department, the judiciary and the general public to act with sobriety and responsibility.  

The basic premise of any new piece of legislation is that whatever exists is insufficient or flawed. That, however, is just one reason for attempting correction. It is (too) easy to use the horrendously flawed Second Republican Constitution (of 1978) as an excuse for (any old) amendment. ‘It can’t get worse’ is tired, silly and unethical reasoning for the simple reason that it (indeed!) can (get worse)!

Just think of all the amendments since 1978. Lawmakers didn’t exactly cover themselves with glory in those exercises. The most recent was the 19th Amendment. From draft to legislation makes a case for how not to engage in constitutional tinkering. The Supreme Court shot holes in the draft. The lawmakers did not amend the draft but almost rewrote it, leaving contradictions and grey areas. It was a shortsighted and mischievous piece of legislation, to put it mildly. Let us just mention, in passing, the following: a) presidential powers to dissolve parliament, b) the appointment and removal of the prime minister, c) the notion of a national government to circumvent limitations on cabinet-size, and d) a politician-heavy constitutional council which effectively mangled the idea of ‘independence’ in related institutions. 

Since the Supreme Court determination on dissolution, there’s two documents before Parliament. First, the (new) 20th Amendment tabled by the JVP seeking to abolish the Executive Presidency, and secondly a new constitution, as per a TNA need, based on recommendations by the so-called committee of ‘experts’.  

The merits and demerits of both exercises can be debated. Obviously, the second would make the first irrelevant. But what’s crucial to understand here is the fact that this parliament has proved beyond a shadow of doubt that it is incompetent when it comes to its fundamental purpose — law-making. 

The Parliament made a mess of electoral reform, in effect replacing the existent proportional representation system with another proportional representation system, despite the rhetoric to the contrary! Today, across the political spectrum, people seem to have resigned themselves to reverting to the previous system, which each and every one of them deemed to be flawed, made for thuggery, the movement of vast sums of money and other ills.  

We saw how they went about with the 19th Amendment. The proposed 20th Amendment shows how shortsighted and silly the JVP is, since it seeks the abolition of the executive presidency without accounting for the dangers of such an eventuality given the existence of the 13th Amendment (which moreover was constituted in the most undemocratic manner). 

Now we have the ‘new constitution’ circus. The JVP has opposed it. Sections of the ruling coalition, especially the JHU, has objected to it. The TNA, as expected, whines about people being ‘political’ — as though politics is something absolutely alien to that party! The chances of a new constitution, therefore, are slim. That’s not something bad, even though the current constitution simply cries out for replacement. ‘Not bad’ because we just cannot trust this Parliament to do anything right regardless of intentions, which too they have taught us not to trust.  

However, there is the danger of this utterly sophomoric set of legislators hoodwinking the masses by leaving intact articles whose repeal could spell trouble while surreptitiously inserting others that make those very same articles irrelevant (just like the articles pertaining to dissolution in the 19th Amendment). They can retain terms and notion (e.g. ‘unitary’ and ‘foremost status of Buddhism’) and throw in things that make them meaningless. They can’t make decent laws but they seem to be experts at the indecent end of things.  

The question is simple: considering that this set of parliamentarians have demonstrated incompetence, proved they are either hooligans or have directly or indirectly sanctioned hooliganism, that electorally, the UNP, SLFP and JVP (making up a majority) have lost their standing and even legitimacy in the eyes of the voting public, and have abused power in numerous ways, can we and should we trust them with tinkering with the constitution? The answer is pretty obvious: No!  

The constitution needs to be changed, yes, but not by these people. We just cannot trust them to do anything right. We cannot trust them to ensure that the sovereignty of the people is kept intact. 

We can trust them to do just the opposite. 

RELATED ARTICLES


malindasenevi@gmail.com. www.malindawords.blogspot.com

05 July 2018

A poser for the self-righteous: how about a Tamil or Muslim presidential candidate?



Yahapalanists, i.e. those advocating yahapalanaya or good governance, as per their own articulation of the term, are for equality, justice, truth, transparency, accountability and other such lovely things. Again, as per their rhetoric, they abhor injustice, corruption, nepotism, graft, misuse of state resources and abuse of authority, among other things. 

Yahapalanaya, in the way the term has been used by its advocates, is not just about good governance. Yahapalanist rhetoric has waved many other flags, with noble objectives beautifully embroidered on them. They have called for a separation of religion and state, regularly rant and rave against assertion of identity (usually limited to those by  Sinhalese and Buddhists) and insist that Sri Lanka is a multi-ethnic and multi-religious country (carefully omitting relevant numbers and percentages).  As such we have to take ‘yahapalanaya’ as a political concept that embraces all these things and it is the broader definition that we use here. 

Yahapanlanists, in the sense the term is used here, refers to all those in the United National Party (UNP), the Sri Lanka Freedom Party (SLFP) and other parties who directly or indirectly backed Maithripala Sirisena’s presidential campaign and all individuals and organizations opposed to the previous regime.

Alright. Various key Yahapalana spokespersons have often dismissed and vilified their political rivals, in particular key personalities in the Joint Opposition and the Sri Lanka Podujana Peramuna as well as those in organizations claiming to represent Sinhalese and Buddhists. They have been called racists and chauvinists. They are said to be out of touch with the times, accused of living in the past and being obstacles to progress.  

This is not a defense of those accused thus. The ululation notwithstanding, there is truth in some of these charges at least with respect to some of those charged. The issue here, however, is about the integrity of the accusers, or put another way, the yahapalanist worth of the yahapalanists. In short, the question is, ‘do/can they put their money where their mouths are?’

Now both the parties led by the President and Prime Minister, the SLFP and UNP respectively, have a long history of positions taken than yahapalanists would not hesitate to call chauvinistic, racist, extremist, intolerant etc. These parties have spawned many leaders who have in their operations turned the basic premises of yahapalanaya on their proverbial heads and kicked them in their proverbial behinds to boot.  Furthermore, it is not as though the current lot are squeaky clean when it comes to upholding the yahapalana articles of faith.  Let us be generous, however. 

Let us assume, for arguments sake, that the yahapalanists are actually abiding by yahapalana principles. Assuming thus, among all litmus tests one can theoretically conduct to ascertain integrity with respect to the noble objectives articulated by them in the run up to the January 2015 election there is one that I believe would demonstrate beyond a shadow of doubt their commitment to the yahapalana cause: the ideal profile of a Yahapalana presidential candidate? 

If, as they claim, the JO, SLPP and other non-yahapalanist political groups are ‘majoritarian’ cannot they, the yahapalanists, being the righteous, noble and exemplary political actors on the Sri Lankan stage, be they members of political parties or not, argue for a presidential candidate who is the antithesis of whoever a JO/SLPP-led coalition puts forward (i.e., a racist in the eyes of yahapalanists)?

No, it would not be enough for such a candidate to be a Sinhalese or a Buddhist uttering yahapalana terminology at every turn. They should go the whole hog. Get a non-Buddhist who is also a non-Sinhalese as the candidate.  If they don’t, it could mean that they are playing ethnic-politics that is a far cry from yahapalana ideals. 

Let’s take Ranil Wickremesinghe. His religious affiliations are not clear, but there’s no doubt that he is a Sinhalese. Sajith Premadasa is a Sinhala Buddhist.  Ravi Karunanayake is a Christian, but he’s a Sinhalese. Sinhalese are out, so let’s not labour the point with other potential UNP candidates. Among those who are neither Sinhalese nor Buddhists, the most senior is Kabir Hashim. How about Kabir as the UNP’s next presidential candidate? Has any yahapalanists stopped to even consider him? 

It doesn’t have to be someone from the UNP, after all that party has not fielded a candidate at a presidential election since 2005. The UNP can find someone from outside the party system (e.g. Sarath Fonseka in 2010) or back a candidate from another party (e.g. Maithripala Sirisena in 2015). And the UNP need not worry if the political history of the particular candidate being embarrassing either due to wrongdoing (e.g. Fonseka, who was called all kinds of names by UNP stalwarts) or association (e.g. Sirisena). What counts is agreement on a program, never mind ability to deliver or lack of political will (e.g. Sirisena).

I am sure there are exemplary Tamils and Muslims untainted by political affiliation and endowed with the kind of integrity and aloofness from the dust and grind of ideological/political engagement. Can the yahapalanists come up with some names? Better yet, will they sweat and toil for such a person to be nominated as a candidate who runs against ‘the racists’?   

Let’s assume that they want someone who is already ‘political’ (considering the utter failure of the Fonseka experiment); let’s lower the bar. Let’s just say ‘ok’ to any Tamil or Muslim politician, regardless of his/her track-record ideological or political.  

R Sampanthan is the most senior politician in today’s Parliament, along with John Amaratunga, the latter not relevant since he’s a Sinhalese.  Sampanthan had his black marks thanks to circumstances forcing his party to be an LTTE mouthpiece and before that for subscribing to Appapillai Amirthalingam’s chauvinism, such blemishes can be ignored. He’s not disgraced himself as the Leader of the Opposition. Moreover on countless occasions Sampanthan has spoken for all citizens and not just the Tamils.   

Age is not on his side, obviously, for he’s 85.  How about M.A. Sumanthiran, then? The occasional Tamil nationalistic rhetoric aside, Sumanthiran has also, like Sampanthan, spoken for all citizens, articulating their concerns and critiquing policies that could have a detrimental impact on them. How about a Sirisena-like deal, where Sumanthiran is nominated as the ‘Yahapalana Candidate’ with all yahapalanists backing him?  Would the main ‘yahapalana party’ go along? That’s the UNP, by the way, which added a ‘yahapalana’ tag to the party name when contesting as a coalition in August 2015.  How about Rauff Hakeem?  He’s been embraced by the UNP and the SLFP at different times. Arumugam Thondaman?  

Would all this shock the yahapalanists? Would they say I’m being mischievous and just trying to tease yapalanists to find someone who is unlikely to win?  Well, the fact of the matter is, either you are idealistic or else you are abusing idealism. You can’t be a yahapalanists who is willing to bend the yahapalana yardstick, surely?  

Let’s hear it from them.  Dear yahapalanists, would you go with a candidate whose choice will do justice to your multi-ethnic, multi-religious rhetoric or would you not? 

05 November 2017

The Mangala-Sumanthiran bluff on secularism



Mangala Samaraweera, in supporting the report submitted by the Steering Committee on constitutional reform, called for a constitution that ‘will help our nation put its past behind for good and move forward with renewed hope.’  On the face of it, this is a positive statement.  

Mangala’s speech also alluded to the Sathara Brahma Viharana or the four divine abodes, metta, mudita, karuna and upekkha (oving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity).  

There’s been a lot of allusions to the Buddha’s docrtine of late.  M.A. Sumanthiran (TNA) has argued for the repealing of Article 9 of the constitution which states “The Republic of Sri Lanka shall give to Buddhism the foremost place and accordingly it shall be the duty of the State to protect and foster the Buddha Sasana, while assuring to all religions the rights granted by Articles 10 and 14(1)(e).” 

He has rightfully stated that he, not being a Buddhist, ‘cannot be told that I [he] am [is] second class in this country.  He argues further that support for Article 9 is ‘an indefensible position for the Buddhists to take.’  

It is telling that Sumanthiran is silent about Articles 10 and 14 (1)(e) while make Article 9 nonsensical.  That said, if Article 9 is ineffective, it should go or else Articles 10 and 14 (1)(e) should go.  A third alternative would be to reformulate these articles to make Article 9 effective.  

The inconsistency with Buddhist philosophy would remain, however.   The politics of this whole story ties up with Mangala’s dump-history call.  It is not innocent and neither is it progressive. 

First of all, history, whether we like it or not, bears upon the present and future.  Constitutions have not, do not and will not fall from the sky.  Societies and cultures are wrought over time.  They are not cast in stone of course and are necessarily altered over time, for better or worse.  

Dumping history is mischievous because the past has seen violent and bloody persecution which cannot and should not be forgotten.   One notes that neither Samaraweera or his political friends have clean histories and neither are they ready to do the forgive-and-forget of past wrongs perpetrated by political opponents.  They are right in the middle of a revenge game, as were their predecessors.  

More seriously, Sumanthiran is a Christian, and his religious community has had it good for centuries at the expense of Buddhists and Hindus.  Asking Buddhists to act as though they have achieved one of the four levels of enlightenment is a a bit much, especially when it is a call made by someone who cannot claim to be adhering to the Christian doctrine to the letter.  

Sumanthiran, for example, could read Matthew 5:39: “You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye and tooth for tooth.’ But I tell you not to resist an evil person. If someone slaps you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also; if someone wants to sue you and take your tunic, let him have your cloak as well.”  

If, then, the Sinhalese and Buddhists have done him or his community (Tamils and Christian) wrong, he should grin and bear.  He could also read further and encounter Matthew 10.34 (or read back and find the many examples where violence is advocated in the Old Testament): “Do not assume that I have come to bring peace to the earth; I have not come to bring peace, but a sword.” He could use this to call for armed insurrection or justify it, as his party and its constituent political groups did for many years.  

If you think Sumanthiran is a babe in the woods, consider the following section of the speech he made at the 14th ITAK Convention: 

“We remember the Tamil youth who sacrificed their lives in armed struggle, which they resorted to on the failure of their peaceful struggle for the political rights and freedoms of their people.” 

So if you want to dump the past, it either means that you find history uncomfortable due to the complicity of your faither or its adherents in genocide and ethnic cleansing or you really don’t have much of a past to talk about.  

There are other pernicious subtexts to this dump-history theory.  The advocates don’t want history dumped, but want only certain parts of it dumped, in this instance the ‘Buddhist’ part of it. 

If you want to put the past behind, you have to acknowledge that this past included Tamil chauvinism in the form of the Vadukkoddai (Batakotte) Resolution, the twisting of myth into history, fiction into fact, the use of lines arbitrarily drawn by the British as borders of so-called ‘Historical Homelands’ and the attendent attempt of land-theft.  

Is Sumanthiran or Mangala talking about this past?  Are they demanding that fiction was a key element of this past, that it should be called as such, that it should therefore be dumped and along with it the whole devolution-thesis (for reconciliation, equality, respect etc) should be scrapped?  No, they are not saying all this.  They are not advocating accordingly either.  

If Sumanthiran and Mangala want ‘change’ and want to dump the past and ‘move forward’ then all legislation at odds with notions of ‘equality’ or which supersede general laws pertaining to freedoms should go.  

Why is it that Sumanthiran and Mangala are silent on the Muslim Marriage Laws, the Thesavalamai Law and the Kandyan Marriage Laws?  Why don’t they visit Article 12 of the Constitution (which speaks of the Right to Equality)?  How is it that these individuals, who argue for a secular state, do not see that the state IS religious and not on account of Article 9 [which, as we said, is negated by Articles 10 and 14 (1) (e)]?  Why do they not speak a word about religious holidays?  Why don’t they note that ‘Buddhist holidays’ were reduced from 49 to 13, while there are 54 Christian holidays, 3  Hindu holidays (sadly, one might add, given all that’s being said about equality), and 3 Muslim holidays supplemented by the equivalent of 13 work days (for Friday prayers) as well as lenghty leave options (four months and ten days for Muslim women in the event of the husband dying and three months in the event of a divorce)?  

These come under ‘customary law’.  However, custom, by definition is about history.  It is about the past.  It affirms culture and religion.  If you want to dump the past, you can’t keep these things intact.  But Sumanthiran and Mangala are quiet about such things. Why?

Why?  Because they are not innocent.  Because their intentions are not pure.  Because they are playing selective-politics with the past, present and future.  

For those who love to bash Buddhists, often quoting the Buddha, let me recommend that they try a bit of self-reflection, you know, ‘be a bit Buddhist yourself’ kind of exercise.  Check the material your walls are made of.  The chances are they are made of glass.

So, to conclude, let’s go secular.  Let’s go the whole hog.  No more religious holidays.  No more Poya days.  No special hours off work for prayers.  No Christmas.  Let the ‘weekend’ be shifted to any two consecutive days barring Sunday and Friday.  And let there be no state subsidies for any religious schools including pirivenas.  

And while they thus reflect, let them also note that in officially non-secular states and even in many ‘secular’ states, particularly those that have Christian or Muslim majorities, there are no holidays for other faiths.  Let them note, also, that perhaps it is the Buddhist character of this society that has permitted the religious freedoms even to the point of privileging other religious communities. 


Sumanthiran states, “a Constitution that gives a particular religion the foremost place cannot be a Constitution that treats all of its citizens as equals.”  He is correct.  Let him apply this logic to every letter of the 1978 Constitution and it’s 19 Amendments.  He could do the relevant perusing with his ardent fellow-traveler in the matter of constitutional reform, Mangala Samaraweera.